The EBU (European Broadcasting Union) has published another report aimed at defending the 700 MHz spectrum band for DTT operators against re-allocation to the mobile industry.
Published by telecoms consultancy Aetha for the EBU along with the BBC, French broadcaster TDF, DTT lobbying group BNE (Broadcast Networks Europe) and infrastructure providers Arqiva and Abertis, the report claims the cost of migrating the so called sub 700 MHz band between 470 and 694 MHz from DTT to mobile services over the 2015 to 2030 period would be at least four times greater than the benefits accrued.
The report estimated the costs of migration at €38.5 billion, including €19.7 billion for the consumer equipment required, €10.8 billion for setting up a new free-to-view platform and €14.2 billion arising as a result of reduced competition in TV platforms, but minus the €6.2 billion saved through no longer having to run DTT networks.
Against this the report estimated the benefits to mobile operators by starting off considering the difference between the network costs with and without the additional 224 MHz of spectrum gained from the sub 700 MHz band. Then Aetha took account of the increasing competition among operators that the extra spectrum would trigger, with the effect of forcing MNOs to lower their prices in order just to retain market share. Benefits to consumers were also taken into account in arriving at the final figure of €10.5 billion gain for mobile services. This was assuming traffic levels at the top end of the estimates – for less traffic the benefits were lower and so the net cost of migration would be even higher, according to the authors.
One odd thing not about the study itself, but its promotion by the broadcasters is that it is not much different from one published just two months ago by the EU itself, which we summarised in the September 4th edition. That report was commissioned to end the rancour between broadcasters and mobile operators and develop a common European approach to spectrum until 2030 so that all parties can plan for the foreseeable future. It was chaired by former European Commissioner and WTO Director General Pascal Lamy, concluding that “the EU should adopt a common position against the co-primary allocation of the core audio-visual band (470-694MHz) to the mobile service at WRC 2015”.
Like the latest EBU report, this effectively split this spectrum into two, the so called 700 MHz band between 694 and 790 MHz and the sub 700 MHz band between 470 and 694 MHz The EBU at the time applauded the report’s recommendation that the sub 700 MHz band be retained for broadcasters until at least 2030, but expressed concern over the suggestion that the 700 MHz band be given over to wireless broadband services in 2020, plus or minus two years.
But it now looks like the EBU has given up on the higher 694 to 790 MHz band, since this latest report by Aetha concentrates on the sub 700 MHz band which will be the battleground against mobile operators between 2015 and 2030. The Aetha report is perhaps more dismissive about the compromise proposal for co-allocation where spectrum is shared between DTT and mobile, not even considering it as an option. It also dismissed the idea of further segmenting the sub 700 MHz into two or more separate bands, arguing this would be uneconomic and introduce yet more complexity.
While that might be right, the report is guilty like others before of it of failing to take account of the complete picture. There are really three elements here, transmission technology, economics and competition between factions for spectrum ownership. Regarding transmission in the long run everyone agrees that unicast will be uneconomic for transmitting live TV to large numbers of recipients, but no given technology has a monopoly. The report fails to take account of emerging options like LTE Broadcast on the mobile side.
The report argues the economics favour retention of the sub 700 MHz for DTT until 2030 at least, but again makes numerous assumptions such as the continuing appetite of consumers for accessing live channels over the air, and also over the impact of competition in the respective sectors. In terms of ownership the battle is between operators and broadcasters for control over spectrum used for some form of multicast video transmission. The EBU portrays it in the context of a battle to defend free to air public service broadcasting, but given a likely erosion of the licence payer model in those European countries that have it, between 2015 and 2030 we can see a trend towards TV coming universally via some form of broadband subscription and the question is really one of timing, with the focus on the coming 15 year period.