A few weeks back someone asked us at Faultline to say which of the pay TV/Broadband mergers that were proposed, which should not go ahead, and we ranked them in order – Liberty Global – Ziggo in the Netherlands would distort the market the most, so was the worst; Comcast-Time Warner Cable was next and AT&T DirecTV really wasn’t that bad in anti-trust terms, we said.
But there are other lines of thought going through the air and we have to be flexible and think outside the box. The Liberty Global deal is a concentration of both pay TV and broadband into majority market share, with broadband just about 50%, and pay TV much higher. If these markets were going to stay the same, then that deal should not have been allowed and we still feel it should have been firmly crushed.
The reason it wasn’t, was that someone at the European Commission saw an opportunity to strike a blow for Network Neutrality. This is strange because in the European Union the Commission has full control of this aspect of law and has the power to issue a Directive on Net Neutrality. A Directive is an edict with a timescale on it, by which time each country must enact a law to protect net neutrality. It did this on copyright and could easily do so on Net Neutrality and has said it will if it needs to.
No court can say that the Commission is over-reaching itself, except the European Court of Justice and its constituent parts such as the General Court. And they can pick and choose their cases, rather like the US Supreme Court, or delegate to lower courts. We know of no instance in the 40 years we have been following this where a Commission ruling was kicked upstairs successfully, and the only one we can remember was Microsoft going to the General Court (then called the Court of First Instance) to appeal its anti-trust verdict. It got nowhere.
So there really was no need to strike a blow for network neutrality in Europe, while there very much IS such a need in the US, where US courts routinely strike down rulings by the FCC. This is because the nature of the FCC is as a regulator and the European Commission is in charge of legislation and treaties. They have different roles.
The Commission is really trying to sponsor competition throughout its operator markets – telephony, both fixed line and cellular; broadband and pay TV, not to mention broadcasting. But the current thinking tends to be that there need to be less silos in each country – why doesn’t Canal Plus in France compete with Sky in the UK – and more Europe wide based organizations that fight on all fronts.
Perhaps it is right and Europe will only ever be competitive on a global basis if some Europe wide champions can be created. In the past a single country could not have a dominant supplier, but we are seeing this change to a situation where as long as that supplier can be a force for good across the Europe-wide landscape, then the Commission has less problems with local dominance than it used to.
Shift to the US and we see a very different landscape. Comcast really will only be reaching 30% of US pay TV customers, not 65% as in the Netherlands, and by defining pay TV in the Netherlands more widely, and including cellular video and OTT services like Netflix, and cheap DTT services, and with the arrival of Vodafone into the video market, the Commission believes it can justify the creation of a monopoly in old pay TV markets, as long as it protects the newer markets. The letter of the European law has been smashed here, to support the spirit of what the future law might be.
But Comcast has been at 30% before. And the non-overlapping argument that cable companies have (because they are rarely given leave to overbuild) supports higher concentrations of broadband, than pay TV. In the Netherlands this would be around 50%, turning broadband largely into a duopoly. The Commission thinks that’s not a problem because of unbundling laws, and sees the future of broadband in fiber and knows there are some smaller businesses pushing fiber. But the truth is that as broadband becomes a commodity, it is the service differentiation above basic broadband that creates wealth – as long as net neutrality holds. Perhaps the Commission would argue a neutral internet is more important than Broadband competition.
The US has exceptionally poor broadband competition, with many regions having a single supplier and most of the US with only two – one cable and one telco. Usually that is hardly a choice at all, and US telcos have been losing the war for broadband for the past 7 years, hand over fist – not a single new broadband line has gone to a telco during that time, except where it replaces one that has been lost. Growth of telco broadband has been zero. In other words AT&T broadband plus Verizon broadband in fixed lines is the same number that it was in 2007, with all the growth going to cable companies. So where there is telco and cable, it is a virtual monopoly anyway for the cable company because of the speed advantage. That may change with G.Fast and fiber, but so far it hasn’t.
