We are a little baffled by the new kid in the block, Ampere Analysis, a UK-based spin out from IHS, which suggests that US skinny bundles may reach 3.5 million by the end of 2017. It passed that level in early 2017.
Any rough count would put Sling TV at over 1 million, Showtime and CBS All Access each on 1.2 million, and HBO Now on 2 million. Most of these are reported figures, with the exception of Sling TV, which you have to make an estimate of from last year’s run rate. Then there is Comcast Stream, DirecTV Now, Sony Vue and the new Hulu skinny bundle, YouTube TV, not to mention Go90 and anything that Verizon launches in the coming months. Surely, we are way over 4 million today, rising to 10 to 12 million or higher by the end of this year. Although we can accept that some of these numbers are high and one or two have begun going backwards, we cannot accept they will fall below 3.5 million ever again or anywhere close.
Let’s follow Ampere’s logic a bit further. It suggests that the US’s new wave of OTT TV ‘skinny bundle’ providers will offer a more direct competitive challenge to cable and satellite TV players than Netflix and Amazon. Not really, what is needed are three or four cheap services to buy instead of taking one cable service. So Netflix and Amazon are part and parcel of the disruption.
It’s interesting. When Faultline Online Reporter in 2013 suggested that TV content would slowly be “unbundled” we were inundated by analysts who could not see “how” this would happen. We made it clear that selling online would require selling cheaper and only the best content, and that this would narrow down the bundle considerably. Online you have to search for content, on a TV you can just keep turning the dial. They are different discovery routes.
And while we feel this process will continue, others point out that it is just as likely that once new market leaders in Advertising VoD (AVoD) are established, they will become dominant. Go90 shows that’s not going to happen because Verizon has launched a service it cannot even give away.
Ampere goes on to forecast that pay TV penetration will drop below 70% before 2020 and already maps household pay TV penetration falling past 80% in Q3 2015 in the US and then reached 76.5% at the end of 2016. The thing is, we think this is a tipping point. At every step of cord cutting, it has been accelerating. It may well be a gradual decline from 80% of homes having pay TV, to 76.5%, but that does not mean that it is gradual from 73% to 70% a year or two later. More time will lead to more advocates of skinny bundles who “show” other people how they have changed their viewing experience and it turns rapidly into an avalanche. Pinning down that acceleration point is tough, is it when 25% of the market have skinny bundles? Around 25 million? Or is it when 7 or 8 million constantly tell their friends on social media what platform they were watching last night?
Ampere has asked US consumers and says that almost 50% of US internet users could see their household no longer watching broadcast TV in the next five years. For that to happen it means that 10% (roughly 10 million) more could drop out in a year or so, and for that to happen some 30 million (3 per home) OTT services might need to be signed up for. You see one is counted in homes, the others in individuals.
Half are already using online video services as the main way to watch TV. Which is our point exactly – it is not a linear relationship – for every skinny bundle sold, that does not mean a cable cord cut. But once two or three services are being used at once, in the same home, there is every chance that there remains no further reason to sustain a pay TV deal, unless blackmailed into it by a cable company who charges way more for broadband, without TV, than it does with.
Toby Holleran, Analyst at Ampere Analysis said: “Longer-term, we believe that the rapid growth in the VMSO market will offset the continuing decline in traditional pay TV subscriptions.” That is so nice and optimistic of you, Toby. We have often made the point that losing an $80 to $100 a month subscription on pay TV, in favour of a $20, or two $20 OTT services, is still a substantial net loss of revenue for the industry and that this is already rampant at Dish. That’s not really an offset. Toby, you need to tell your clients the amount of pain they are about to go through, get out of the IHS cosy habit of telling them it will all be fine.