Recent studies on the rising phenomenon of multitasking while watching TV have mixed implications for operators and advertisers. On the one hand people are actually concentrating more, rather than less on the TV program being watched, while they multitask – but at the same time the number engaging in second screen activities related to the TV content itself remains stubbornly low at around 5%. This suggests perhaps that the TV itself should be the focus of actions designed to exploit second screens, such as click to purchase.
The headline is that multitasking while watching TV is booming, with 51% of viewers now doing it at least almost every time they watch TV compared with 36% a year ago, according to Tivo’s Second Annual TiVo Multitasking and Social TV Survey conducted on a sample of 856 individuals.
Multitasking at some level is now almost ubiquitous, with 94% of the sample doing it at least sometimes while watching telly, and 58% doing it most of the time. The study also found a significant increase in TV viewing as the primary focus among multitaskers. Among the sample 47% said their primary attention was on the TV show while engaged in second screen activities, up from 39% last year. At the same time the proportion multitasking with their main focus on another task was almost unchanged over the year at 26%. These two figures combined suggest that the new recruits to multitasking over the last year may be the most devoted to the TV content as their primary focus.
Yet it also looks like the new recruits are not engaging in second screen activities related to the TV, since the proportion of all respondents doing so remains on just 5%. The top second screen activity is browsing the Internet, engaged in by 74% of respondents at some time, followed closely by email at 73% and text messaging at 71%.
Drilling down we find a number of other findings relevant to operators and advertisers especially. During commercial breaks, 56% of respondents reported multitasking at least almost every time, so 5% higher than the figure during the program itself. Presumably again little of this activity is related to the ad being shown, so any second screen opportunity would be around somehow hijacking the user’s attention, perhaps through some form of inducement. However 25% of all respondents said that reaching the Internet for related information about a program was the second screen activity that most increased their overall TV enjoyment, followed by episode recaps and reviews much lower at 10%.
The survey suggested that posting about TV programs being watched on social media is not as popular as has sometimes been reported, with only 22% admitting to ever having done so and just 5% on a regular basis, several times a week or more. Twitter fared particularly badly, with only 24% of those who do post regularly on social media tweeting, compared with 71% choosing Facebook. This equates to only about 11 of the 856 sample regularly tweeting.
What the survey does show, in common with others, is that multitasking has now invaded the TV arena after becoming commonplace at work and also during social activities such as dining out. In the case of TV, the term is slightly misleading in that viewing the program itself is supposed to be a form of relaxation rather than a task, although similar mental processes may be involved. Until recently studies of multitasking in general were almost unanimously negative about the phenomenon, suggesting that concentration and productivity suffered when people either performed two or more tasks simultaneously, or switched frequently from one to another.
The definition of multitasking extends to both simultaneous and rapidly alternating activities, so that talking while driving and flipping between email and web surfing are both included. In the case of TV the switch is often between giving a program full attention at one point and then giving just half an ear to the audio while surfing or communicating via the second screen, so it is a mixture of both forms of multitasking.
One or two of the most recent studies suggest that people bought up to multitask from an early age are better at it and may even be stimulated by the constant changing, which is not totally surprising given what is now known about the plasticity of the brain during formative development.
While earlier studies suggested that heavy multitaskers who do it a lot were least productive, more recent ones indicate that the opposite may be true among teenagers who have done this all their lives. One study just completed at the Oregon Episcopal School in Southwest Portland, US and presented this month at the American Academy of Pediatrics National Conference & Exhibition, assessed 196 girls and 207 boys ages 10-19. All participants answered questions about their daily media habits and completed the Stanford Multitasking Media Index, which assesses how often a person multitasks via texts, instant messages and emails at the same time. Participants then completed tests to assess their ability to switch between tasks and also to focus on a single task.
Those who scored low on the index, spending an average of about 20 minutes a day multitasking, were much better at single tasks than doing several at a time. High scorers, spending three hours or more a day multitasking, were highly adept at filtering out distractions and performed very well in environments with a lot of interruptions. They also found more time for homework each day, 3.5 hours rather than 2.5 hours for the lower group, and generally engaged in more media including TV. High multitaskers tended also to be high achievers overall.
The working assumption of delegates at the meeting was that adolescents who grew up with high exposure to multiple media have developed an enhanced working memory valuable for a wide variety of tasks as well as multitasking on more than one at once. This would have implications for education and the media industry. But this hypothesis needs further testing, for it could be that individuals more innately suited to multitasking are the ones who come to engage in it a lot. However the fact only recently surveys have found any cognitive benefits at all from multitasking does lend credence to the working memory hypothesis, since we are only now able to observe the effects of heavy multitasking from a very young age.
Meanwhile the Tivo study does observe that some aspects of TV viewing behavior have not changed. The Milton Berle effect that water pressure drops during commercial breaks as people flock en masse to the toilet still holds. In the early 1950s, there were the first reports of significant drops in water pressure during The Milton Berle Show’s commercial breaks. Now, even with widespread use of DVRs enabling ad skipping, 85% of respondents reported going to the bathroom during commercial breaks, with even 81% of those with a DVR doing so.
One slightly surprising finding given the tablet boom is that the smartphone and laptop are still way out in front as companion screens. The smartphone was number one with 78% reporting using it while watching TV, followed by the laptop on 78%, tablet on 55% and desk top computer 28%.