Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 October 2015

Vodafone adds its voice to rivals that want BT broken up

The UK newspapers this week reported Vodafone joining the list of companies calling for the breakup of incumbent telco BT, as a response to regulator Ofcom’s sector consultation on the future of telecommunications.

The issue is fixed broadband, and Vodafone adds its weight to Sky and TalkTalk who are also major rivals in delivering broadband in the UK. They all want BT OpenReach, which runs the copper loops in the UK, to be separated from the rest of BT.

The truth is this is very unlikely to happen. OpenReach was set up under a compromise deal with Ofcom in 2006, to dis-entangle the way that broadband lines were allocated, from the core residential customer facing parts of BT. OpenReach was to treat Vodafone, TalkTalk and Sky the same as it treats the rest of BT, and at an arm’s length price.

That came about as a result of a previous 10 year Ofcom review. Since then the UK unbundled local loop has thrived, and now wholesaling, through VULA rules (Virtual Unbundled Local Access) is being pioneered for all of Europe by Ofcom. VULA came about because to get to the next stage in DSL broadband, a single entity needs to cancel all cross talk in the wiring bundle, to extend the reach and bandwidth of VDSL lines. BT wants to take on this role, asking rivals to give back their local loops and in return BT will offer virtual bandwidth back to their customers.

The concern is that while broadband has become enormously competitive in the UK over the past ten years, shifting to a single entity cancelling cross talk may change the balance of power in favor of that entity, especially if it also has a residential broadband offering.

The options laid out by Ofcom when it put out the consultation in July were to 1) Leave things as they are; 2) Strengthen the current model by varying BT’s voluntary undertakings; 3) Consider a breakup or 4) Reduce the amount of regulation and let everyone simply compete.

These are mostly empty threats to BT. Ofcom wants to change some of the undertakings and there is no political will to do any more than that. Remember the last review resulted in a 40% fall in the price of broadband in the UK, in a market where superfast broadband uptake is double the average across Europe, with TV being offered successfully over broadband and pay TV growing from 44% of homes to 59% of homes in that decade. That’s not a regulatory environment you want to make root and branch changes to and that success has given Ofcom something of a leadership role amount other regulators in Europe.

Vodafone claims this week that BT has made £6.5 billion in excessive profits over the past 10 years at Openreach and that these profits give BT an unfair advantage. It may be true that this allowed BT to bring to market the TV channel BT Sport, using it to outbid Sky for major sports rights. And on the back of that, it introduced a far more successful TV package than it had previously. It did this by giving broadband signups free access to BT Sport.

This all kicked off perhaps because in May 2013 TalkTalk, a rival broadband provider in the UK, made a complaint and Ofcom responded by opening an investigation. TalkTalk said BT had abused a dominant position in the supply of superfast broadband and failed to maintain a sufficient margin between its upstream and downstream prices, thereby operating an abusive margin squeeze. Ofcom decided that there was no case to answer, but proceeded to a new unbundling model.

Ofcom, after consulting with the European Commission, decided to include the unit costs of BT Sport in its calculation saying, “We consider the VULA margin control will have limited impact on BT’s incentives to bid for future rights. We accept that, under our proposals, higher net BT Sport costs will increase the VULA margin that BT needs to maintain. However, even absent regulation, we would expect BT to only bid for content where the associated revenues outweigh the rights costs. . .” It says much the same about offering a free set top box for its BT TV and concludes that BT has other advantages that will make up for including these costs prior to calculating the wholesale maximum price.

So now BT’s VULA cost calculation includes the costs for marketing, customer service, billing and bad debt, labor, R&D, accommodation, IT spend, and marketing platform spend, among others, including all costs of BT sport. This sets a minimum price for residential broadband for BT, and it’s wholesale prices are calculated to include none of these, leaving room for a decent margin for rivals.

BT says that the UK is the “most digitally advanced nation in the G20”, in part owing to its “multibillion-pound investment in broadband”. It labelled Vodafone’s claims “misleading” and said it had ambitious plans for the next decade that will take the UK from “a superfast nation to an ultrafast one”.

Sky, Vodafone and TalkTalk all want to make an investment in faster fiber services, but worry that BT will undercut its prices using G.fast and its existing infrastructure.

We know not everyone is a fan of local loop unbundling or VULA unbundling, but it has worked miracles in the UK and before it started, you could wait months for a broadband line of 500 kbps. So we suspect little to no change will come of this consultation.