Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 June 2018

US Court hears happy end to 7 year Apple Samsung dispute

News came out this week of the US District Court of Northern California, that the 7 year long dispute between Apple and Samsung is now completely over, with the last few items having been settled out of court. This leaves Apple to focus on suing its suppliers such as Qualcomm instead. It sure as hell won’t focus on re-inventing itself.

This is the court in the same state as Apple’s HQ, where a local jury initially agreed with Apple that Samsung should pay over $1 billion in damages, and this has since been reduced back to $539 million, back in May after a visit of the case to the US Supreme Court. Further complaints were due to be heard by the same court, as new patent issues arose, and it is these which are now settled. Presumably Apple has finally agreed to pay Samsung something for its cellular patents which are genuine, unlike the Apple design patents which are laughable.

Patent claims between the two outside the US were all settled in 2014, and despite this being one of the worst “home” court rulings in history, where Apple got away with a clearly biased Jury decision – the settlement of this dispute shows that suing each other is not the answer. In financial and marketplace terms this has achieved precisely nothing.

Apple has had a long policy of adopting technology ideas from just about anywhere and worrying about who owns the patents on them later. It especially borrows from educational environments. It then behaves like it invented all these ideas and it also sues based on design patents – down to the angle of the bevel of the edge of the metal in the phone – which are of course in phones, pure nonsense, since once they are turned on they behave totally differently from one another. Those laws were originally created to prevent design rip offs for name brands of fashion clothing. Talk about unintended consequences!!

Certainly the design of the iPhone was predated by other phones with the same look and feel – including the touch screen – but no-one ever bothered to sue the Californian company. Apple at one point claimed it owned the patent for gesture controls, despite the fact that there are many precedents of how pinch to zoom etc… might work. Too few companies are prepared to take on Apple legally to ensure their own patents are protected, a fact it relies on.

No terms of the final US deal were issued, but even if more cash was paid out, it will be a small amount compared to the global smartphone market revenues – in the hundreds of $ billions.

In a way Tim Cook was duty bound by the litigious memory of Steve Jobs, to carry through on Jobs’ threat to sue Samsung. He probably feels he has done enough to honor the memory of the founder of Apple.

Chances are that both senior management have spent way too long thinking about these issues, and the legal bills, and that this is no longer a sane way to run their businesses.

Apple started the legal actions in 2011, accusing Samsung of copying the iPhone – clearly some elements of the iPhone were copied, and Samsung could have been a little smarter about how it went about this process – adopting capacitive touch screens from the open market and allowing gesture control, would have been enough, added to the Android operating system, but Samsung went further to ensure every little detail was copied, which was clearly dumb.

Today the phones each have a very distinctive look and feel, and there is little in common. Their fight, has publicly made them the two phone leaders by quite a margin, pushing almost all others suppliers out of the limelight. As video moves more and more to the phone and with the prospect of 5G class bandwidths just around the corner, this will increasingly become the territory that Faultline Online Reporter has to occupy. God Forfend.