Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 January 2015

DTT on the brink of something in Europe, but what exactly

Anyone judging the emerging fate of digital terrestrial TV (DTT) in Europe would be utterly confused by contradictory signals both from analysts and the market itself. This partly reflects differences between countries in sentiment and policy, but more particularly a divergence between consumer demand and market dynamics.

While many people would be only too happy to receive all their premium content Free To Air over DTT, the reality is that increasingly over the last decade or more they have had to pay to watch it. This dichotomy shows up in recent observations, so that on the one hand DTT viewer numbers are still going up, while on the other, at least in some countries, the choice of what to watch on DTT is diminishing.

The latter is certainly the case in France, where commercial broadcaster TF1 has asked regulator CSA to give up the terrestrial frequency occupied by Eurosport France, which has just been sold to Discovery. This reduces further the amount of programming shown on French DTT channels and comes nine months after TF1 and another commercial broadcaster M6 decided to shut down TF6, the pair’s joint venture channel on the DTT platform.

TF6 had lost €1 million on revenues of about €17 million in its last year, as a result of a 30% fall in advertising sales, which had accounted for 50% of overall takings. Admittedly this was on the back of a general decline in French TV advertising but highlighted the vulnerability of DTT there – this particular bouquet had only 400,000 subscribers, and yet it had distribution costs of €4 million.

This bad news for DTT is countered by data from Eutelsat indicating growth in European DTT viewing. Called the Eutelsat TV Observatory, the report found that the number of European homes with only DTT reception increased from 44.2 million in 2010 to 48.2 million in 2014. This was almost exactly matched by the decline in cable TV homes from 49.5 million to 44.3 million over the same period, against a backdrop of a slight rise in total TV households from 171.4 million to 175.7 million.

And while the French picture is gloomy, prospects in Germany improved slightly during 2014 after a dismal 2013 which started with leading commercial broadcaster RTL announcing plans to ditch DTT transmission altogether. Politics came to DTT’s rescue, since Chancellor Angela Merkel, despite winning 48% of the vote in the country’s general election, still needed to enter a coalition to form a majority government. After three months of wrangling she finally entered a partnership with the Social Democrats (SPD), but this required several concessions. The headline concession was agreement to instigate a minimum wage of €8.50 an hour starting in 2015, but less well reported was a notice of intention to preserve frequencies in the 700 MHz band for broadcast usage during the transition to DVB-T2 from the first generation DVB-T technology.

This made all the difference according to RTL, which immediately announced its attention to reconsider its earlier decision to pull out of DTT broadcasting, and then six months later in June 2014 made a provisional commitment to continue transmitting FTA channels over the medium from 2016 after all.

Meanwhile the UK remains Europe’s most successful large DTT market, with the Freeview service currently gaining subscribers at least as fast as the two main pay TV offerings, BSkyB and Liberty Global’ s Virgin Media, although TalkTalk’s IPTV package and OTT offerings are growing even more quickly. The immediate future there for DTT is secure as more HD channels become available after the migration to DVB-T2 infrastructure. Now over 19 million homes – over 75% of the total – use Freeview, while for about 10.3 million, a little above 40%, it is their primary TV service, meaning that ranks effectively well above pay TV leader Sky in popularity.

Yet it is the UK’s regulator Ofcom which has been leading the European charge towards opening up some of the 700MHz spectrum band, currently used by TV broadcasters, for mobile broadband. Ofcom announced plans in November 2014 to follow Europe’s first ‘digital dividend’ in the 800MHz band with the release of 700MHz frequencies between 2020 and 2022 in the UK.

Ofcom however has been contradicted by a European Union report issued around the same time which was designed to unite broadcasters and mobile operators behind a common strategy for radio spectrum below 800 MHz. The report effectively split this spectrum in two, the so called 700 MHz band between 694 and 790 MHz and the lower sub 700 MHz band between 470 and 694 MHz The EU recommended that the sub 700 MHz band be retained for broadcasters until at least 2030, a decade or so longer than Ofcom.

It seems that the speed of the shift to delivery of broadcast channels over IP is being interpreted differently by the two parties.

We are also getting mixed messages from analysts, at least at first sight. A new report, the ‘Roadmap for the evolution of DTT’, co-authored by Digital TV standards body DigiTAG and Analysis Mason, concluded that DTT would remain the platform of choice for many viewers across Europe for the foreseeable future. But then the report conceded this would only be the case if DTT receives ongoing support of governments, industry stakeholders and viewers. A key requirement would be continued access to spectrum during technology migrations to ensure uninterrupted service, according to the report, which predicted that DTT would have to evolve again to a platform capable of supporting UHD within 3 to 12 years, depending on the market. Most countries are likely to fully adopt a profile that supports UHD and 4K TV formats alongside SD and HD, MPEG-4 and HEVC encoding, as some adjunct to DVB-T2 transmission, according to the study.

So rather than being a forecast the study is more of a call to arms. But a report from Generator Research is not shy of putting the boot into DTT, even if some of its reasoning is rather circumstantial. The report predicts that whatever happens over the next 10 years, broadcasters face the reality that they will eventually have to vacate the terrestrial airways for mobile and come to terms with migrating all their distribution to the Internet eventually. Of course the Internet will increasingly embrace the mobile network over that very spectrum that has been given up, but the difference is that broadcasting will no longer be in control of its infrastructure. The very concept of a broadcaster would go, for instead we would merely have a vertical market for content from production through wholesaling to distribution and consumption.

Generator Research bases its reasoning on the fact that although DTT consumption may be growing, the mobile industry by all measures is leaping ahead. In terms of devices, smartphone households are catching up TVs and will overtake in numbers by 2018, while for advertising the equivalent point was passed a few years ago. In 2014 worldwide revenues from mobile data were almost exactly twice the value of global expenditure on TV advertising at about $560 billion, according to the firm. Furthermore, by 2017 revenues from mobile broadband service will exceed all expenditure on all media.

What such reports forget is that whoever owns the airwaves one incontrovertible fact remains, which is that for live video being consumed by larger numbers of people, bandwidth and spectrum will remain at a premium, given that resolutions are still increasing. That means that mobile operators will also need some way of multicasting, not just to the cell tower, but right to the end device. That is why there has been so much interest in LTE Broadcast and why it being pushed hard across the mobile device ecosystem by the likes of Ericsson and Qualcomm.

Putting all this together we can say that DTT’s future looks OK for the short to medium term with significant regional and country variations, but that in the long term it will either fade out or merge with mobile. The future of broadcasting though, or at least multicasting, is secure.