‘When we looked at entertainment, we asked 2,500 people 150 questions what they wanted and the overwhelming answer we found was that people wanted video based around the TV.’
That’s the pragmatic British Telecom answer to how it formulated its entertainment strategy, from the CEO of BT Entertainment, Andrew Burke, clearly pointing to the years when most people thought that video would come through the PC.
‘They don’t want video to be exclusively through the TV,’ said Burke, ‘there are some forms of entertainment that are one to one,’ he said, clearly referring to pornography, but not saying so.
‘Once we knew that, the question was how best to do it over broadband?’ Burke puts you into the dilemma he found himself in when two and a half years ago he put himself into the firing line at British Telecom.
‘We realized that the economics of broadcast over broadband would never win against over the air broadcast,’ says Burke, which is why British Telecom has opted for a hybrid instead of the raw, broadband only set-ups that companies like SBC Communications are planning in the US.
‘We saw the Freeview effect,’ said Burke, referring to the UK digital free to air service which carries 32 free UK channels using DVB-T, ‘and decided we needed to stick a broadband Ethernet connection in the back of the box.’
In effect DVB-T uses the existing TV aerials from analog TV to pick up digital TV signals and route them to a set top that also talks Ethernet to a nearby broadband line.
‘All customers need is a cheap freeview set top box and a 2 Mbps broadband line to get our TV service,’ says Burke. ‘We wanted to have a kind of universal appeal, without a telephone exchange to telephone exchange rollout, so we opted for a system that would work with our existing DSLAMs.’ As British Telecom has rolled out broadband over the past two years, it has patiently waited for each telephone exchange to demonstrate the need for a broadband upgrade by allowing customers to pre-sign up for it.
It may be hard to believe, but for the UK this is likely to have some huge success. There are 7 million (around 30%) of homes that have switched from the free to air analog system to the free to air digital system and in just two years, and in the process gone from 5 TV channels to 32. The price they have paid is sometimes as low as $50 to $70 for a DVB-H set top. Some additional channels, referred to as ‘top up TV’ have opted to be delivered encrypted and have charged for their service.
The UK has 25 million homes, more of them with a telephone than with a TV, but with more or less 100% coverage for both. So 7 million converting to digital TV signals is probably a better penetration than most of the rest of the world, which is what points BT to this strategy.
‘We used a trial that was built up around ‘Catch up TV.” says Burke. In the past it has been referred to as ‘Delay TV’ but in effect the main ingredient is to offer a unicast VoD service that includes recent past TV programs by using an electronic program guide that looks 14 days forward and seven days back.
‘We offer a network DVR of infinite size. But we don’t use up more than 1.5 mbps of bandwidth. We have tried this out at 160 homes since November using MPEG 4 , and the output is high quality. We used an nCube head end, and a DSP based software decodable set top for the trial. Now we are waiting for a hardware based set top like everyone else.’
It’s well known that British Telecom is now a Microsoft customer for its IPTV software. So is that what was used in the trial? ‘No we used something else for the trial, but the name of the supplier is not for release, but we are now using Microsoft. For the trial we just pulled the system together from components.’
‘There was no need for Quality of Service software for the trial, although we will use Alcatel software to provide that for the real launch. We are going for an April 2006 full trial and a late Summer full launch,’ says Burke.
We asked about Microsoft fast channel change, and Burke said simply ‘We don’t use that. We only use VoD. We are not offering multicast services, just VoD.’
In effect this is a hybrid, and Microsoft was chosen as much for its size as for the quality of its product. ‘We are as much interested in the unified DRM as anything else. We want to be able to encode once and move content to multiple devices,’ said Burke.
‘In order to do IPTV or triple play, you need brand and loads of cash, you also need the consumer relationships, the broadcast relationships, the systems integration for billing and things like that, and you need an engineering team. This system cannot self install. To self install this system you need to lay cable in the home. We could have offered Wi-Fi, but that does not have QoS for another couple of years, and anyway we use bricks to build houses in Europe and there’s now way a wi-fi signal is going to get through all UK walls,’ says Burke.
So how will the signal get across a home if not Wi-Fi? ‘We might use HPNA ‘ Ethernet access across telephony twisted pair ‘ and take the Ethernet to the set top,’ says Burke, ‘we’re not sure yet.’
So will British Telecom need to upgrade its DSLAMs in order to deliver what is effectively a triple play (it does offer VoIP through its BT Communicator product line, alongside normal telephony)? ‘We may need to upgrade later, but by 2008/9 we will have switched to the 21 Century Network.’ (BT is shifting to an all IP network).
‘What we have done is look at when people will use on-demand and when they will use broadcast, and look for the peak throughput. If you don’t offer multicast, it’s a lot easier on your network,’ says Burke.
So what will happen when BT introduces ADSL2+ as it has already announced plans for? ‘Then we can offer multiple screens to a single home or maybe HDTV. We are not expecting HDTV to take off for three years in the UK. BSKyB will make the market in the middle of 2006 and we will come after.’
So is catch up TV all that BT will be offering? We will add a library, we’re not sure how big yet, of blockbuster films plus certain classics and the Microsoft software will help us do searches of the entire library in the EPG.’
What about the long tail and adding thousands of movies, we ask? Burke simply shrugs and says, ‘The long tail. Hmm? Maybe’