Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 December 2014

Google Verizon accord offers immunization against patent attack

If 2011-2013 were the years of repeated attacks on Android in the patent courts, 2014 was the year when Google started to hit back – not by joining the IPR arms race, as it did when it acquired Motorola Mobility, but by signing neutrality pacts with significant players such as Samsung and Cisco, and even coming to an accommodation with Apple. The latest deal is with Verizon, and the search giant portrayed the pact as a blow to patent trolls.

Details are sparse, but the long term cross-licensing deal with Verizon Wireless covers “a broad range of products and technologies”, said Kirk Dailey, head of patent transactions at Google, in a statement. More colorfully, Verizon said in a blog post that the agreement would guard against the patent troll – “the Johnny-come-lately owner of a single patent can threaten an entire innovative ecosystem,” it wrote.

By removing the risk of future litigation, the pact frees both firms to concentrate on new services, Google said. Of course, such tactics remove one of the key arguments which Microsoft, in particular, has used against Android (while collecting fees for its own Linux patents from most of the OS’s supporters) – that the Google OS exposes its licensees to the risk of lawsuits, in a way that Windows does not.

After agreements with Samsung in January, followed by similar ones with Cisco and LG, Google is starting to counteract that argument. It also settled the disputes with Apple that it inherited with its Motorola purchase, another boost to confidence in Android, though the biggest lawsuits of them all, between Apple and Samsung, are still dragging on (though the most recent ended with damages that were lower than the costs, and both players seem to be losing the appetite to behave aggressively over IPR).

Google was naive in thinking it could bring its preference for open source or patent-free technologies to the mobile world, where IPR protection and licensing fees are an intrinsic part of the business model. That mistake resulted in a hail of lawsuits being thrown at Android (though rarely directly at Google) by those better endowed with mobile patents, such as Apple and Microsoft. After paying highly for Motorola’s intellectual assets, Google has changed tack and started tempting mobile players into deals which protect them from the lawyers.

It is also vocally campaigning for patent law reform, especially in the US, to curb the activities of trolls. Verizon is supporting that aim, and its blog post says that cross-licensing can be a protection against the “innovation tax that patent trolls often collect.” It also said bipartisan deals are not adequate to reform the whole system, and called on Congress to pass new laws. The last attempt at that, a bill called the Innovation Act, gained significant Congress support in the spring but failed at the hands of Senate Democrats. The newly elected Congress, which is Republican dominated, is likely to re-launch the bill next year.

Among other attacks on patent trolls, Google and other Silicon Valley giants launched the LOT (Licence on Transfer) Network in July, aiming to reduce the risk of litigation and “patent privateering” by instituting a royalty-free cross-licensing approach. This came close to a patents pool, a well-established mechanism in some areas, but which has failed to make much headway in mobility. The LOT group particularly targets ‘non-practicing entities’ which exploit their IPR for fees but not for any other product or business. The consortium said in July that more than 6,000 lawsuits were filed by such parties in the US alone in 2013.