In the wake of dropping out of the Secure Video Processor Alliance last month, Widevine has now joined the Coral Consortium, the DRM interoperability group that has been created around Intertrust technology.
Widevine is the key DRM player in IPTV rollouts, and its installations include the world’s biggest IPTV installation, the 600,000 strong Chunghwa Telecom service in Taiwan.
‘When we offered to join the SVP Alliance, we thought they would turn us down,’ said Matt Cannard, head marketing at Widevine, ‘but they let us join and after that we found NDS using the fact against us.’
NDS is the driving force behind the SVP Alliance, and has grown out of conditional access (CA) sales it has made mostly to parts of the News Corp empire such as DirecTV and BSkyB.
‘But once we had joined we began to see NDS telling customers that ‘look Widevine has joined us, that must mean they are supporting NDS technology, so don’t buy from them with their technology,” said Cannard.
Virtually every conditional access system in the world, the systems that are used to protect pay TV services, are now trying to find ways to interoperate with portable devices. They want to be the gateway for content onto portable devices rather than systems like iTunes.
But given that most US systems use either NDS or the Motorola and Scientific Atlanta conditional access system preferred by cable operators, those gateways always looked like they might be proprietary too, which would be largely pointless.
Samsung is the only consumer electronics group to take a prominent role in the SVP Alliance, and may well gain a substantial number of sales from portable devices that can act as gateways for the 40 or so operators around the world that use the NDS CA system.
Widevine pulled out of the SVP Alliance with a bald statement in mid-June, the significance of which was lost in most media coverage given that Widevine holds the key to gateway over 1 million IPTV customers into the portable environment, and that number is rising rapidly.
Alongside Widevine other specialist DRM companies have had some success in IPTV projects such as Irdeto Access, Secure Media, and Latens of Ireland, and how they open their customers’ networks to portable devices is equally important.
‘The SVP Alliance is an attempt to create a closed system where NDS gets all of the licensing. Every component in the system has to pay a license to the SVP Alliance, which means paying NDS,’ Cannard said.
Sony has now approached Widevine to joint the Coral Consortium, which goes about the problem in a different way, using the Intertrust designed NEMO architecture which stands for Networked Environment for Media Orchestration, with is a way of using software agents and online connections to verify content transactions, as a basis for interoperable DRM.
Ironically NDS is already part of Coral, joining founders Hewlett-Packard, Intertrust, Philips, Panasonic (Matsushita), Samsung, Sony and Twentieth Century Fox, with other later arrivals including Comcast, NBC Universal, Sony BMG, Universal Music Group, IFPI, the organization representing the recording industry worldwide, European DRM specialist DMDsecure, Pioneer, Seagate and STMicro.
Those operators that use NEMO will be able to simply implement a NEMO agent on its CA allowing it to talk to whatever DRM the portable devices have already implemented.
The biggest announcements in this field so far have come from a Microsoft-TiVo tie up, with its TiVoToGo product and Comcast has said that it will introduce a CA to portables service this Summer, but has given no indication of what technology it will use while it remains committed to Motorola and Scientific Atlanta CA systems.