Under the title of “Broadcom Powers the Gigabit Era of DSL,” this week Broadcom announced its fully fledged and 100% committed entry into G.Fast chips, a market that it has traditionally dominated for years. It clearly wants to dominate it through the next generation despite having more opposition this time around.
The announcement was scheduled, as so many were this week, to coincide with the Broadband World Forum in Amsterdam. But while Broadcom may have dominated the chip supply to this market for years, in each generation there is a wild card, a start-up that either gets there first or gets there early and carves out a noticeable segment of the market for themselves.
In VDSL2 this was Ikanos, which took an early lead, but in this instance it is the Israeli Sckipio which got in two weeks ahead of Broadcom, claiming it had the first G.Fast chipset for both CPE and distribution points, announcing it at the Broadband Taiwan conference. Both companies are anticipating a standard which won’t be ratified for another two months.
There are subtle differences in the announcements – the Sckipio offering is in two chips one for CPE devices and another for the exchange which can each support 4 of these chips and are sold in clusters of 4 chips to support a total of 16 G.Fast subscribers. The impression we got was that the central office box with 4 chips in it could support 16 G.Fast lines or 64 vectored lines, which we took to be VDSL2 lines, which in backhaul terms is roughly the same bandwidth.
Broadcom has done something similar with a two chip central office solution using the BCM65200 DSP with a BCM65900 analog front end and a home gateway SoC, the BCM63138. In this instance Broadcom says that its two chip combination can support 36 lines of VDSL2 or 6 lines of G.Fast. Presumably it would also be possible to engineer devices with multiples of these numbers and although Broadcom said very clearly that no other announced chip can support both VDSL2 and G.Fast in the same cabinet, we get the impression that Sckipio can certainly do that too.
Broadcom also made claims to better power efficiency, but did not put a number on its power use, while Sckipio talked actual power levels at 1.5W per line.
In terms of design wins Sckipio said that Lantiq would use the Israeli chip in its EASY330, as the industry’s first G.Fast reference design for a residential home gateway. Lantiq then added its own 802.11ac WiFi, gigabit routing, gigabit Ethernet switch and carrier grade VoIP to the reference design.
A handful of other equipment makers backed Sckipio such as Suttle, XAVi, VTec and Zinwell, but it is the big broadband implementers like Alcatel and Huawei that will swing the market. Historically Alcatel has used VDSL2 chips from Broadcom and we have no reason to suppose it won’t this time, except that recently it took a strategic investment in Ikanos. Huawei’s G.Fast trials have all been conducted with specially built FPGAs.
Interestingly Broadcom managed to get Swisscom to say in its release that it will be installing Broadcom G.Fast and VDSL2 chips throughout its network, but without saying which implementer this is with. We understand that each implementation can be different and operators can sometimes choose the chips first and tell the implementation partner what it wants in its equipment. But even, so those implementers usually prefer working with one chip or another. Swisscom only has about 1.8 million broadband customers and chose both Huawei as prime contractor and Alcatel as the equipment supplier, in contracts awarded in February 2013 and February 2014 to prepare for vectored DSL of all types including G.Fast. It could be that Huawei got the contract and it was then thrown out in favor of Alcatel, or that the G.Fast boxes (and routers) are to be supplied by Alcatel with Broadcom chips in them, and stuck on fiber to the curb that was installed by Huawei. If that IS the case, then both of the largest broadband suppliers in the world will be immediately up to speed on Broadcom chips.
Alcatel put out a release this week also timed to coincide with Broadband World Forum, saying it now has 12 G.Fast trials with Austria Telekom’s A1 which we mentioned last week, BT and Orange and another 8 to start between now and the end of the year. That of course only adds up to 11 so either it has its math wrong, or there is another trial that has started that it cannot mention as yet – oh yes that might be Swisscom.
Interestingly Huawei was given as the contractor for the BT trial, and now Alcatel seems to be claiming it, perhaps because, as at Swisscom, much of the equipment provided was from Alcatel, and Huawei has contributed the rest.
Given that AT&T will move slowly, but that it is known to love Broadcom chips and Alcatel installations skills, it could easily transpire that the early ground made by Sckipio is eaten up in tier 1 contracts destined for Broadcom – potentially AT&T, BT, Swisscom, Orange, Belgacom, A1 in Austria would lead these off. It would need some level of breakthrough in China and other regions of Asia Pacific, if Alcatel is to mount a global challenge , but it has managed this in the past.
The truth is that we are seeing operator trials way ahead of where they usually are in prior broadband technology generations, and we get the impression that many European operators are up against it, in the sense that Cable with DOCSIS 3.O and 3.1 is surging ahead. They look like they will be moving to G.Fast and Vectored VDSL2 simultaneously based on a tiered broadband offering, almost skipping a technology generation, depending upon respective pricing. In prior telco broadband environments, where the homes are as close to the central office as they are, and one technology simply offers more speed than the previous one over the same distance. In those the cost of the new chips soon approached the price of the previous generation as volumes grew and one generation replaced the other.
But as we move from the central office to the street cabinet, and then closer still to a new routing point a few hundred yards or less from each home, there is a fiber building cost that needs to be shared among the higher speed broadband layers. That suggests that this has to become a user choice – Do you want cabinet based VDSL2 speeds or shorter loop VDSL2 speeds or G.Fast speed? And that implies graduated pricing, from 100 Mbps up to 1 Gbps service.
Broadcom’s new gateway SoC offers data rates in excess of 1Gbps using 106 MHz of spectrum and supports what Broadcom calls Gigabit dual-band concurrent Wi-Fi which we take to be both 802.11n combined with ac, plus multiport Gigabit Ethernet and multiline VoIP.
It uses a 1 GHz dual-core ARM Cortex A9 processor with additional offload engines built into the SoC including a dedicated routing accelerator, and has support for attachment to high performance NAS disk drives and is already in volume production – which means Broadcom could have told us about this months, if not years ago and has been telling operators and equipment vendors about it for perhaps 12 months.