Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 August 2005

The Tale of Three Telcos

Verizon, BellSouth, SBC and the other local US phone companies face two main problems: They’re losing local phone service accounts by the hundreds of thousands, even millions, and, at the same time, they’re trying to break into the pay-TV business, in which the cable and satellite providers are already deeply entrenched.
Decline in Residential Phone Lines – 2Q05
Company Losses Total Lines %
Verizon (1,203,000) 32,441,000 -3.58%
SBC (296,000) 27,144,000 -1.08%
BellSouth (383,000) 14,692,000 -2.54%

To make matters even worse, the cable TV companies have moved in on the broadband business with a vengeance, honing in on what should have been a natural growth market for the telcos.

A growing number of folks in the US in the 18-30 age group use a mobile phone exclusively – they don’t even have a local landline. And the cablecos are now selling local phone service to those who still have a landline phone. Then there are the VoIP services that are attracting the more technically advanced telephone subscribers.
Now on the counterattack, the telcos are attempting to become total communications services and media providers by offering a so-called “gram slam” of services:
TV
Broadband
Cellular phone
Local and long-distance phone

(The pdf version has all the diagrams fro this article)

BellSouth
For some telcos, loss of residential lines to cell phones is somewhat like taking money out of one pocket and putting into another. Verizon owns 55% of Verizon Wireless (Vodafone owns the other 45%) and SBC (60%) and BellSouth (40%) share the proceeds from Cingular Wireless.
BellSouth’s second quarter report showed residential phone lines were down to 383,000 to 14.7 million, a decline of 2.54% compared to the prior quarter. “There has been an acceleration of wireless substitution,” said BellSouth senior VP of finance Pat Shannon, who did not acknowledge any loss to VoIP.

Its second quarter growth in broadband was slower than the first quarter, with 124,000 new DSL customers, bringing the total number of DSL subscribers to 2.5 million. In the year-ago quarter it added 120,000 broadbanders. The company said the downturn was caused by “seasonal declines,” such as college students disconnecting for the summer. It admitted to losing 35,000 broadband customers who cancelled their service after the company ended its $9.95-a-month-for-six-months promotion. In the last 12 months BellSouth grew the number of broadband subscribers by 42.3%.

Morgan Stanley was quoted in Forbes as saying it expects BellSouth’s phone line decline to accelerate further as competition from the cable TV companies ramps up. It also sees evidence of slowing DSL and long-distance growth at the company. According to Forbes, BellSouth had a sequential increase in lines lost of 131% as well as sequentially lower DSL revenue.

BellSouth, which like Verizon sells DirecTV’s satellite TV service, said it signed up 80,000 new TV users, down from 113,000 new users in the prior quarter.

SBC
SBC reported lower-than-expected DSL additions, blaming seasonal trends, such as students who stopped service at the end of the school term. It added 360,000 new broadband subscribers, a remarkable figure compared to Verizon and BellSouth. Many subscribers were no doubt attracted by the $14.95-per-month broadband it began offering in June. The increase is 14% more than 2Q04, but less than the 504,000 new subscribers added in 1Q05.
“The sequential decline was expected due to seasonality, but the magnitude of decline is surprising, especially considering the price promotions,” Lehman Brothers analyst Blake Bath said.
SBC CFO Rick Lindner also said AOL’s decision to stop reselling SBC’s broadband service cut quarterly results by 25,000 to 30,000 lines.

Falling Satellite
SBC’s Sales of EchoStar’s TV Service
Q4 2004 97,000
Q1 2005 73,000
Q2 2005 10,000

The company said that new broadband subscriptions are the key to staving off attacks by cable TV services such as Comcast and Time Warner Cable, who are increasing their marketing of phone services and offering attractive bundles of phone, pay-TV and broadband. SBC currently sells EchoStar’s pay-TV service, and anticipates offering its Project Lightspeed pay TV service in some areas next year. (One hopes the Lightspeed name applies to the speed with which Microsoft is developing the IPTV software that SBC has committed to using for its pay-TV service).

