The major record companies are putting it about that they are fed up being bossed around by Apple and that they will instead go after the mobile phone operators, who they think will bring them more revenue.
It is a familiar refrain and one we quite frankly think is just a leak to stir the applecart and create false negotiating pressure. CNET carried the leak in glorious technicolor this week, saying that the labels were unhappy that Apple wants to continue to offer a flat 99 cent charge across both new and old music – apparently they prefer to have older music charged far less per track and newer music cost far more.
What we’d like to know is why suddenly the experts on online music sales are not Apple, but instead are the labels that were so hopelessly baffled by piracy and the mobile operators who charge three times what Apple charges for a ring tone, which is effectively the same file.
Apple is also meant to be under pressure from the record labels to open its Fairplay DRM to competing equipment suppliers, such as Microsoft.
There has been some talk that Motorola has been rebuffed by the mobile operators for wanting to offer them a phone with iTunes on it. There may be some truth in this, since mobile operators that offer iTunes are unlikely to make huge ARPU increases based on their own music service provision, but the official reason that Motorola stopped talking about its iTunes phone is that Apple said that it was not yet ready, so asked the phone giant to stop taking about it until heavy marketing campaigns and a launch could be co-ordinated.
What everyone seems to be missing here is that the first operator in a territory to offer the iTunes phone may lose some music revenue, but it will gain huge market share. And the big operators must be careful that they don’t force the iTunes phones down to ailing smaller operators which will then begin to eat into their market share.