Sometimes listening to what newspapers are prepared to say on behalf of cable operators, by repeating the quotes of their CEOs, just makes our blood boil here at Faultline. Like the public arguments of Mike Fries, the CEO of Liberty Global, who fancies himself as something of an intellectual in the argument against Net Neutrality, but he makes points that a first year under-graduate in logic could pull a horse through. And newspapers still give it space.
The public argument is between Fries and the Netflix CEO, Reed Hastings, and of course this presages the next move by Liberty Global, which is to try to charge for Netflix to connect to its broadband network, so that it can get its video to customers. It is the same argument that AT&T, Comcast and Verizon have had with Netflix, but Europe is a very different place.
Speaking on a joint panel at the CTAM EuroSummit in Copenhagen on Friday, Fries said that web content companies should help foot the bill of delivering web video. Naturally Hastings disagreed and said that would be like Liberty Global helping Netflix pay its content costs.
Fries talks about peering arrangements being handshake deals, and complaining that the peering deals are now one sided. He is right, but which way around.
It is in fact Liberty Global’s customers that are asking for content from another ISP peer, so the demand is coming from Liberty’s success in selling broadband lines. It is compensated for having lots of customers by being paid lots of money and it can use that money to build a robust infrastructure for them. But Fries doesn’t see it that way.
It can also pay peering charges, if they are applied to Liberty, to any tier 1 peer that is part of the central Internet transit. Interestingly there are no definitive tier 1 internet hubs in the Netherlands, but KPN is one of the largest tier 2 hubs. Tier 1s never pay for internet traffic, but they can often charge smaller internet providers for agreeing to pass their traffic through. Below this, contracts do tend to be handshakes, just as Fries says, between peers of a similar level, involving no payment from one to the other despite disparity in traffic to and from the other.
For instance where one ISP works on winning enterprise accounts (for instance Level 3 in the US) and another works on acquiring paying consumers (like Comcast, and Liberty Global), who is to say that traffic flowing from the enterprise oriented ISP to the consumer oriented should invoke extra payment. Surely it could be just as easily construed, that requests are coming from one ISP to another, and since it is servicing those requests, the consumer ISP should pay the enterprise oriented one for replying.
Fries wants to turn that logic on its head. Not only will Dutch law find that against the spirit of the European Commission’s stance on Net Neutrality, but it could also lead to all of those prior peering arrangements, such as those with the KPN internet backbone and Liberty Global. KPN might think that a handshake is not good enough and that it sees too much traffic from Liberty Global, and needs to upgrade equipment because of it, and so will begin charging.
Of course IF Liberty Global and Ziggo ever manage to merge, then that will be the largest consumer ISP in the Netherlands and suddenly it may threaten to de-peer (disconnected) from other local ISPs (like KPN) in order to get it (KPN) to pay it money (Liberty Global).
That will lead to KPN using different routes to carry its traffic and every one of the internet peers getting upset. So Fries argument is a yet another good one to prevent that kind of disruption, by preventing the Ziggo merger.
Hastings countered that if Netflix is supposed to pay some of the cost of the network, then maybe it should get some of the broadband revenue. Now that’s a nice idea – Netflix creates the urge for Liberty Global customers to traverse outside of their network to the ISP that carries the Netflix traffic. So Liberty Global should pay the ISP lots of money for carrying and replying to all those requests. And that ISP rewards Netflix with cheaper prices because it is bringing in business. That case could be just as easily made, which is why Netflix gets so upset over this and so do we.
In our experience market control is measured by the amount of damage that a company can do by NOT cooperating, and in the case of Liberty Global, that’s a lot more if it is allowed to buy Ziggo. That’s why Fries doesn’t want regulators involved, because when there is no regulator the bully or the man who is prepared to buff always wins.