The European Commission has leveled a €4.34 billion fine against Google (more than $5 billion) for tying Android to search and Chrome browsers and other services on smartphones.
Essentially the Commission defined the market as all licensable mobile operating systems, which it said Google had a 95% market share in (outside of China), and also pointed out that even on Apple phones, which had a non-licensable OS, Google is the default search engine – so Google is utterly dominant and today, about 80% of smart mobile devices in Europe, and worldwide, run on Android. As a result, Google also has more than 90% of search traffic in most European Member States.
It must now pay the fine and change its contractual and technical obligations and allow handset makers to use the open source versions of Android without incurring any disadvantage. Google has 90 days to fix its position or face further penalties of up to 5% of the average daily worldwide turnover of Alphabet, Google’s parent company.
The Commission found Google guilty of multiple anti-trust restrictions, but essentially it tied Android licensing to Search, and without this, other search engines would have had an opportunity to take more mobile advertising.
By preventing Play Store and the Chrome browser from being downloadable, it meant that any handset maker who did not agree to take search and used an Android Fork, could not use the Play Store or Chrome.
All Google really has to do is allow the Play Store to be downloadable and allow handset makers to take phones without Google search, but all the other features. The dominance of Google search on phones has meant that it has also dominated handset advertising and is being investigated separately for that in Germany.
Tying one service which is dominant to another which is not, is considered pretty much illegal in any kind of anti-trust law around the planet, and certainly in Europe.
This practice has been going on since 2011, and certainly one company that may have benefitted from this policy changing back then is Nokia. It did not want its phones to become undifferentiated from HTC, Samsung and other Android handset makers, but it could not use Android without all the other options, so it opted to use Microsoft operating systems on its phones, a decision which proved disastrous and resulted in Nokia’s handset division being sold to Microsoft for almost nothing. It fell from grace in just a few years, in the chase to build a sophisticated, touch based operating system. The Commission also said it found the situation around these rules prevented handset vendors from developing and selling devices based on Amazon’s Android fork called “Fire OS.”
Google has been at odds with the European Commission over a number of issues, its search and its advertising and the standard reaction is to go straight to appeal and ignore the complaint until an appeal court, and eventually the European Court of Justice, endorses the decision. Google would be better advised to work with the Commission on a solution which will preserve much of the existing handset business it has.
There is another side to this complaint, which is that Google has also been shown to be up to the same tricks as Intel, which means it was offering payments conditional on exclusive pre-installation of Google Search to handset makers. This would be fine in a market where Google is not dominant, but not in search, although this apparently stopped in 2014, said the Commission.
For the Faultline video market we must now consider subsets of this dominance – such as insisting on using Widevine for DRM on a browser that was helped to dominance illegally; and whether or not Android TV, by insisting on the Play Store being installed, is also in breach. We suspect not since AOSP users have been able to use different DRMs, and to operate both with and without the store. However, this case may change the attitudes of European operators to adopting the fast-growing Android TV – with or without its voice control advantages.