The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has thrown out a claim by Seachange International that C-Cor has infringed on Seachange patents.
The decision reverses a lower court ruling and the case will now go back to that lower court, the US District Court of Delaware. The patents relate to how video objects can be stored using redundancy and multiple processors and is contained in SeaChange’s patent number 5,862,312.
What’s interesting about this is that the case was brought in 2000, and yet nCube, the company it was brought against, which has since been acquired by C-Cor, was offering a multi-processor system as early as 1990 and perhaps earlier. The company was formed way back in 1983 by some ex-Intel employees and in 1988 Oracle’s Larry Ellison invested in the company. It has always used parallelism and multiple processors and that’s what all of these patents and all the other legal arguments between the two companies relate to.
No costs or awards have yet been granted to either SeaChange or C-Cor in the case and damages had never been determined in the original case.
There are other cases outstanding between the two video server companies and during 2003 nCube won patent infringement damages from Seachange that led to a provision of over $14 million in its accounts.
Neither case has really been resolved, as the disputes are all being appealed, but given the amount of money the two companies have spent on litigation, it appears that sitting down and agreeing who invented what and negotiating a settlement hasn’t occurred to either of them.