If a rising tide lifts all ships, Apple has done a favor to the struggling NFC m-payments business. The launch of Apple Pay is sparking US consumer interest in smartphone payments in general, according to new figures, and the use of Google Wallet has doubled since the iPhone 6 announcement.
Tim Cook said recently that one million cards had been activated for Apple Pay – hardly a shopping revolution, but a healthier start than Google Wallet enjoyed in 2011. According to reports in ArsTechnica, Google Wallet transactions have risen by 50%, and the number of new users has doubled, since September in the US – where the biggest NFC battles are taking place, and which will provide templates for other countries.
Actual m-payments growth is mainly happening in emerging markets, though often using simpler technologies like SMS. Outside a few exceptional territories like Japan, uptake in developed economies has been slow so far, partly because many initiatives have been led by carriers, which have not worked out a convincing business model or relationship with banks and other participants.
The companies like Apple and Google, which may, through the weight of their consumer brands, convince users and merchants to support NFC have focused heavily on the US for now. But they are not having the game to themselves. They face rival NFC systems led by retailers (particularly the MCX group which is preparing to launch the ConnectC service); by operators (Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile have partnered on SoftCard); or financial institutions.
Some ConnectC members, such as major pharmacy chains Rite Aid and CVS, have blocked Apple Pay, presumably to improve the chances of success for a system in which they, not a handset maker, have the guiding hand. But such disputes threaten to fragment the market and consumer pressure may force a change of heart. MCX’s CEO Dekkers Davidson said in a recent interview with Walt Mossberg that the decision to support ConnectC exclusively was only designed to give the retail-driven system “breathing room”, and blocks on Apple and Google wallets would be removed “in months not years”.
Davidson also said in a recent press conference: “We’re agnostic about technology. We started with QR code-based technology that allows us to go to market broadly. If we need, we can pivot to NFC.” It is important for would-be m-payments leaders to have this flexibility, since there is still no guarantee that NFC will become the standard. Some major influencers, like PayPal, have remained skeptical about it, and believe merchants and even consumers will prefer simpler approaches which do not require specialized terminals and apps.
However, many agree with Davidson that Apple’s support may revive a technology which had appeared to be failing. “I think there’s been a mistake made here, and that is focusing on the technology instead of what business or consumer problem you’re trying to solve,” Davidson told the New York Times. “It’s ironic in a way that we’re talking about a really old technology being employed here. Way before Apple Pay, merchants hadn’t enabled it or planned on using it.”
ConnectC will join the other payments choices in early 2015, launching in about 110,000 outlets across the US, including chains such as Walmart, Best Buy and Target. The app will use QR technology for transactions, creating a scannable barcode. Its appeal to merchants is that it does not incur credit card fees like plastic cards or NFC. However, it will need to offer incentives to consumers to use it, which may include retail rewards schemes or vouchers.
Many experts are saying none of the potential m-payments powerhouses should go much further with their schemes until security issues have been more effectively addressed. MCX’s email provider was hacked last week, exposing some testers’ details, and hackers have warned that Apple Pay needs more extensive security trials too.
Meanwhile, as retailers, device makers and operators all fight for their place in the mobile commerce value chain, the existing payments giants – whether the card processors or PayPal – have to be in pole position still, with their business models and platforms already in place. Several national and international banks are reported to be planning their own system, rather than just partnering with players like Apple. “Banks all around the world are working on this right now,” James Anderson, SVP for mobile and emerging payments at MasterCard, told NetworkWorld. He did not identify the banks, but said MasterCard was in conversations with them already.
There are various technology options, but the most likely may be HCE (host card emulation), which is the carriers’ nightmare because it implements NFC without using the operator-controlled SIM card for authentication. Instead, HCE allows applications to emulate the secure element found in smartcards, SIM cards and the iPhone 6 in software, with authentication in the cloud.