Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2005

AMD US legal action against Intel is echoed by European case

The legal action brought this week in the US by Advanced Micro Devices against Intel has the feel of something tangible about it. Intel has already been warned by the Fair Trade Commission in Japan for the same practices and there is a continuing investigation within the European Commission into Intel’s rebate practices which has suddenly come back alive.

Put simply, if it can be shown by AMD that Intel offered rebates to customers purely because those customer refused to conduct any business with AMD, and if at the same time it can prove that Intel is dominant in PC processor chips, then Intel is likely to find itself found guilty under European law.

Much the same should be true of US law, but US anti-trust cases have a way of getting swept under the carpet, even when the accused party is found guilty, such as in the recent Department of Justice Microsoft case.

In the end rebates are all about hitting quarterly numbers and even customers the size of IBM, Hewlett-Packard, Dell and Sony must find it tempting to accept the Intel rebates if it means bringing down costs for the next quarter by cashing in a rebate instead of paying real cash for more inventory.

In the long run this type of practice will artificially lift the price of microprocessor chips by eliminating competition, even though there is a short term reduction in costs.

Now AMD says that these companies are likely to testify, it may be that they have come to realize that by not using AMD for these chips, they have created a pure monopoly where pricing is totally dictated by Intel.

AMD has filed a 48-page complaint which says that Intel also uses discriminatory subsidies to win and keep customers and has been doing it for more than ten years.

If the European Commission or a US court finds Intel guilty, the likely fine will have to be enough to be corporately damaging, because a healthy AMD would have created a much more level playing field and denied Intel much of its margin over that period.

Naturally Intel denies the suit and says that it has always competed fairly and regards AMD as viable competition. If IBM had not bolstered AMD fortunes over two years ago by taking its Opteron chip for one of its big servers, AMD might not have made it. As it happens IBM began a trend and since then AMD’s fortunes have looked better, and it has even made a comeback in the PC chip market.

AMD says it was making inroads in the Japanese market, with a 22% market share in 2002, until Intel paid both Toshiba and Sony ‘multimillion dollar’ amounts which were disguised as discounts and promotional support in exchange for exclusive use of Intel chips.

AMD is seeking an injunction against Intel as well as unspecified damages and wants the case in court before the end of 2006. We would expect that the European Commission would want to keep out of it if there is any chance that the matter will be resolved in a US court as it usually comes into an anti-trust matter, like the Microsoft case, when the home US courts find their hands tied by the US political agenda.