Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 April 2018

Soft landing for premium sports bubble as OTT plays long game

Spain’s La Liga remains in the spotlight as it strives unsuccessfully to close the gap on the English Premier League (EPL) as the world’s most valuable football property for TV rights. But this is really a story of a bubble inside another bubble and does not entirely reflect the global picture, which varies between countries and with the choice of sport.

There is clear evidence that longstanding gains in TV audiences for the big premium sports, primarily American football, baseball and basketball in the US and soccer football elsewhere, have tailed off or even reversed. Yet it is only football rights prices in Europe that have stalled or even slipped in the latest rounds covering the next few seasons and then only on the domestic front.

In fact while the EPL’s failure to increase its domestic rights takings for the three seasons from 2019/20 attracted much publicity it is likely international rights will be close to £5 billion for the same period, an increase of £2 billion. The EPL will therefore enjoy another substantial hike in TV takings as a whole. International audiences for European football in the US, China and much of SE Asia in particular are still growing fast.

The situation is different in the US where the big three sports tend to attract huge live domestic audiences across all TV platforms at particular times, notably the National Football League (NFL) Thursday Night Football. Although live TV ratings for that declined by about 10% over 2017 that has not yet at least dented enthusiasm for the rights. Twenty-First Century Fox had to pay $3.3 billion for Thursday Night broadcast rights covering the next five years, or $60 million per game, which is 50% more than CBS and NBC paid per game in 2017 for a year.

The reason is that NFL still represents the country’s biggest live audience all watching at the same time and so present a massive target for big brand ads. US TV advertising is still a $70 billion annual market and big iconic sporting events draw the biggest fees for spot ads. Broadcasters therefore feel they have to be there to compete to a greater extent perhaps than say in the UK, where EPL audiences are confined to the two pay TV platforms Sky and BT. It is notable that the two have come up with a mutual agreement to show each other’s EPL games to maximize reach.

OTT is the other big dimension here and hopes that the big players Amazon, Google and Facebook would weigh in to sustain the inflationary spiral proved unfounded in the UK. The same has now happened in Spain, where La Liga’s strategy had been distorted by the EPL’s bubble within a bubble, aiming to achieve parity this time round through a big rise in rights revenues. Late in 2017 La Liga was openly appealing to the big OTT players to come in, hoping this would provoke the existing rights holders such as Telefonica into raising their stakes.

But existing rights holders actually came together in an informal revolt to hold down prices and that appears to have succeeded. We reported earlier that Telefonica had declined to bid for the next round of domestic La Liga rights while Vodafone Spain called for a new variable cost model where it would pay a fee per subscriber, so that the rights owner would share the risk. Now we hear that La Liga is resigned to falling short on all fronts, domestic, European and global markets. It had aimed to secure around $400 million from Europe, $1.3 billion across international markets at double the present rate and $1.7 billion domestically, about 30% up.

OTT players have held off there too for similar reasons, principally that competing directly for overall sporting rights does not suit their business model at the prices they would have to pay. They would likely be unable to recoup the outlay, so they would only pay if this achieved longer term gains in audiences or potential for earning advertising revenue. The position varies between the players, with Facebook, Twitter and other social media platforms being distinct in relying on advertising income alone. With viewing on such platforms mostly on mobile devices they would never be able to recoup anything near what they would have to spend for say La Liga domestic sports rights. They would be more interested in the international rights given that audiences are growing rapidly, and that OTT then really comes into its own with the scope for aggregation across the world.

In the case of Amazon, the objective is to gain subscribers to Prime and then charge supplements for sports as well as other premium content, along with advertising. Again though they would be highly unlikely to recoup the cost of full rights. In the case of the NFL however, streaming-only rights has attracted heavy bidding this time round with signs that this bubble is still inflating very nicely. This is despite online audiences for game so far being less than mouth-watering.

Amazon, which held the 2017 streaming rights for NFL Thursday Night Football, reached an average of 310,000 viewers, so it was far from the most popular asset on its service. However it was a simultaneous audience rather than fragmented across time and Amazon is bidding again in the knowledge that live audiences help gain access to that advertising revenue and that the time has come to strike. In 2016 Twitter paid $10 million for those Thursday NFL rights, with Amazon then paying $50 million for 2017 and signs that it will go well over $100 million for 2018, or even more per year if it is a multi-year deal as expected.

But the OTT threat in sports will probably come strongest on the international front, with an example being Turner in the US, which is launching a standalone premium sports streaming service on the back of European Champions League and Europa League football rights in the country for the three seasons from 2018. Turner has exclusive English-language rights for the two competitions in the US and hopes to ride rising popularity of the events to become a substantial US OTT player.

By a similar token, Twitter’s bid for Thursday night NFL was motivated by the hope it would gain international viewing from among its 800 million worldwide users. This did not quite materialize with only 2 million viewers compared to the 48 million watching on TV in the US. Feedback suggested viewers were put off by seeing live tweets alongside the game, detracting from their overall experience and Twitter failed to regain the slot next time round. Then Amazon did better, attracting 18.4 million viewers over 224 countries and boosted overall consumption of the Thursday Night Games by 2.5%.

For premium sports the biggest threat may come from going direct to the consumer. Some first line rights holders such as Formula 1 and the International Tennis Federation (ITF) are planning to launch their own OTT platforms for live streaming of events. Disney is also one to watch, having taken majority control of BAMTech, the Major League Baseball’s streaming outlet in the US, so games could be shown via Disney’s forthcoming OTT service.

Finally it is worth mentioning the Olympics, which although only every four years attracts huge global audiences at that time and is ripe for OTT because of the ease of flipping between multiple events and different views. Discovery has made a major move here by acquiring European rights to the Olympics which will be available via its Eurosport Player.

So far there is no sign of the really big rights holders such as the EFL or NFL going direct but they will certainly be watching the experience of others. Meanwhile for big broadcasters heavily reliant on sports such as Sky, the risk is that if the premium events are fragmented more across platforms, churn will start to increase and they will in turn be unable to pay so much for the rights. At this time though the rights holders are keen at least to maintain the value of rights packages and so are reluctant yet to do anything to kill the goose that lays these golden eggs. But a point may soon be reached when the cart tips over.