There is every indication that homes will need a wireline backbone to support WiFi whose shortcomings, even the 11ac version, have become obvious with the increasing use of mobile devices within the home, the coming proliferation 4K capable devices and future bandwidth-hungry applications such as telemedicine and video calls.
We have from day one supported the companies developing the G.hn home network technology under the umbrella of the HomeGrid Forum. At that time we first reported on G.hn in 2008, we thought that a better technology was needed for powerline and for telephone wiring, both of which the G.hn crowd promised along with faster networking over coax – although MoCA appeared to be filling that need – and still does.
G.hn has taken much longer to develop than anyone expected, including its developers. The coax version of G.hn, for example, is just now coming to market and is, as far as we know currently available only from one equipment maker – Comtrend. Since G.hn’s early days, new versions of HomePlug and MoCA have been developed and used in products that are being shipped to consumers and service providers – HomePlug, notably AV2 and MIMO, and MoCA’s coax technology, the 2.0 version. Both technologies are faster and more reliable than they were when development of G.hn began. Both new versions are interoperable with their prior versions – although at the prior versions’ slower speeds and fewer capabilities. And, we have not heard any talk of G.hn over phone lines in a long time.
Now we come to the heart of the matter: “Does the world need another coax home network technology – in addition to MoCA? Specifically does it need the coax version of G.hn?
MoCA’s overwhelming acceptance by cablecos and satcos plus selected telcos indicates that MoCA performs as well or better than consumers need. MoCA is beginning to appear in a few pieces of CE gear that consumers buy directly – such as TiVo’s DVRs and satellite set tops.
However, the fact that no major service provider has begun mass deployments to all its subscribers of HomePlug – in the way that many service providers have done with MoCA – indicates the shortcomings of powerline technologies, shortcomings that perhaps cannot be overcome sufficiently to deliver flicker-free video in every room of every home. The home’s electrical lines are filled with lots of disruptive noises and interference, unlike the home’s coax cables which have only been used to transmit video. In the powerline tests we conducted we found significant differences in performance from room-to-room. A pay TV service cannot risk those variables – especially now that OTT services are breathing down their necks for consumer viewing time. HomePlug is shipped in Europe from a number of Telcos for their TV offerings, but it is done as an add-on that is optional for each home, as if to say, “It’s not a core part of our offering.”
Recent tests of HomePlug AV2 and G.hn by our US partner Rider Research showed that G.hn does perform better in most cases in the standalone home and the apartment in which we tested – so there has been some progress. Whether it’s enough improvement to make consumers and service providers happy remains to be seen. MoCA may be a better solution for consumers now that Actiontec has started shipping at retail MoCA 2.0-to-11ac WiFi adapters which have Quantenna’s super-charged WiFi chips – at least in every room that has a coax outlet. Even Comtrend said in its announcement of the G.hn-over-coax adapter, that some consumers may be looking for an improvement to powerline performance.
The case was made early on that because G.hn worked on all the home’s wires, consumers could use both coax and powerline in the same home – that adapters could be made that were both powerline and coax so a consumer or service provider could use the same adapter for either or both – coax to some rooms and powerline to others, all interconnected. We have yet to see any such dual adapters.
Last week was the first announcement of a G.hn over coax adapter, which we reported. The announcement raises several questions; firstly whether Comtrend’s GCA-6000 G.hn Ethernet-over-coax adapter would have to compete directly with MoCA-based Ethernet-over-coax adapter. The question is: How are they going to compete with MoCA exactly? What are the advantages that G.hn-over-coax has over MoCA 2.0? So far we have not been able to obtain the Comtrend units for testing – although it’s still early in the game.
Secondly the MoCA products which have been on the market for over a decade and have been very, very successful. The G.hn EoC adapters may be aimed at appealing to telcos, except Verizon and AT&T’s DirecTV, who do not want to compete against cablecos that are deploying the same home networking technology.
The fact is that AT&T is now the largest deployer of MoCA by virtue of having acquired DirecTV and they are not going to switch from MoCA to G.hn. HomeGrid has said for years that AT&T was a supporter of G.hn.
But it would be too expensive and besides G.hn is a new technology. Verizon has been deploying MoCA from the day it began offering FiOS and is not likely to change. MoCA has made other inroads into telcos. Cincinnati Bell and Frontier use MoCA. So does Google Fiber. We have been told that other telcos are evaluating MoCA.
Then there’s Europe and Asia, which are by and large virgin territories when it comes to wireline home networking. Our sense was that G.hn had jumped to a big edge in China, potentially the world’s largest home network market, but both MoCA and HomePlug seem recently to have increased their efforts there. Despite prior announcements by the HomeGrid Forum, China Telecom and TV makers Skyworth, Skyworth, Hisense, Haier, TCL, Changhong and Konka (which were said to be making TVs with G.hn built-in), China seems like a wide-open market.
Because of the Chinese government’s involvement, the Chinese home network market is even more sharply divided than North America and Europe. It seems that within an MDU, cablecos can only use coax, Ethernet and fiber, but not phone wires; telcos can only use telephone wires, Ethernet and fiber, but not coax. The third part of the market is Chinese consumers who buy what is available and, usually, the cheapest thing that works.
In China because of the predominance of MDUs, there is an added layer in networking: connecting the incoming broadband, increasingly fiber, to the residence – which could be done by coax, phone wires, Ethernet CAT 5 cables, or even more fiber. Within the residence, the choices are the same as elsewhere – wireline or WiFi. Because of the thin walls and tiny size of residences in an MDU, WiFi interference can be a problem, hence the need for a wireline solution.
As far as we know, Broadcom is still pushing its DOCSIS-based EoC (Ethernet over coax) in China and Qualcomm its HomePlug-based EoC. One other complication in the market is that the Chinese are still developing an EoC technology called HiNOC although we do not know of anyone that is currently making HiNOC chips.
What we do know is that both HomePlug and MoCA recently feel rejuvenated about their opportunities with cablecos and telcos in China.
This first ran in Rider Research’s Online Reporter