Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2005

Harmonic stumbles as it waits for IPTV to be Prime Time

Every triple play, whether it is based on the IP protocol, comes over cable or wireless or is sent from the sky by satellite, needs a head end, a converter and playout center for organizing and encoding content. So when one of the largest public companies that relies almost entirely on supplying head ends issues a warning, in the form of Harmonic of the US, fears that the market is in retreat have to be considered seriously.

The company said that it expects to report net sales of approximately $56 million to $60 million for its second quarter, lower than previously anticipated due to slower orders of digital head end systems. It will make a loss for the quarter for the first time in years.

Anthony Ley, CEO was fairly bullish about his company’s prospects, but pointed out that the business he was in was ‘lumpy’ meaning it comes in big lumps, and as a result, if one or two orders are delayed, Harmonic can easily miss targets.

While not yet Harmonic’s biggest business, the stall in IPTV activity was more or less confirmed by Ley. Faultline has suggested that the market would stall due to Microsoft software not yet being ready, effectively being more promises than substance.

Ley said, ‘Telco implementations are at their initial stage and recently there have been a number of well publicized issues and some telcos are re-appraising their best way of rolling out plans to supply digital video across their networks’

He later added, ‘We have a very good VC1 encoder and we have a relationship with Microsoft, because we can do with our platform one or two of the things that are causing Microsoft difficulty.

‘The industry, which has embraced the Microsoft eco-system, is taking a little bit of a pause because there have been some well publicized issues which imply that it (the Microsoft solution) is not quite ready for Prime Time.

‘Most people would agree with that, but I think that most people would also take the view that a company with the size of resources that Microsoft is putting into this, means it will all be solved in a reasonable amount of time.

‘It has made the Telco industry look very carefully at what they are doing and they are slowing some deployments down.’

Then referring to whether or not Harmonic was getting its fair share of IPTV head end rollouts, Ley added ‘It is difficult to engage SBC and Verizon directly. When customers are new to video, the tendency is to go for a turnkey approach with set top and head end coming from the same supplier. As they understand video better, they may allow a more direct approach. In the meantime we will be targeting the second tier competitive DSL providers rather than incumbents.’

Ley was virtually admitting that without tying up with Microsoft, Harmonic would have been sidelined in the big telco deployments by traditional set top makers Motorola and Scientific Atlanta. But at the same time by accepting Microsoft as a partner, it would have to put up with further delays in major deployments.

Harmonic says that it already has ten IPTV accounts globally, but only a couple that it can talk about, which were the UK’s Video Networks with its Homechoice service and Plala networks, a subsidiary of NTT in Japan.

It has also supplied Yahoo Broadband, a Softbank company in Japan, and Aliant in Canada and CanalSat DSL, as an IP extension of a satellite service in France.

The great bulk of Harmonic’s business remains the cable operators in the US, which are putting in a greater number and more advanced MPEG2 head ends in order to free up bandwidth in each of their digital cable loops. Often this is part and parcel of the process of moving from analog to digital loops. Comcast has been very active in the first quarter and less so in the second, while other cable operators have yet to place big orders for 2005.

This market is the one driving the triple play, making cable networks VoIP ready in order to attack the US telcos. This remains an MPEG2 market for the foreseeable future and by freeing up bandwidth with yet more head ends, Harmonic expects cable networks to become more telephony ready.

If that wasn’t happening, and if independent VoIP companies weren’t succeeding, then the big telcos would have little reason to take up arms against the video based cable operators and having telcos as potential head end customers is a new broadening of the market for Harmonic.

But at the same time, just as when the MPEG2 market began to take off, it also attracted new entrants to the encoding end of the business and companies such as Tandberg Television,which now owns N2 Broadband, Optibase in Israel, Envivio, Scopus Network Technologies and Skystream Networks are all now targeting this segment, along with the set top majors.

When asked about whether or not there were many VC1 contracts out there, Ley answered ‘The system that Microsoft sells is agnostic to either MPEG4 or VC1, and that’s a call that the customer makes,’ suggesting that although VC1 systems were not being currently specified, that didn’t mean that its MV100 encoder which can work with MPEG4 Level 10 AVC (H.264) compression or VC 1, was not in active bids.

Ley also said, ‘In satellite it is hard to see them getting any more out of MPEG2 and satellite providers will be requiring MPEG4 head ends, but we see this as a next year activity despite the odd statement about them made by one or two operators.’

We would now expect to see further evidence in the month ahead as various companies report their financials, and the fear, uncertainty and doubt that Microsoft has placed on the market by pre-launching an IPTV system, which is patently not yet ready for major installation, further stalling firm orders and global IPTV rollout.