Last week we talked about the way UK operators are preparing for financial mayhem with Quad play services, with both BT, the fixed line incumbent which has built up a huge number of WiFi and broadband assets, likely to be one of the biggest disruptors, as would TalkTalk.
No sooner is the idea of a quad play war out of the bag, than players in the market have immediately tried to change the equation – with most talk this week being triggered by British Telecom being approached by Telefonica to buy back its O2 cellular service, to fuel its hungry coffers for expansion and consolidation in its Latin American markets, never mind defense in its homeland Spain.
It is proving so tempting to British Telecom that EE, the merged cellular love-child of Orange and Deutsche Telekom’s T-Mobile, has thrown its hat in the ring. It is tough to see precisely which came first the chicken (suitor) or the egg (offerer) and in which order, but given the bewildering number of potential deals to consolidate the fecund UK operator market, it is even tougher to predict the outcome.
The newspapers are pushing BT as the unshakeable “incumbent” which holds all the cards, but it is the sole European incumbent that managed to sell off its most profitable part, its cellular empire in 2005 for £18 billion (Today worth $28 billion). Of course the BT share price has been on the rise for some time, mostly since the current management was installed. Since then the company has performed predictably after a few disastrous years. It then went and launched the TV channel BT Sport, and used it to drive up its broadband market share dramatically.
That sentiment and the announcement of these discussions has seen the BT share price rise over the past 2 years in a ski jump curve, and suddenly makes it a predictable force. Recently there has been plenty of talk about its MVNO with EE, and the idea that the company will finally uses its market power to drive a quad play and steal whole chunks of the cellular market, especially using its exclusive FON UK deal, whereby it has 5 million WiFi Access Points through which to offload cellular data in a WiFi First strategy.
In our view, BT should have perhaps gone ahead and done just that. But in a last gasp effort to prevent quad play pricing mayhem in the UK, Telefonica has offered to fall on its UK sword, sell up control to BT, but take instead a sizeable holding in BT, that will see its customers have privileged roaming access to BT assets, when they come to the UK.
Such a move might be enough to keep Quad play prices in the UK a little higher. We said last week that both BT and TalkTalk could be disruptive in the coming war, but with a conventional cellular operation to protect, BT may be far less inclined to push cellular pricing to the floor.
That’s something we have said for years. If you own a fixed line architecture business and add cellular, the tendency of management is to preserve your old revenues and bundle in cellular for free. When things happen the other way around, the tendency is for a cellular operator buying into fixed lines to give away fixed line services like TV in order to preserve cellular dollars.
Vodafone then buying Ono will offer its loyal mobile customers cheaper broadband. But Iliad’s Free when it acquired a French 3G license decided to offer its 5 million loyal customers insanely cheap cellular. If this is a rule of operators, then this move to sell BT a cellular operation is seen as turning BT into more of a Vodafone, than a Free. It’s almost as if someone is saying “Don’t spoil the market for all of us, okay then you can have your cellular toys back.”
But while that won’t make much difference to O2, and it might re-instate the status quo at BT, it is seriously concerning to the other players in the UK, and not just cellular players – Liberty Global’s Virgin Media, Vodafone, 3 UK, and Sky, not to mention TalkTalk, will all have their noses put out of joint, so may make a move to challenge either of these deals.
Neither EE nor Vodafone wants to have the main supplier of their fixed line backhaul, owning the second largest (or largest) cellular operator in the UK. That’s especially true when neither of them have a quad play yet (both have just talked about plans for a 2015 launch) or have hardly any fixed lines in the ground.
Weirdly as a DTH supplier, Sky is the second largest holder of ISP broadband lines in the UK after BT. That means it can offer phones, broadband and TV and it is only a matter of time before it launches its own brand MVNO to facilitate the Quad play. This broadband situation came about because it bought one of the ULL pioneers Easynet in 2005.
We pointed out last week that the pecking order for broadband in the UK goes BT with 7.4 million DSL lines, but domestic retail is only 5.4 million, with a handful more on fiber, and Sky on 5.3 million, Virgin with 4.5 million and TalkTalk with 4 million.
So where does that leave the other major MNOs in the UK? O2 sold its 500,000 broadband subscribers to Sky in early 2013, while EE has around 612,000 unbundled and wholesaled broadband lines, and has recently said that it would introduce pay TV and create its own Quad play. 3 UK has no broadband lines and also only has a 3G network, so cannot even fall back to a prior GSM network.