So really the FCC and Justice Department cannot agree the Comcast deal on the same basis. There is a lot of consolidation needed in European markets in broadband and pay TV due to national silos. There is far less required in the US. There is more competition in Europe on broadband, there is almost none in the US. There is little belief in the US that Net Neutrality is sacred among operators, whereas in Europe is could be made a law at the drop of a hat.
But the US has done things by consent decree time and time again and it can do this now on the Comcast TWC deal, and we mentioned this last week. Strangely there is a lot of public sentiment in the air which is against Comcast and TWC – two of the laziest customer care organizations on the planet – becoming a single entity.
This week for instance the head of the Senate Judiciary Committee has asked Comcast to permanently ban Internet fast lanes. Now that would leave Comcast constrained by Net Neutrality and AT&T not constrained, because remember, it is AT&T which is offering fast lanes on wireless broadband.
Senator Patrick Leahy has raised this in a letter to Comcast executives asking for the Internet not to become a two-tiered system of haves and have-nots, controlled by a small number of corporate gatekeepers.
In a sense that’s exactly what everyone wants. A small number of gatekeepers who CANNOT make the rules about who can have what on the internet – just bit carriers, a little like electricity companies, who cannot tell you what to power with that electricity.
Another consideration is that each of the exponents in these three deals have a different history of ignoring consents that they have given in the past, and some companies, the worst of which is Comcast, have then gone on to abuse these.
The fact that Comcast is a serial abuser of past promises means that any consents it gives will have to be policed until the practice becomes ingrained. So asking Netflix to pay for connection upgrades should not require an investigation by the FCC, someone on the ground working inside Comcast, acting as an expert, not an advisor, but who cannot be ignored, should have had the right to say “No way,” to the Comcast management. Much the same should be done around blocking OTT video rivals or giving away the bandwidth needed to carry your own services. We cannot see Comcast ever giving consent to a deal like that, but there are precedents in the past both in the US and in Europe.
In other words the price you have to pay for making a market like broadband slightly less profitable, is to allow less companies to own MORE of it.
But when you look at the moves that Comcast has made over the years, it has shown it wants to shift up the eco-system by getting into content, as denoted by its purchase of NBC-Universal and its previous failed bid for Disney. It doesn’t want to slide down the margin tree into a commoditized broadband market. But overnight if every Comcast customer dropped its pay TV plan, and paid only for broadband, each customer one would pay substantially more at least for that broadband. Broadband without TV costs about $5 to $7 more, than broadband with TV and the first options you see in Xfinity internet are with 10 or 45 TV channels bundled in.
There is no commoditized broadband market in the US and there is no prospect of one. However a consent decree in order to allow the merger might include an agreement to there being no bundling of TV services with broadband for one price. It might include the disposal of even more customers than there are on offer, in order to more rapidly create another cable rival closer to the size of Comcast. It should include promises that Comcast is the odd one out when it comes to bullying Netflix and co, in that it cannot impose a connection sanction. An additional condition might be that when it offers OTT video services, the broadband element must come out of its cap.
Now put yourself in that position. If, in order to get agreement for the merger, Comcast has to hobble itself in this way, would it agree to it? Our take is that it would, but that it would renege on those terms, as it has before on similar agreements. Which is why the deal, if allowed has to be with a policing arm that has access to Comcast internal thinking and decision making. And if that exists, what else might emerge about its internal behavior and that may make Comcast senior management walk away from the deal. So there are two stumbling blocks, either the deal is simply stopped, or terms imposed are so deleterious that Comcast changes its heart.
Comcast can achieve better profitability by spending the same funds set aside to buy TWC on overseas cable operations, content or OTT investments of its own.
Finally, it is likely that The AT&T DirecTV merger would escape any censure and most imposed conditions, but it may also win AT&T very little in terms of improved profitability. It was entered into in order to “cover” the move by Comcast, and while it may find itself allowed, it may still end up not making it through to completion once the Comcast deal goes off the table, because AT&T management may then see things differently.