The pay TV infrastructure market is not so easy to count accurately now, because it overlaps increasingly with other sectors during the migration to IP and file based transmission, sharing resources with non-video applications. Not surprisingly there are wild disparities among analysts over assessments and predictions, but one thing everyone agrees on is that Cisco has opened up a clear lead, which has widened over the last year.
The uncertainty is over the relative standings of the chasing bunch, although Arris looks to have established second place after its acquisition of Motorola Home from Google for $2.2 billion in cash plus some shares, completed in April 2013. The positions of Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent are hard to quantify given their overlaps between pay TV, IP and mobile infrastructure, with the former making a big play with LTE and the latter in DSL vectoring technology, which are both driven largely by video but are not usually counted as broadcast infrastructure. Neither of these two are even mentioned in the summary of a recent study by Synergy Research Group, which rates the global pay TV infrastructure market as a whole at $10 billion this year, split roughly 80/20 between hardware and software, although this distinction is increasingly blurry and meaningless.
On that basis Cisco and Arris are almost the only two major players with total coverage of pay TV infrastructure, including CPE, and only the former is also big in general IP networking with its dominant number one position in IP routers and Ethernet switches. Harmonic is sometimes considered to be an all-round player, but actually has gaps in its portfolio, including set tops, CDN distribution, security and areas of software like content discovery, which is why it has formed alliances with the likes of CDN technology vendor Broadpeak and also France Telecom’s Viaccess-Orca for pre-integrated service packages.
Harmonic is also much smaller than Cisco or Arris, with 2013 revenues of $461.9 million, just slightly down on 2012, slipping a little further this year. So by Synergy Research’s reckoning and given that it is a dedicated vendor in the field, Harmonic has about 4.6% of the pay TV infrastructure field and so is not ranked as a leader. Cisco is considered to have 19%, equating to $1.9 billion revenues and Arris about 12.5%. So while Cisco may be in the lead it is miles away from meeting an objective CEO John Chambers once cited as a criterion for success, to have more than 50% of a given market.
There is little chance of that happening in pay TV infrastructure, although Cisco could well increase its share up to around 25%. Below Arris, the next players in line only register in one of the two segments, hardware or software, according to Synergy. Taking the bigger hardware pie, Pace and Technicolor are rated joint third at just a whisker under 5% of that market. Despite the fact that both would claim they are really driven by software, their contributions are all counted as hardware, though we’re not quite sure why.
On the smaller software side, Nagra is actually ranked second on just below 14%, with Arris third on 9.5% and Rovi fourth on 7%. But we question numbers that have no room for Ericsson, so need to look a little further. Part of the problem lies in the difficulty working out what Ericsson’s pay TV revenues are, but it should rank quite highly both on hardware, with its various encoding and video processing platforms and on software, for example with Mediaroom, which accounts for about 25% of the global IPTV middleware market.
Ericsson has, to some extent, followed a parallel pay TV trajectory to Cisco through takeover, but an important difference is that the latter completed a lot of its acquisition pains earlier and is now in a stable position for growth. Cisco also scores almost when anything moves, video or otherwise, which is not the case so much for its rivals. Cisco’s major pay TV acquisitions were Scientific Atlanta for $6.9 billion in 2005 to get into hardware and then NDS for $5 billion, completed July 2012, to establish pole position in software.
Ericsson’s first big move came early in 2007 with the acquisition of Tandberg Television for $1.4 billion, giving it at a stroke about 20% of the then global video processing hardware market. Ericsson’s more recent notable acquisitions included the Mediaroom IPTV middleware package from Microsoft and UK content management company Red Bee Media in 2013, followed in early 2014 by adaptive streaming and content protection software vendor Azuki Systems to get a leg up into OTT. These were all for undisclosed sums.
Ericsson’s total revenues in 2013 were $29.7 billion and are riding pretty flat at the moment. Most of that is still from mobile and especially 4G/LTE network infrastructure, where the company is world number one, as it is for telecoms software. In that sense Ericsson’s efforts to migrate from being a telecoms hardware company towards software and services with a focus on video and TV has been rather painstaking.
Our estimate is that Ericsson makes about $700 a year million from video processing hardware and $500 million from software, of which about $350 million comes from Mediaroom alone. This would give Ericsson about 12% of the global video infrastructure market by the Synergy Research reckoning, in third place just marginally behind Arris, but we think the research company’s total market calculation is way too low anyway and should be about $14 billion and not $10 billion. Similarly Huawei and ZTE which both have end to end IPTV installations in Asia Pacific markets, are not mentioned either.
Of course broadcasting services, where Ericsson is a fast growing force, is a separate category, so the company’s overall position in the broadcasting and pay TV ecosystem is greater than its infrastructure ranking would suggest.
The general picture in video infrastructure is one of fragmentation, both overall and within individual sectors, indicating there is much to play for during this transition in the industry towards IP and file based distribution. Multi-screen transcoding is a pivotal sector here, since it has been expanding to address multiple devices in OTT and TV Everywhere deployments.
This market, worth about $190 million in 2014, is particularly split, with Harmonic leading, at least until recently, on just over 10%. The company has been pinning its hope for growth as we indicated earlier by presenting itself as a one stop shop, with the help of partners providing pre-integrated components where necessary. But on its own Harmonic has the delivery ecosystem well covered, offering both file and live products, as well as re-encoding and transcoding for principal use cases. It also extends well beyond transcoding across the video processing and delivery ecosystem to include multi-screen stream packagers, storage, origin servers, playout servers, and storage. So far Harmonic has struggled to capitalize on this position in its core encoding market, since its revenues there have only grown in line with the recent 15% or so annual growth rate in the sector.
In fact by some counts Harmonic has been caught up or even overtaken in encoding by Elemental, which has scored by being more disruptive in the field and making hay with its software based approach. Ground is also being gained by other dedicated players, such as the cloud based Brightcove Zencoder and ATEME of France. The aforementioned big players, Cisco, Ericsson and Arris, are also upping the ante, especially Ericsson with its virtualized encoding designed to allow mixing and matching between software and hardware based approaches.
The other two key sectors are CPE hardware, already touched on in the context of that Synergy Research report, and carrier transmission equipment, which is usually excluded from the video infrastructure sector. For CPE hardware the order is now Cisco, then Arris, followed by Pace and Technicolor in a dead heat.
In core IP routing and also carrier Ethernet, Cisco does have a majority share of about 60% and with video accounting for about 70% of total global IP traffic now and forecast to reach 90% by 2018, the case for including that in the video infrastructure segment, certainly with a little weighting, is becoming overwhelming. That would at a stroke propel Alcatel-Lucent up the league table, since it is world number two in IP routing. So while the identity of the number one is not going to change, it is far from clear who will be number two in pay TV infrastructure, even next year.