Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 October 2014

Death of Redbox Instant raises questions over Verizon Video

Verizon’s OTT service has been shut down due to poor performance. A very short post on its website told Redbox customers that they would be able to receive some refunds, but that the service “was not as successful as we hoped it would be,” and would be closed as soon as the clocks hit midnight on October 8.

Redbox kiosks will live on, allowing users to rent physical media, but any credits bought through Instant to use at the kiosks will expire with the OTT service. More worryingly for customers, Verizon hasn’t disclosed what will happen to purchases made through the platform, and instead says “we’re exploring options for customers who purchased electronic versions of on-demand movies.”

This raises huge question marks over the wisdom of the Verizon management team, and the future of its OnCue OTT video service purchase from Intel, and just what Outwall, the parent company of Redbox (the Kiosk variety) can do to ensure its survival.

Redbox Instant came about as a joint venture announced between DVD-kiosk provider Redbox, by far the biggest business owned by Outerwall, and Verizon announced in 2012, with Verizon holding 65% control. It launched in March 2013 with 5,000 titles and has migrated to a number of devices including Roku boxes and the Sony PlayStation 4.

During the wars with Netflix Coinstar, as Outerwall was previously called, took its kiosk technology and drove the prices to the floor in Disk based video rentals. It made a hole in Netflix at a time when it was considering departing physical disk content. Netflix today retains the online DVD rental business, but it is a fraction of its revenues and it has not replicated that part of its business overseas.

Now how does Red Box go forward, surely it is as outmoded and out of date as Blockbuster DVD stores have become and the same result is likely. We would say there is only one answer – it has to find another partner to stump up the cash to buy out the Verizon experiment, and somehow keep it going. The fact that it has allowed Verizon to issue this statement about its closure, means that it won’t be doing that – but it must have tried.

You could argue that the remaining 42,000 Redbox kiosks in 36,000 locations in the US and Canada, are still assets and still generating cash.

In its second quarter numbers revenues overall were slightly down at $549 million at Outerwall, with profits more than halved, but cash generation up at $36.8 million in free cash flow, but that’s because it has run the business to earn as much cash as possible. The management referred to its weak content additions during the quarter, so clearly it is not going down the route of Netflix to invest in original content.

The Red Box portion of that revenue was $445.5 million down from with$478.5 million in 2013 across 169.3 million rentals. What has historically driven Red Box sales is something it calls Box Office, which are new releases onto DVD of movies which made at least $5 million at the box office. This has been really weak in the quarter, down 37.5%, further compounded by the scarcity of strong content available for rent in June. June 2014 Box Office was 83% lower than June 2013 because it only added 4 titles that month.

And here is the major problem for it, any OTT service has all of its backlog on file, and can sign exclusive TV series deals. Whereas DVD services have historically made little sense to offer with any kind of exclusivity.

In its other business CoinStar, Outerwall has opened new kiosk businesses in grocery and other sectors and seems to be growing new kiosk business as fast as it can, so that it can replace the ailing Red Box business. That’s worrying, because the only way it could possibly replace that business would be to spend a lot of money, and the best way for it to do that would be to sell Red Box. We’re not sure than anyone will pay much of a premium for a business that is “end of life.”

The Verizon part of the video equation seems just as worrying. If Verizon cannot make Redbox Instant work, and yet believed it could, it means it does not have such a handle on what will and what won’t work in video, whether that’s on a phone or a tablet or online to a PC or TV.

Verizon has spent a fortune buying in every kind of technology – from CDNs to media players – as well as bolstering its fiber, in order to be ready to carry video over its fixed line and cellular networks including investing in broadcasts over LTE. It’s entire strategy seems to rest on dealing with the video escalation on wireless networks. If it can get something like Redbox Instant all wrong, then it can surely get all of its video ideas wrong.

Verizon’s interest in growing the Redbox Instant service arose from a desire to expand beyond the confines of its wireline footprint of only 22 FiOS states, because Redbox kiosks are found within a 5 minute drive of 68% of the US population, giving the brand strong recognition for an OTT video service.

Now the plan has failed the most obvious culprit to blame is Netflix, the kingpin of OTT, with Hulu and Amazon also serious contenders in the space. But Redbox was noteworthy because it gave Verizon access to the revenue generated by non-Verizon customers – to the tune of $9 per month per subscriber for streamed content, and more if they made VoD purchases.

Redbox Instant’s library was noticeably smaller than rivals, but a bigger issue was the company decision to block new customer signups for the last 3 months due to a credit card fraud problem – which had the knock-on effect of preventing existing customers adding new payment details for expiring and revoked cards.

Whether the shutdown of Redbox Instant will be a blow to Verizon’s mobile OTT ambitions remains to be seen. The telco acquired the remainder of Intel’s aborted OnCue project earlier in the year, which management admits were snapped up to form the basis of an internet-based multiscreen TV service. Intel’s attempt failed because it couldn’t secure enough content rights, much the same reason that has apparently deterred Apple from launching a TV for these past few years, despite constant rumors. But Verizon already has content deals in place thanks to FiOS and the Redbox Instant service which may have put it in a good position to extend rights to its cellular customers on the go and OTT customers.

In a recent investors call, Verizon CEO Lowell McAdam said “I think over the top video is right around the corner. We’ve got the assets in place, and I don’t feel we need an awful lot more. We are very focused on probably the late first half of 2015 for having these products in the marketplace. We have been investing in our Verizon Digital Media Service, which is that content delivery network that gives you the ability to insert ads and deliver to any kind of device.”

So perhaps Redbox Instant was the dry run, and Verizon has learned a lot about OTT video at the expense of Outerwall.