Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 October 2015

Sckipio – Cruising in the slipstream of the Alcatel giant

Like most technology markets, the winners and losers in the Gbps fixed broadband market depend upon who you last spoke to, they are either Alcatel or Sckipio or neither as cable based DOCSIS 3.1 shows its hand. Fiber to the home is not really still in the equation, except in Russia and a handful of Green Field sites in Europe.

This week we didn’t just ask, but attended Broadband World Forum and saw for ourselves some of the things which point to, perhaps not to a winner, but maybe the current leader, in the war for hearts and minds of the telco community in G.fast.

Sckipio was quietly demonstrating in one of the two interop pavilions, two differently branded G.fast devices built around its chips, talking to one another. One was unsurprisingly from existing partner Calix, while the other came with an Arris label on the side. Arris to date has not really been part of the Telco broadband supply market, and has yet to place its vote in the purchase of a particular chip, but this is the closest it has come to it, and it looks like it will put its strength behind Sckipio.

Arris is in the process of buying Pace, a deal that has got it into trouble with US regulators, who said this week they want to examine the deal in earnest which means that completion of the deal will move back into end of Q1 2016 and may come with “remedies” such as selling off some parts of Pace. One such part could be its old 2Wire business, which accounts for its Telco home gateway design with wins at AT&T and BT, to name but a few.

Interestingly at the BBWF show, while Alcatel was telling anyone who would listen that it has trials at BT and a deal at Hong Kong’s Chunghwa, BT was demonstrating a device which also had the Sckipio chip in it. Strange that. We said back in August that British Telecom had opened its trials up to 2,000 homes in Cambridgeshire to all communications providers on equal terms. But in early October Alcatel hit back announcing another 2,000 home G.fast consumer trial in Gosforth in the North-East of England. However this trial cites speeds of up to 330 Mbps, still way below the 1 Gbps line that most telcos want to target. This trial is for 6 to 9 months

Sckipio announcements at the BBWF include a full 1 Gbps over 300 meters, using not one, but two copper twisted pairs, using a bonded approach. Spokesman for Sckipio Michael Weissman told us that this could deliver up to 2 Gbps, over very short distances like 50 meters. We then asked about plans at AT&T, which to our understanding has yet to ship VDSL2 vectoring and still tries to get away with broadband lines in the 50 Mbps range, which is why it has not gained a single increase in broadband customers since 2007, when, like today, it had just over 16 million broadband customers.

Key to AT&T’s deal with the FCC, over the conditions under which it could acquire DirecTV, was for it to become a viable broadband supplier in the US. This was worded as “Within 4 years, AT&T will offer its all-fiber Internet access service to at least 12.5 million customer locations, such as residences, home offices and very small businesses.” These were effectively additional lines summed up by “Combined with AT&T’s existing high-speed broadband network, at least 25.7 million customer locations will have access to broadband speeds of 45Mbps or higher.”

We would contend that a G.fast line, especially a bonded G.fast line, would allow AT&T to meet that condition. It could meet it even with VDSL vectored lines, but since G.fast is on the way to being much the same price to install as Vectored VDSL, AT&T could go this route. IN all headlines to date these lines had been considered to “have to be” fiber.

However it does that, its loop lengths must continue to get smaller and smaller, but any order from AT&T could become the “big one” in terms of dictating who is winning in the broadband war. Remember AT&T created the DSL business when it first gave a contract to tiny Amati Communications, a business led by the current ASSIA CEO and founder, John Cioffi. That company was bought the day after the order was placed by Texas Instruments, and you wouldn’t bet that something similar could happen once again.

If AT&T remains with Arris (Pace 2Wire) as its incumbent for home gateways that business may go to Sckipio. If it remains with Alcatel as its broadband infrastructure partner, that may go to an Alcatel solution – however, critical to Sckipio’s ambition in this area is to open up Alcatel products to the lure of its chip.

Right now Alcatel is tied to the Broadcom chipset, separating its 30 or so trials around the world into those which only use the Broadcom G.fast chips, and those which also do the cross talk cancellation on the line cards installed in the central office, on chips designed by Alcatel.

But one announcement by Sckipio at the show as a new relationship with China’s Cambridge Industries Group, an independent technology firm which supports ODMs in building devices around new technologies such as G.fast. To date CIG has been focused on GPON. If Alcatel is told by a major operator (such as AT&T) “We want this chip inside a box which links to a GPON back end,” it would ask companies like CIG if it can show a working integration – rather than lose the business, and then it can rapidly adopt it. It is one way into Alcatel and many of the local Chinese ODMs, and this deal speaks to Sckipio thinking about the future, and how to nail down a deal like AT&T. Since that Amati deal, AT&T has been fairly slow to finally order new devices, but is always an early partner in chips built by start-ups. Look at how it has adopted Quantenna WiFi chips into its CPE, after just the second Quantenna chipset – that deal leading to key investments in Quantenna at a critical phase in its development.

Alcatel may find the CPE deal at AT&T goes to Arris, while the infrastructure part of a deal goes to Alcatel – it has to be ready for such an eventuality.

Meanwhile among its own announcements at the show Alcatel claims it has nailed the G.fast business at Australia’s National Broadband Network (NBN) with a trial of G.fast fiber-to-the-basement (FttB) technology, which it says achieves throughputs of 800Mbps down and 200 Mbps up, aggregating 1 Gbps.

NBN is the government controlled business taking over existing broadband networks of Foxtel and Telstra (cable and telco) to ensure Australia does not miss out on rapid broadband. So the winner of that deal will have a massive boost, because it’s virtually all the broadband in Australia. But then again it would be insane for the NBN to give all that business to a single supplier, especially one that in the past has offered proprietary connections to its devices, in order to shut out competition. So while this is good news for Alcatel, we would expect a similar involvement from a second source. Alcatel, as we said, claims 30 live G.fast trials. Sckipio claims it has 30 active customers (mostly equipment vendors) and 50 design projects – end device designs which operators want to try out from those vendors. It’s about a draw right now.

Finally Sckipio also talked about a new 32 port G.fast Distribution point for MDUs, the first to distribute vectoring across 32 copper pairs in a single distribution device – all previous devices have supported just 16 ports. By combining this with Simpler Network’s EZ-Edge 100-port Automated Distribution Frame, Sckipio claims that telcos can wire up an entire 100-resident apartment building at half the cost. So clearly it remains focused on the processes of how you install broadband – backhauled by GPON and split into lines to go inside an MDU.

Alcatel-Lucent at the show talked about Vplus products as well, filling in the gap between VDSL2 vectoring and G.fast. Actually this is just by switching the CPE to work in 35 MHz instead of 17 MHz, and was launched over a year ago by Alcatel, so this is just another VDSL profile really.

It also showed its TWDM-PON (Time and Wavelength Division Multiplexed Passive Optical Networks) portfolio which ups backhaul from 2.5 Gbps to 10 Gbps – an essential part of backhauling a G.fast network, again introduced over a year ago by Alcatel.

At the BBWF show Broadcom attacked the passive optical network (PON) market as well with an optical line terminals (OLTs). Its new chip is a multi-mode SoC which supports existing and next-generation fiber technologies.

Broadcom’s BCM68620 also offers support for the new G.989 NGPON-2 protocol, due in the first half of 2016, which it says is idea for Software Defined Networking (SDN) management practices.