Hisense and TCL will this fall each start shipping a line of low-cost 1080p HD sets with Roku’s proven and successful net-top box technology built-in. But they will not be UHD sets.
Make or buy is the question that makers of hardware have asked for years. That’s true for the smart TV technology that goes into TV sets; Sony, Samsung and LG have developed (made) their own. LG went so far as to buy a failed software division called WebOS from HP to control its smart TV destination.
Google tried and failed once at developing smart TV technology ‘ the infamous Google TV ‘ and is trying again with one called Android TV. It, like Roku, wants to supply its smart TV technology to makers of TV sets ” and other devices such as Net Top Boxes.
The Roku technology is a different kettle of fish from Android TV because its technology is proven. It has an estimated 44% of US Net Top sales compared to 26% for Apple, according to Parks Associates. Roku has a couple of features that provide some unique selling points. Most importantly, it has lots of OTT sources ‘ over 1,700 at last count ‘ including all the popular ones such as Netflix, plus many specialty sources.
The Roku technology also integrates local TV channels. When an over-the-air antenna is plugged in, Roku looks for local channels that can be received and creates an ‘Antenna’ list for them to be selected in addition to its many OTT services.
There is no ‘input’ or ‘source’ button on the Roku-based TV sets’ remotes because all devices, such as a Blu-ray players are icons on the sets’ home screens. It’s a feature that Samsung has on its newest UHD sets although there is a source button on the remote functions as it does on other TV sets.
Both companies’ Roku-based TV sets have dual band Wi-Fi. TCL and Hisense are also different. Both are based in China and manufacture TV sets on a grand scale and so can price their sets low. TCL is the world’s third-largest maker of TV sets and Hisense is the sixth.
Hisense has not pre-set retail prices of its TVs but expects the Roku-based sets to sell for less than a comparable separate TV and Roku box. The Hisense sets are expected to start shipping in September.
TCL’s Roku-based sets will sell for:
32-inch 32FS4610R with 720p $229
40-inch 40FS4610R with 1080p $329
48-inch 48FS4610R with 1080p $499
55-inch 55FS4610R with 1080p $649
Those are attractive prices for TVs that have Roku and its 1,700 sources of videos included. All four of the TCL HDTVs are available for pre-order now and are scheduled to ship by the end of September.
The low prices for these and other 1080p HD smarts TVs are one of the barriers that makers of UHD sets must overcome. It can only be overcome with lots of ‘must see’ UHD content shows ‘ preferably sports, but DirecTV said it may be 2016 before it can start UHD broadcasts of ‘live TV’ and the wireline pay TV services are not even talking about it. Currently, the only UHD suppliers are OTT services.
Haier, the third major Chinese maker of TV sets, has yet to be heard from as to whether or not it’ll embed the Roku technology.
The big disadvantage of building smart TV technology into the TV sets is that although you can add OTT services and update the software, the set makers cannot upgrade the hardware ‘ say from hardware assisted H.264 decompression to HEVC or HDMI 1.4 to HDMI 2.0. That can only be done by replacing the TV. That means the new Roku-based sets from Hisense and TCL can never be UHD TVs.
However, you can’t fault TCL and Hisense for buying proven smart TV technology for their TVs instead of developing and maintaining their own, especially because they are far removed from the North American and European markets.
Neither Roku nor any other maker of net tops and smart TVs, except Apple, can offer direct access to Apple’s very popular iTunes OTT service.
What we’re most interested in is when the China-based set makers will launch Roku-based UHD TV sets because surely those are coming. All of which leads to the overwhelming question: What will Apple do? ‘ with both its Apple TV Net Top that has now reportedly fallen far into second place in market share to Roku’s and Apple faces an onslaught from other net top technology such as Google’s Chromecast, Amazon’s and TV sets that will have Google’s Android TV technology and also with Apple’s always imminent but never launched Apple TV set. Apple is unlikely to allow a maker of TV sets embed Apple TV as Roku is doing with TCL and Hisense.
All we can say, with some degree of certainty, is that future Apple TV net tops and Apple TV sets, will have to be UHD capable with excellent up-conversion technology plus all the technology that UHD requires such as HDMI 2.0 and HEVC, technologies that are becoming common on most TV sets. The Apple TV set will also need a new user interface to handle the scores of sources that consumers demand and the right to distribute some if not most pay TV channels.
Apple also needs to combine linear TV and OTT sources into one user interface and programming guide. Apple said the interface should be content-oriented, meaning offering specific titles up for the viewer to browse through, rather than app or channel oriented, as net top interfaces and TV guides are today. If it does this Apple could be the first to bridge the gap between linear TV and OTT. This is a sorely needed feature for the modern viewer, who must switch between inputs to find something to watch ‘ unless the viewer has a TiVo, which already combines OTT apps and linear TV, plus DVR recordings all in one interface.