The 360,000 broadband adds compares with a net gain of 315,000 DSL lines in the second quarter a year ago. Over the past four quarters, SBC has added 1.7 million DSL lines, with 864,000 net adds in the first half of 2005, and ended June with six million in service, number one among US telecom providers. SBC’s consumer DSL penetration of its primary retail lines now stands at 21%. DSL/Internet revenues grew 21.8% versus 2Q04 and were up 5% from the first quarter of this year.

SBC said total access lines fell 1.6 % in the quarter to 51 million, including a drop of 186,000 primary residential phone lines.

Like Verizon and BellSouth, SBC is trying to increase revenue from broadband and wireless to offset flat or declining residential phone service. All the while, it’s working feverishly to deploy a fiber network and offer pay-TV.

SBC said it’s pulling back on selling EchoStar’s Dish pay-TV service in areas where Project Lightspeed will soon be completed. It still plans to deploy the HomeZone set-top box, which integrates broadband and the EchoStar Dish TV service, later this year. SBC’s capital expenses will increase, the company said, as the costs for installing fiber wires and conditioning lines sharply increase in the next six months.

SBC said consumer wireline revenues were up 2.6% in the quarter. The growth in business and consumer revenues was partially offset by declines in wholesale revenues.

“SBC’s second-quarter results demonstrate our ability to deliver solid financial returns as we compete aggressively and transform our business,” said SBC chairman and CEO Edward Whitacre. “Our attention to costs has allowed us to expand operating margins. And Cingular Wireless continues to make excellent progress, with strong subscriber growth and substantial margin improvement.”

Verizon
Verizon’s operating revenue reflected the drop in its number of residential phone lines. The local telephone services it provides in 29 states and the District of Columbia declined to $9.45 billion in the quarter from $9.49 billion. Its domestic cellular business grew to $7.85 billion from $6.85 billion.

Much of the news from Verizon’s quarterly financial announcement centered on two areas: it lost 1.2 million residential phone customers and it’s increasing its capital spending to bolster its broadband and wireless businesses. Verizon said it would increase its capital spending by about 15% this year from last year’s $13.3 billion. Much of that is going to install fiber optic cabling to every home in its territory, as the company has previously promised. An optical network will enable Verizon to offer superior broadband to that of the cable TV companies and pay-TV in order to compete with them and the satellite TV companies.

Verizon chairman Ivan Seidenberg said the spending increase was being done to maintain capacity at Verizon Wireless and launch the company’s FiOS pay-TV-over-fiber-optic lines. It’s embarked on connecting every home in its area to a fiber optic network. Verizon and other US phone companies say they need a pay-TV service to compete with the cable TV companies’ bundles of services. “We see the results of this steady investment today in our wireless results, and we firmly believe that this stepped up investment is the right long-term strategy for the wireline side as well,” said Seidenberg.

“Verizon continues to shift its business mix away from their traditional, land-line voice services,” Daniel Zito, a telecom analyst with Legg Mason Wood Walker told the Washington Post. “All of them [the US phone companies] are making that bet.”

The company said the cause of the decline in its residential phone business was due to growing competition from both its own Verizon Wireless and other wireless services as well as cable TV operators such as Cablevision. Cablevision offers a $99-a-month bundle that includes pay-TV, unlimited local and long distance phone service and a broadband connection.

Although Verizon added 278,000 broadband subscribers, CFO Doreen Toben promised that the company will soon launch new promotions. SBC is currently offering its SBC Yahoo broadband service beginning at
$14.95 a month. BellSouth recently ended a broadband offer of $9.95 a month.

To Recap
Only SBC added more broadband customers (360,000) than it lost in residential lines (296,000) in the quarter. SBC’s broadband efforts were helped no doubt by its offer of a 12-month broadband deal for $14.95 a month. Verizon’s 3.58% and BellSouth’s 2.54% quarterly decline in residential lines are, in a word, crippling if continued. Come on TV and broadband!

Next week we’ll have the cable TV operators’ numbers to compare, including their telephone subscriptions.

Note: The fact that a cable TV company offers phone service does not necessarily mean that it’s VoIP, Cox, for example, is selling standard phone service delivered over its wiring but not VoIP, as shown by the fact it charges all the usual telephone taxes. There are no taxes on VoIP. Cox also advertises the consumer gets one bill for phone and TV service but actually sends two.

This coverage originally ran in The Online Reporter at Rider Research, email peter@rethinkresearch for contact details.