Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 October 2015

Marvell pushes out first G.hn 200 chip

Another player making waves at Broadband World Forum this week was Marvell, showing off the next generation of G.hn technology which it claimed delivered 2 Gbps over any wire. The new version of G.hn uses 200 MHz of spectrum and Marvell claims it is the perfect backhaul for wave 2 802.11ac WiFi.

HomeGrid Forum, the alliance built around G.hn has barely got through launching its first generation technology and has little market share to speak of at this point, although some significant design wins. Whether or not it is ready to push on to a second generation is moot. New devices based on this version are due to be announced later this year, are based on the latest version of the ITU-T standard for G.hn, with the draft standard due for approval in February 2016. It achieves this basically by supporting a 200MHz wide channel, rather than 80 MHz.

Back in 2010 concerns arose about regulatory conformance in using the 100 MHz to 200 MHz channels, and so they were dropped from G.hn and its power level was also reduced, one of its biggest setbacks. Presumably this means that G.hn 200 (as HomeGrid is calling it) will suffer regulatory issues as it tries to roll this technology out in some regions although clearly some progress has been made on electrical power levels.

A blog from Chano Gomez, director – Broadband Solutions Group at Marvell back in August first mentioned the new version, confirming that this is all that HomeGrid has done. It was HomeGrid that called out Atheros when it did much the same thing within the HomePlug standard, accusing it of making false claims around the technology in 2011, with its AR7400, which it said offered 500 Mbps in powerline using HomePlug AV. This was a blind alley which almost never shipped in volume, but kept the HomePlug headline speeds up while it actually went and built a real HomePlug AV2 technology. We think this is more or less the same for G.hn, and it will have limited appeal.

The war that is going on right now – between MoCA which has been boasting its MoCA 2.0 performs at 400 Mbps real world speed at 90% of connections last week; at HomePlug which has tried to claim it is fast enough for 4K support last year, and G.hn now with this release – is to steal the high ground as a backhaul for Wave 2.0 802.11ac WiFi. In truth we are looking at 300 Mbps to 600 Mbps genuine average backhaul need for an Access Point in this technology, and all of these technologies, with the possible exception of HomePlug AV2, are fast enough. But some connections are not average, and backhaul links may need to be faster.

But with all the claims made in WiFi chips that they offer Gigabit performance and scale up to 10 Gbps, is makes it sound dumb if it is backhauled by a 1 Gbps technology, never mind a 400 Mbps technology – but that’s the truth.

It is true that a typical use case of 2 x 4K streams being delivered around the home, with one coming from the internet, and another from a DVR, plus a couple more HD streams to tablets and the like, might mean that WiFi actually carries something more like 100 Mbps constantly, across multiple beams. Even a backhaul technology like HomePlug AV or AV2 or G.hn should be man enough to carry all of those over a single, contention network. So this is really a PR battle, little more, for that space.

At the same conference multiple carriers and equipment vendors are discussing plans for upgrading their access networks to 10G PON technology, and finding a home-networking technology that can keep up with the access network is a key part of their strategy. So you get the idea of 10 Gbps to an MDU building, 1 Gbps to each home using Ethernet over Coax, and 300 Mbps around each home, as a “real world” scenario.

In addition to the increased 2 Gbps speed, the latest wave of G.hn products will include LDPC Forward Error Correction, automatic detection and retransmission of packets with CRC errors, and remote spectrum management, said HomeGrid.

It also claims that the new G.hn standard uses dramatically less power than current Coax networking standards and Marvell’s 2 Gbps technology also takes up far less space on circuit boards.