Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 September 2014

Vodafone and Cisco’s produce Germany’s first 4K set top

Cisco and Vodafone, using Broadcom chips, will show a 4K set top box designed to integrate all of its German  TV offerings, at IBC. The move is a radical step to steal the lead in a pay TV market where to date Vodafone has been singularly unsuccessful.

Vodafone has an unspecified number of ADSL TV subscribers in Germany, perhaps 100,000 or so, from its long held 3 million plus ADSL connected Mannesmann broadband customers. It also has the 8.3 million or so Kabel Deutschland TV customers, of which 7.6 million subscribe directly and 2.3 million also take broadband.

Last year in May Vodafone cut deals with Deutsche Telekom to take its Vectored VDSL2 lines wholesale, calling this a bitstream network agreement. The idea comes from the fact that Vectoring cannot be offered fully until all the lines in an exchange are managed by a single provider, so Deutsche Telekom must have offered good terms, for Vodafone to step back from owning its own local loop customers.

This means that it can now upgrade or swap those ADSL broadband lines over time, to 50 Mbps lines, and possibly later to 100 Mbps. Kabel Deutschland, using bonded DOSCIS channels has already demonstrated the ability to offer 1.5 Gbps lines, and currently offers a 100 Mbps line as standard on its cable broadband.

With both of those speeds in place, Vodafone really would be in a position to offer 4K content to all 5 million of its broadband customers in Germany, as well as having the potential for a simple DOCSIS upgrade for the remaining 5.5 million Kabel Deutschland customers, should they opt for it.

Now it has gone to Cisco, and by Cisco we don’t just mean the Scientific Atlanta set top division, but also the “MediaHighway” middleware side that it inherited with NDS, to get it a 4K set top. In effect this is like the Horizon project that Liberty Global entered into – it is supposed to be a gamer changer for Vodafone in Germany.

Vodafone says it will be offering the box to subscribers at Kabel Deutschland in the first half of 2015, with content being supplied over the operator’s hybrid distribution platform.

Vodafone TV was launched as a service in Germany over the top in 2010, using a hybrid approach which could combined free to air satellite or cable with IPTV and OTT in a single set top.

The new set top seems to be introduced so that customers anywhere can be offered the same TV service, including those at Kabel Deutschland (KDG). Vodafone acquired KDG for $10.4 billion after outbidding Liberty Global.

Cisco’s Videoscape MediaHighway software provides the OS and processing power required to decode the Ultra HD content, while the Videoscape VideoGuard Conditional Access package will be responsible for protecting the content’s delivery. KDG went simulcrypt back in 2009, shifting from Nagravision conditional access to NDS, a move that is largely thought to be complete by now.

The underlying hardware is a Broadcom BCM7252 SoC, which offers HEVC decoding for 4K content at 60fps, at up to half the bandwidth required for a H.264 video stream. The CPU is a dual-core Brahma15, which is rated at 10,000 DMIPs. This might also be the first set top to feature DDR4 memory, and the unit can also support USB 3.0 peripherals.

Cisco’s Yves Padrines said “the adoption of 4K has been a point of discussion in the industry for a number of years, and we are delighted to be working with Vodafone to move it from a theoretical discussion to reality, while enabling their subscribers to benefit from even greater quality viewing. The deployment marks another first for Vodafone, who remain at the forefront of IPTV innovation.”

But 4K is a problematic format to push to consumers. As we’ve seen in previous issues of Faultline, 4K TV sales are not taking off at anywhere near the level that was optimistically projected in the recent past, and even if a consumer was to purchase a compatible TV, there has not been a growth of 4K content for them to consume. It’s a chicken-or-the-egg scenario that doesn’t have a clear solution.

OTT services have been the first to embrace 4K, with Netflix’s ‘House of Cards’ being the most prominent, with a number of smaller OTT stores pushing 4K to apps, web browsers and even some dedicated set tops. Even YouTube has begun supporting 4K content. Some satellite DTH channels have emerged in 4K around the world in small numbers.

But the last mile connection that is proving the major stumbling block, certainly in the US – where ISPs appear to be throttling the high-bandwidth Netflix content and forcing Netflix to sign interconnect agreements to guarantee that its content makes it to the customers. But even without these underhand tactics, a 4K Netflix stream requires a 15.6Mbps connection, which is not always an option for most internet users. But as we have seen Vodafone may be able to get their first in Germany.

But distribution channels like cable and satellite seem like strong potential homes for 4K content – as they aren’t hampered by the physical constraints of an un-vectored DSL line which has trouble pushing 15.6Mbps. Satellite and cable have the required bandwidth to support multiple 4K channels, and DOCSIS based internet would also happily supply a 4K stream to a customer.

On the purely ISP side of things, VDSL and fiber would also provide adequate bandwidth, but these are hampered by the slow rate of installation and the inherent issues involved in installing fixed line infrastructure. While the same can be said of cable to some extent, satellite appears to be the easiest way of rolling out 4K unicast services (TV) to mass audiences.