A number of people have written into Faultline, pointing out the level of anger and frustration that has accompanied Sony’s decision to open an asset exchange web site for items that improve player’s standing in its Everquest massively multiplayer online role playing game (MMORPG).
Simply put, most gamers would prefer that instead of promoting the idea of buying advanced players, weapons and in-game treasure, that Sony instead used its technology to block the practice.
Many are accusing Sony of betraying the community, and using the trading exchange to simply make more money out of the players.
At the moment there are many existing, some might say shady, trading exchanges that buy and sell players without the permission of the game operator, and these include IGE and Yantis.
It must be understood that MMORPGs are not the same as PlayStation platform games based on Sony hardware. Although they can now be played on PS2s, originally a PC was required to play Everquest, along with a host of other similar games. Players pay anything up to $20 a month to play and have to earn points by reaching certain levels and collecting items as they go.
Most Far Eastern trading sites are thought to employ cheap labor working in concert to reap swift amounts of treasures in their chosen roles, ganging up on any loner and ruining the game for lots of other players. The more successful this is, the less places gamers can find to play genuinely among themselves.
Already this trading practice has drawn estimates of how much business is done by these sites of anywhere between $100 million and $800 million in annual sales.
These trades are in breach of most online game’s End User License Agreements, but the servers are not set up with sufficient security in order to stop players registering and building up a player and handing them over to someone else.
In the words of one astute gamer, ‘It really is disheartening to see 20 macro’d bots harvesting everything in an entire zone, dominating crafting resources on the server in order to manipulate the prices of items and always getting in the way of the rest of us.’
Effectively Sony says that it can see no way out, except that by managing the sale of characters, it can ensure that no-one is subject to credit card or other fraud. Right now Sony is saying that it will not artificially create any players for re-sale, but that has raised the suspicions of many players that they won’t be able to tell if a player has been artificially created by Sony, or build up by a player, and that the purity of the game is altered by novices coming in at such an advanced and powerful state of play.
From the business point of view, anything that is learned in the highly critical arena of MMORPGs can be transferred to the more generic world of PlayStation, and to some extent Sony uses one as an experimentation area for the other. Role playing games are not particularly popular with PS2 players, but the concept of acquiring strength and weapons throughout a game are more or less universal.
A number of game producing executives have gone on file this week saying that this is one of the worst decisions in the history of gaming, describing it as the entertainment version of day trading. But then again none of them have made any suggestions about just how to block the activity.
So far the Sony service is only for Everquest 2 itself, when played on the PC, and it is a trial running on only some of the Everquest servers, not all of them.
Also last week we gave the impression that Sony might offer this service on games that it doesn’t own. By that we meant that if it does shift the concept from MMORPG to PlayStation, on this platform it has virtual control of all the publishers that offer services on PlayStation. We didn’t mean that Sony would offer exchanges services to other MMORPG games without an agreement with the publisher. More likely it will share its results with other publishers in the hope that it might offer such a service with their approval. It would need to be integrated into their servers and that might only be achieved on a profit sharing basis with the game owner, which is pretty unlikely given the fact that they are Sony rivals.
Insiders tell us that the REAL reason for Sony offering this service is to cut down the 40% plus of its customer service calls that take up most of the helpdesk time on the subject of ‘scammed’ player sales, where someone has pretended to sell a player and just taken the money and not delivered or delivered something less than was promised.
The truth is that on the new Exchange Sony won’t even be able set the prices for these players, so the top end $500 sales will still be there, and with the semi-official sanction placed on it by Sony, it may mean that many times more players come to think that the activity is ‘OK.’
If Sony accompanies this move with a technical attack on the pirate exchanges (in its interest to do so) then perhaps the mercenary black market companies may disappear, which is the only blessing that players
themselves can see right now.