3 is in a delicate positon and last year it talked about merging with O2. If EE allows O2 to merge with BT, then both Vodafone and EE will look at 3 and whether that might give them the leg up they need to retain or retake the number one spot.
Currently EE has 28 million UK customers, O2 some 22.9 million, Vodafone around 19.5 million and 3 around 7.5 million. Given that there are 4 MNOs right now and a healthy MVNO market (Virgin, Tesco, TalkTalk…) the mobile landscape can change rapidly with any number of deals.
Certainly Vodafone could consider buying 3, as might EE or even TalkTalk, bringing the number of operators down to just three. Right now the TalkTalk MVNO is with O2, in a recent development, after years with Vodafone. Virgin holds an MVNO license with EE, but Virgin Media could buy 3 if it wanted, and replace a virtual network with a real one, especially if BT had merged with EE.
But to us the real kingmaker here is the ability to offload to existing Wifi Homespots, which are run from those broadband lines we discussed earlier. BT said at the end of 2013 that it had access to 220,000 normal commercial hotspots in the UK, and a further 5 million Homespots, all of which can deliver WiFi.
While we don’t think that BT has built 220,000 Hotspots, it probably has the lion’s share of those, perhaps 170,000, especially after it installed a huge number for the 2012 Olympics and the rest exist in bartered hotspot agreements with others. EE has a deal to use all existing BT Hotspots and these days BT does not distinguish between normal commercial hotspots and Homespots. It certainly has some kind of sharing agreement with Sky which owns The Cloud, which claims 20,000 WiFi hotspots in Europe, with more than half off those in the UK. BT customers can also access the 13 million FON hotspots around the rest of the world.
Sky certainly has the ability to plug the WiFi gap at any of the MNOs, and also offer up its TV content to complete any of their Quad play portfolios, either the full DTH lineup or more likely just the Sky owned channels, or just Sky Now, its OTT subset of channels.
We know that Vodafone is speaking to Sky about licensing Sky Now as part of its Quad play, and it may be that it will also use Cloud hotspots to offload data services, especially video, to WiFi. As it builds out 4G, Vodafone will be in a position, as its 4G network is virtually empty, to offer video over data and we know it is working on LTE Broadcasting in Germany and could import the results to its UK home. While Vodafone would probably not be invited to acquire Sky by 21st Century networks, there is a natural alignment between these two. They have done business together for years and have mutual respect. If Sky decides to put a second SSID on its home gateways, it could also offer 5 million homes of WiFi access to Vodafone, at a price.
It is the same for the fixed line Telco incumbents of Europe – they are more likely to do deal with BT than with anyone else – but that still doesn’t tell us which choice between O2 and EE, since they are both owned by fixed line telcos, who have had long and deep dealings in the past with BT.
TalkTalk might find itself be universally shunned, as Free was in France, but where it still managed to be the disruptor that took pricing to the floor.
Here are some scenarios. Vodafone puts in a bid for one of the other MNOs, so that the regulator has to imagine the completion of both deals at once, and so it kills them both otherwise the concentration in MNOs would be too great. Or Vodafone puts in a bid for BT – with the same result.
Liberty Global shows its hand financially by trying to buy someone. Sky announces an MVNO deal with a video service to the handset.
3 UK throws in the towel and announces its sale to anyone in the loop, but since it already has a RAN sharing deal with EE, merges with EE after BT opts for Telefonica.
Many of these are what we call spoiling agreements. They aren’t meant to be done, but they are made to confuse both regulators and shareholders and ruin the deals that are on the table.
In the end most likely outcome is for BT to get O2 back, for Vodafone to go it alone with help from Sky, and for Virgin to continue to partner with EE, and to facilitate some of its TV content for its quad play. That still leaves 3 and TalkTalk in a tough position.
And as if all of that was not enough to consider, Ofcom has received a complaint that BT is too strong in the UK, from the UK Competitive Telecommunications Association (UKCTA), an alliance of telcos. It wants Ofcom to review the market and reassess priorities for the next decade.
That’s the kind of reaction you get when BT recently asked if it could merge BT Wholesale back into BT Openreach, which came out last week, a kind of backlash.
A survey carried out by UKCTA talked about low awareness among consumers over who is actually responsible when things go wrong with their broadband or telephone service. It also asks for Ofcom to focus on getting Openreach to improve service quality and innovation.
This complaint cannot be separated from BT having the potential to become the WiFi kingmaker to a number of UK cellular services.