Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 September 2014

Qualcomm makes the case for TV via LTE Broadcast

LTE Broadcast will be a smart evolution for terrestrial TV services in Europe, according to Qualcomm’s Prakash Sangam, director of tech marketing, and Ed Tiongson, director of product management.

Qualcomm is a big proponent of LTE Broadcast technology, and has been working on technology solutions for both the infrastructure side and the device side that can support LTE Broadcast services, some of which it presented this week in a Webinar hosted by FierceLive.

Interest in LTE Broadcast continues to grow around the world. Qualcomm has participated in 14 trials by 16 different telcos/wireless operators’ around the globe, from the US and Europe to Asia. Tiongson said there are another 10-15 trials on which Qualcomm is working that are not public. Tiongson said every LTE chip Qualcomm ships today can support LTE Broadcast.

“The basic idea of the LTE Broadcast evolution is to bring the efficiency of LTE Broadcast across the network, at more places, more often, for more applications,” Sangam said. “[It’s] not just for some niche applications and some specific locations or situations and scenarios.”

Other use cases for LTE Broadcast include: public safety applications such as emergency announcements, enhanced venue and event-specific content delivery and a “converged” multi-screen broadcast TV service.

Qualcomm offered two sets of example calculations to demonstrate the efficiency of LTE Broadcast over traditional unicast.

“When you create a broadcast, per 3GPP release 9, you can specify up to 60% of that bandwidth to a broadcast/multicast service,” said Tiongson. “Depending on the device type, and depending on the content type, you would allocate a certain percentage of bandwidth. Everything comes down to how much you can take from a video quality perspective.”

For example, assuming 60% of the carrier has been allocated to LTE Broadcast, using around 0.5 Mbps bitrate with HEVC, an operator can deliver 24 streams of video at 540p, which would be ideal for a smaller screen, such as a smartphone.

“We’re seeing a lot of trials where they’re trialing 720p on those devices, and it looks very good,” Tiongson said. “As you increase the size of the display itself, then you may not want to increase the bit rate. When you increase the bitrate, you’re using more capacity, so you have to keep that in mind.”

With a carrier dedicated to LTE Broadcast (meaning 100% capacity is allocated for LTE Broadcast), using 16 Mbps bitrate with HEVC, an operator can deliver five streams of UHD video.

“It’s going to vary depending on the band that you’re using, and how you’re allocating and the network environment, as far as figuring out how much you can deliver,” Tiongson said.

LTE Broadcast offers more efficiency than unicast, even if the number of customers receiving the broadcast content remains low. Across a cluster of cells, if five users per cell receive the broadcast content, the operator will see seven times more throughput than if using unicast; if there are two users in each cell, the operator will receive three times the throughput; and if there is only one user in each cell across a cluster of cells receiving broadcast content, the operators will have 1.7 times more capacity than via unicast.

“With LTE Broadcast, you actually have better performance than unicast even with fewer users,” Sangam said.

The TV use case for LTE Broadcast is the most exciting one. Qualcomm believes LTE Broadcast is a logical evolution for terrestrial TV services, to which Sangam referred as “an excellent and exciting use for LTE Broadcast.” He said LTE Broadcast for a TV service makes sense because the performance is twice what is offered by the alternatives, such as DVB-T or ATSC, that are being contemplated.

From an operator’s perspective, such a TV service could be developed by deploying an overlay of LTE Broadcast using an existing LTE network, including the LTE sites, transport and core network. In order to provide TV-like services, the operator will need to use spectrum dedicated to LTE Broadcast. The content can be delivered to mobile devices, and for indoor devices, such as TV sets, the customer will need a dongle or LTE Broadcast-enabled set-top box, and in some cases, a roof-top antenna will be needed, “which is very similar to how terrestrial services are provided indoor right now,” Sangam said.

The benefits of using LTE Broadcast for a traditional linear TV service include:
-It’s easier to manage one network for mobile and fixed device delivery — meaning one network for delivering content to tablets, smartphones or TV sets and set-top boxes.
– Such a service will expand the reach of live TV content with higher advertising revenue potential because it incorporates delivery to mobile devices.
-Its efficiencies offer an opportunity for more cost-effective, bundled data plans for mobile TV.
-It will enable a provider to deliver a uniform experience across screens.

However, Sangam noted two requirements for LTE Broadcast technology in order to offer a terrestrial TV-like service:
-Operators will need to use a dedicated carrier network for LTE Broadcast.
-Operators will need a longer range reach, up to 15 kilometers (9 miles).

“These two enhancements are essential for the proposed converged TV services — offering regular TV services for LTE Broadcast, not just mobile TV,” Sangam said, meaning the TV use case is still a few years away.

European countries may be the first to use LTE Broadcast to replace terrestrial TV, as the European Commission and other bodies are right now contemplating the technology.

“Europe is defining a future of terrestrial TV, and they are thinking LTE Broadcast is a strong candidate for the next generation of TV services,” Sangam said. “If you look at the existing LTE networks in many of the European countries, you actually can provide an excellent coverage on a country-wide basis, using the existing LTE network.”

Sangam said that using LTE Broadcast for regular TV services could free up 100 MHz of spectrum that would be otherwise used for DVB-T2. This would open up new business opportunities for everyone in the industry, spurring new partnerships between the telecom operators, spectrum holders and the content providers and advertisers to offer new classes of services and new business models.

The European Broadcaster Union (EBU) recently released a report that explored possible uses for the technology for broadcasters, with mixed results. The report’s conclusion was that LTE Broadcast wouldn’t replace DTT in the short term, but the study didn’t say anything to cast doubt on its ability to supplement or replace all together traditional broadcast services down the road.

EBU said the obstacles to widespread use of the technology include getting the proper devices to consumers, meaning LTE Broadcast-enabled tablets, smartphones, TV set dongles, set-tops and antennae; and developing the right business partnerships between spectrum holders (ie telcos or cellcos) and content owners (broadcasters).