Deceased games producer Terminal Reality, which has re-emerged as a private company controlling the patents around its Infernal Engine game rendering software, is suing Microsoft for using its lighting and shadowing patents in its games, including Halo 5.
We’re torn by this one, in that methods for creating shadows in games go back well into the early 1990s and there is plenty of prior art, much of it expired. Even the legendary ID Software (wrote Doom) got into shadowing issues when the man who invented its shadowing algorithms found that his co-worker had sold the patents to someone else and he could not open source them when Doom 3 came out. That was back in the 1998 time frame, and that debacle pre-dates these patents from Terminal Reality and sound similar.
And there are patents on how to calculate shadow going all the way back to 1995 when Silicon Graphics acquired Alias Research of Toronto, which gave us Jurassic Park animation, complete with shadows, and Silicon Graphics also produced entire 3D imaging systems (OpenGL) and put this into Open source.
So to us there is enough prior art to squash flat any shadowing system, but on the other hand, Microsoft was a long term user of the Infernal Engine in the past and just because Terminal Reality went bust in 2013, Microsoft almost certainly thought its rendering engine was also dead or could be used with impunity.
Anyway the lawsuit is now filed, and it follows on from one brought in 2016 against Electronic Arts for the same thing, which a court upheld, so there may be something to it.
The patents – numbers 6,362,822 and 7,061,488 read like nothing extraordinary – just a way of calculating the shadow given artificial lights in the games – a trick which has been around since early Doom, in the early 90s. They relate as we say to lighting and shadowing methods and the techniques were used in Terminal reality games such as Nocturne, Bloodrayne and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct and resulted in the Infernal Engine which was in turn licensed to other gaming studios. We suspect an Infernal Engine license would not have broken the bank at Microsoft.