As one of the bigger mid-sized set top and gateway makers ADB has found itself under squeeze by the big players, especially Cisco, Arris, Pace, EchoStar and increasingly Huawei, unable to match their economies of scale. For this reason ADB has been reinventing itself as a software, services and smart home company, but has made a bit of a meal of doing so and confused the market in the process.
This has led to ADB seeking to go private, following an approach from its leading shareholder 4T with a generous offer of CHF 15.50 (€12.86) per share, a premium of 34% over last Friday’s stock market close and 20% higher than the last 60 days of trading average on the SIX Swiss Exchange. The group’s statement summed things up pretty succinctly, “ADB Group is in the process of changing its business model away from the current hardware-based products towards software, systems and services. Even though the process is underway, it is envisaged to take a relatively long time during which the operational results will likely be unsteady.”
This seems like a euphemism for an impending slump in both revenues and profits as the old business declines before the new one ramps up. But there is plenty to play for yet as the company still has a decent business in set tops and gateways and continues to gain new customers, such as Volia, Ukraine’s largest pay TV operator with nearly two million subscribers, which in June 2014 ordered two types of ADB set top, one for hybrid OTT/cable and one for HD OTT environments. ADB is also managing the software integration with Volia’s existing third-party applications, so this can be seen as an example of success for the new business model.
There are plenty of precedents among major public companies going private to seek shelter from volatile markets during periods of transition or difficulty, obtaining time for new longer term strategies to take effect. Smart phone maker Blackberry is one celebrated example, reaching agreement with Fairfax Financial to sell itself for $4.7 billion in September 2013. Just a month or so later PC maker Dell became the biggest ever company to go back private in a $25 billion deal. These two had distinctive features, in Blackberry’s case reflecting a major failure to compete with Apple and Samsung, especially in smart phones following some big mistakes. One mistake was in persisting with miniature keyboards on phones after most people had swung towards touch screens for small devices on which they are not likely to want to input long documents.
In Dell’s case it reflected the impact of tablets on PC sales and failure to gain traction in that space, coupled with struggle to gain as much ground in the enterprise arena as it had hoped. The fight for control was also a major factor with founder Michael Dell determined to regain total hegemony, which he has succeeded in doing by going private.
ADB’s case is less dramatic than either of those, although both revenues and profits have been in decline. In 2013 revenues were $373.5 million and gross profit $108.7 million, compared with $451.6 million and $133.8 million respectively for 2012. The decline has continued through 2014, with first half year revenues of $161.1 million, down 23.4% on the same period of 2013, with gross profits down from $59.6 million to $49.1 million over the same period. But there have been a few green shoots of recovery showing already, such as gross margin rising 2.2% over the period to reach 30.5% over the first half of 2014. At the same time revenues were only down marginally against the second half of 2013. This allowed ADB to claim that its new software focused strategy was just starting to bear fruit, but that it would need time to build momentum and enable growth in revenues and profits to resume sufficiently to avoid unpleasant fluctuations in stock price.
It remains to be seen whether these really are green shoots of recovery, but at least now ADB is following a clear course. The problem has been insufficient focus, slowness defining its smart home strategy and a failure to capitalize on its early lead in the market for hybrid set tops. It held that lead in 2010 and 2011 after introducing different set tops combining IP connectivity with cable, satellite and digital terrestrial, but has now lost that position to bigger rivals. It has picked up some customers in places like the Ukraine, as we have seen, but few if any major operators. It has also lost ground in its home country where Swisscom went elsewhere for its Internet gateway box launched in November 2013, perhaps a casualty of its failure to get its act together over software more quickly.
In the event ADB only launched its Triple-S Software, Systems & Services strategy in September 2014, including some new products. One of these was a set of middleware called Uniphyne TV, which might have cut some ice at Swisscom had it been available 18 months earlier. ADB also launched an RDK (Reference Design Kit) product, which will help it compete in IP cable among operators. The market for RDK based platforms is likely to be stimulated by completion of the broadband version of the stack after testing by Comcast and Arris.
A key component on the client side of ADB’s Triple-S is GraphyneTV, a software suite enabling operators to deliver video and other media content to TVs, mobile devices and computers. This is available both as an end-to-end turnkey solution (Graphyne E2E) or standalone for integration with the operator’s existing backend.
ADB also launched its anticipated Smart Home Suite at the same time as Triple-S, planning to promote them as parallel suites. The initial focus is on home security, automation and energy management, but ADB aims to cover all smart home applications as they emerge and position itself as a unifying platform. Precisely because no coherent standards are in sight above the physical layer where low power wireless technologies like Zigbee and Z-wave are gaining headway, ADB argues there will be a need for a common platform to enable integration and achieve synergy between multiple smart home services.
Currently ADB Smart Home Suite includes a catalog of sensors, different gateway options, a complete cloud back-end and applications for PCs and mobile devices. It has options for controlling home services both indoors and outdoors.
The challenge for ADB is to capitalize on its early promise in the smart home more than it has in hybrid set tops and gateways. In some ways though the smart home is more challenging for a former set top vendor, since it presents a large diffuse target with no immediate prospect of major revenues. Unlike pay TV where customers are well defined and easy to identify, there are many different players spread across multiple vertical segments. These range from energy utilities, where British Gas is making a major play for the smart home, retailing where Staples in the US has invested a lot, and security from where market leader ADT has entered the fray. Also most of the major Telcos are now expanding their smart home activities, with AT&T and Deutsche Telekom notable players. ADB will have to prioritize its limited resources and pick key vertical segments as well as service categories to address if it is ever to emerge from safe harbor as a public company again. It can say that is has returned to its roots in software where it began in 1995, although then it had a clear focus just on digital TV, then a very new field.