Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 July 2005

Laws Proposed to Make Telcos’ Pay TV Launches Easier

US lawmakers proposed two new laws that would make it easier for the phone companies to launch pay TV services in competition with the cable and satellite TV services, according to Reuters. The bills would eliminate the need for telcos such as Verizon and SBC to go through a lengthy and cumbersome process of getting approvals from every town and city.

Under both measures, however, the phone companies would be prohibited from so-called ‘redlining’ – denying TV service based on potential customers’ income, a fear the cable TV companies have promoted. Cities and towns would still be able to collect ‘franchise fees’ from the telcos. SBC says it doesn’t need local government anymore than the satellite TV companies do, but is willing to make some limited payments to cities. Verizon has been trying to negotiate deals with local governments and pay the franchise fees.

‘SBC is committed to bringing video competition to consumers, and these bills clearly reflect Congress’ intent to promote competition for consumers,” said Tim McKone, SBC’s senior VP for federal relations.
FCC commissioner Kathleen Abernathy said the FCC could become involved in the franchising dispute if asked. ‘Today, all of the debates are taking place at the states,’ she said. ‘There are some legal arguments that under the statutes we may have the ability to pre-empt the states. But no one has filed a request asking us to do that.’

The original justification for the franchise fees (taxes, really) is that the communities’ streets are dug up during the laying of new wiring to the home. The two major US satellite TV services thus escaped the franchise fee although several states have attempted to impose taxes on their subscribers’ monthly fees for TV service. One argument the phone companies made is that their wires are already in the ground. That, of course, doesn’t hold true when the telcos install fiber optic wiring to or near to the home.

Satellite TV subscribers pay a sales tax on their service wherever a sales tax applies, which the satellite TV companies have not opposed. They have fought what they consider any “discriminatory tax” – those that are set up specifically for satellite TV customers.

The satellite TV companies say that for the most part, it’s the cable TV companies that are pushing such “discriminatory taxes” because of their “inability to compete with satellite’s lower prices in a fair marketplace.” In some states the cable TV operators have found “sympathetic legislatures,” say the satcos.

Kentucky: In March the state passed a tax imposing combined excise and gross revenues taxes of 5.4% on pay-TV services. However, the cable television companies are effectively exempted from almost all of the taxes. Any taxes collected from cable TV companies are paid to local governments in lieu of the 5% franchise fee they previously paid.

Florida: It’s communications services tax imposes a 10.8% tax rate, which is substantially higher than cable TV companies’ 6.8%.

Ohio: Since June 26, 2003, Ohio has imposed a 6% sales tax on satellite television service that is not imposed on cable television services.

Tennessee: The state imposes an 8.25% sales tax on the entire amount of satellite customers’ monthly subscription fees. Cable TV subscribers are not taxed.

North Carolina: The state has a 5% satellite-TV tax that is not imposed on cable TV subscribers.

This coverage originally ran in The Online Reporter at Rider Research, email peter@rethinkresearch for contact details.