Later today the FCC will either have voted in a new set of set top leasing regulations or it will have been defeated, so anything we say will be overtaken by events. But it is worth making a few points, as many voices have been raised this week on both sides of the argument.
If the FCC insists that MVPDs open their networks to pretty much any new device, there will be a legal push back. There are genuine issues of security, which these days goes right down to which security platforms are supported in silicon on Broadcom and other chips, and there is the potential for savage unintended consequences and legal actions galore.
If you turn the US set top market into a retail proposition, then the business model of all US pay TV will change overnight. Devices will still need to be “ratified” as secure and adhering to standards, but also if the FCC allows a divorce between the UI and the service, and opening up devices to third party services, then MVPDS will lose their service look and feel. What happens to a consumer who cannot understand how his or her new UI works? Does he call his MVPD, or the device maker? Or the software company that sold the device maker a media player? Or does he throw it in the bin and buy a new one, costing him more?
If the proposal from the FCC is really about preventing the cable operators raking tons of cash off consumers, rated in the $6 billion to $14 billion a year bracket by the FCC, we can all agree that should change. But why is the only way to achieve that to “open” the device to full retail. Surely a simple economic formula which places a value on each box, or each function that a box has, and only allows a rental-to-purchase price ratio in line with common hire purchase deals. That would achieve the same result. Effectively a consent decree from the industry to only charge what the devices costs, plus a bit for profit.
If a box is sold to Comcast at $100 and it charges $231 a month for five years for that rental, it should be forced to offer it in multiple ways; as a hire purchase it might be worth $100, plus 30% profit, paid over 2 years plus 12.5% of its value in maintenance each year. Leading to a monthly price of under $6 a month, more like $72 a year instead of the $231 which the FCC says pay TV operators charge. Sure MVPDs would then load the price they say they are purchasing at with extra costs, like R&D and testing and software support and pretty soon, if this was not well policed, we would be back where we began. So police it.
Outside of the US, this is typically the type of solution that regulators put in place. They do not force everyone to have a Roku or TiVo box instead, as it’s none of their business which device a consumer chooses, only the price they pay is their business.
Inside the US, regulators do not like telling their major corporations what they can do economically as it generally leads to a legal action and a court room battle where the MVPD can claim that the device pricing is both secret and far higher than it really is. US courts will not let a regulator force an operator to run any part of its business at a loss and are easily convinced to over-rule this type of strategy. We have seen this with network pricing and unbundling, which has worked everywhere else, but not in the US.
Simply asking each operator to offer 4 or 5 designs of his own choosing for each level of set top, from 4 or 5 different device makers, may well achieve this, but the MVPD will then load costs onto this for the increased negotiation, testing and support, and once again, pretty soon set tops would rise in price. Supporting multiple boxes is very expensive so you have to support single APIs and let the box makers do self-testing. Having too many boxes also stifles innovation, when you have 25 different old devices which are not capable of next gen service and so have to wait before introducing it.
It is true that the Arris business in the US is a license to make profit and that its designs survive in the field way longer than they would in a retail market. And just because we are moving to OTT, there will be no automatic end to this process. The old Motorola Home business will always get the bulk of US set top supply, and the cable operators will continue to lease such a device for 9 to 10 years, for as long as consumers will put up with that old-style of user interface.
The silliness of this rule-making is that already there is an incentive to move away from older designs. At some point every device will support HTML 5.0, which in turn supports any UI, but would need chip support to keep up natively with new video formats. However due to the short-sightedness of all the browser players, Google, Microsoft and Apple, there is a temptation to allow one DRM to operate for free, and in some browsers for only its native DRM to work at all. Vested interests here prevent this being the right route to go down.
This has meant that the TV industry has had to go down the App route. Writing a new app for each OS is not so problematic these days, and security and other services can be plugged in accordingly and most sit in the cloud. But where an App has to run on a TV or set top, that places MVPD market control once again in the hands of the same companies, those which own App Stores and they could charge for service or even refuse to distribute these Apps for free.
Whichever way the FCC falls, it risks not solving the problem as there is operator push-back and heal dragging. And yet there is an economic shift in the direction of the type of open set top they are advocating. Why not just let that play out. Failure by an MVPD to open their programming to OTT delivery and therefore any device, will mean putting itself at an economic disadvantage.
However, the FCC is right about one thing. Even if an MVPD used Apple TV as its main set top, it would still prevent any alteration to the way its services are presented, and start charging a lease premium for the Apple TV for far too long. A failure to act, will mean preserving the status quo for quite a long time into the future.
Roughly 50% of the cost of any network is the cost of the CPEs, so an MVPD giving up the expense of its CPEs would be to its advantage. Verizon and AT&T have managed this with their new approach to selling smartphones, effectively making them hire purchase deals. Why not use the same here?
At Faultline we are sure a rule-making could be achieved which makes sense although that would be tough in this totally negative industry environment. It might both save the consumer from paying $231 a year to lease a cable box worth just $100, for 8 or 9 years, and it might not mean that the MVPD loses its service identity behind a new, but experimental, UI, which glorifies the supplier brand, and hides the MVPD service brand.
AT&T VP of Federal Regulatory, Stacy Fuller made the point this week that if this happens then privacy rules would go out the window, and the emergence of advertising all over the programming could potentially wreck existing content deals.
Ex-FCC chairman Michael Powell now NCTA President and CEO said this week that the FCC’s proposal will take seven years to implement and end up costing consumers even more than they’re paying now and he threatened court action on behalf of the NCTA. Good luck with that decision.