Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 October 2014

Technicolor makes huge step up to ATSC 3.0 with Sinclair

A major US Broadcaster has used Technicolor technology to open the door on a potential UHD system for broadcasters – one that might extend free to air broadcasting into the UHD era.

The experiment has been put together for the Sinclair Broadcasting Group and it is a really early version of ATSC 3.0, the laughably named standard which is closer to DVB broadcasting technologies than ATSC.

One of the things that has become obvious as the global broadcasting market shrinks and declines is that equipment vendors cannot make different types of equipment for different regions, and an agreement that all broadcasters would use some form of OFDM carrier has been seen as the necessary first step.

But the surprise of this experiment now, is that first it is way ahead of anyone’s expectation for ASTC 3.0, which was meant to be some years away, and secondly just how far Technicolor has managed to go in such a short space of time. Most broadcasters had been expecting that HD broadcasting will be their last over the air technology and are all looking at sending TV signals over the open internet as OTT signals.

The trial has used Technicolor’s ATSC 3.0 4K UltraHD testbed which includes a scalable version of the HEVC codec. It should be noted that ATSC 3.0 has not yet been fully defined and the physical layer could be either DVB-T2  or LTE-based or one that switches between them dynamically with a software-defined-radio, but this system is based on DVB-T2.

Scalable HEVC Video Coding (SHVC) standardizes the encoding of a high-quality video bitstream that also contains one or more subset bitstreams. A subset video bitstream is derived by dropping packets from the larger video to reduce the bandwidth required for the subset bitstream. The subset bitstream can represent a lower spatial resolution (smaller screen), lower temporal resolution (lower frame rate), or lower quality video signal (HD).

And that can potentially make the signal backwards compatible with existing screens, though not their tuners. Right now ATSC tuners use 8VSB modulation and focus on sending one very clear signal that can be modulated to send many symbols at once. OFDM does the reverse and sends many carriers, with a lower symbol rate for each carrier.

If we go back to February we first saw the FCC agree to a channel-sharing trial at KLCS and KJLA, two commercial broadcaster in LA. This trial involved multiplexing multiple HD and SD sub-channels together, though at the time this used H.264 as a video codec, but using OFDM instead of 8VSB for modulation. That way it squeezed 28 Mbps into a single 6-MHz channel.

Now this new trial has moved the goalposts yet again, gaining all the benefits of HEVC but a scalable version will mean that HD TV sets will view the signal as HD, and UHD sets will view it as UHD. The problem is that no existing US TV sets have a tuner that can resolve OFDM signals, because they all use 8VSB encoding, so this will require a full device swap out.

Scalable video coding has been around for years as an idea, but as far as we know it has never been adopted into a full commercial product and there has never been a version before for HEVC.

The idea is that if such a system comes into the mainstream, broadcasters will be able to deliver 4K UltraHD live broadcasts and in the same signal offer HD that can be picked up on a TV, or potentially directly on a phone or a tablet. Right now there are ATSC M/H devices deployed in the US which are made for receiving a variant of the 8VSB signal for mobile and handheld reception. This will have to switch to including an OFDM tuner, but could also be received on a phone or tablet, either directly or with a small tuner add-on.

“Technicolor has created an integrated platform, not just a single component such as audio or video, which enables us to do real-world deployments and testing of this exciting next generation ATSC 3.0 technology,” said Vince Pizzica, Senior Executive Vice President of Corporate Development and Technology for Technicolor.

“Sinclair continues to work to bring future value to all broadcast stakeholders, a future where HDTV and new services can be reliably delivered to tablets and portable devices, and 4K UltraHD to our home audience,” stated Mark Aitken, Vice President of Advanced Technology for Sinclair.

ATSC M/H modulators have been fitted to broadcast antennas in about 70 US markets, but there has been very little uptake in the special phones or add-ons that convert a TV signal to a WiFi input for viewing on a phone under the Dyle brand. If broadcasters shifted to the new OFDM format the same problem would be there to stimulate handset makers to include TV tuners in their devices, either integrated or separately.

But given the power of some of the chips included in the modern handset, it may well be possible to use the existing app processors on chips such as Qualcomm’s Snapdragon range, and run the demodulation there. This is what Qualcomm has managed to do for LTE Broadcasting, and it seems a problem of a similar magnitude. The only difference would be the spectrum that has to be intercepted on the phone, which is similar between LTE and LTE Broadcast, but not between ATSC 3.0 and LTE. So we’re not sure that the ATSC 3.0 lends itself any more to mobile delivery than its predecessor ATSC 2.0.

Still Technicolor and Sinclair must have a plan. This is certainly the first successful broadcast of Scalable HEVC compression we have come across and also first integration of MPEG-MMT A/V transport technology, which Technicolor says is enhanced with its own fast channel change and Staggercast technologies (which we understand to be Turbo Code FEC based) which ensure consumers don’t lose audio even where video reception is poor.

Technicolor said, “Scalable HEVC translates bits from a network data stream into a picture by breaking up video bit streams into subsets that add layers of quality and resolution to video signals. Our platform allows us to flexibly adapt to sub-par network connections by dropping these bit stream subsets or packets in order to reduce the frame rate, resolution or bandwidth consumption of a picture, which prevents the picture from breaking up.”

It was March last year that the Advanced Television Systems Committee announced a call for proposals for the ATSC 3.0 physical layer which must support video with a resolution of 3840×2160 at 60 fps and this has not yet been agreed upon.

Technicolor says its platform is also based on the MPEG-H audio and MPEG-MMT transport formats, and put together for Sinclair’s experimental OFDM transmission system in Baltimore, Maryland. These tests were  conducted using a single 6MHz channel where WNUV sits in Channel 40, in the 600 MHz band. Sinclair shut its regular ATSC broadcast off at midnight and conducted tests until 5am, using an experimental DVB-T2 transmitter.