In the wake of the Supreme Court’s ruling over the Brand X ISP case, the FCC last week has decided to treat all internet access the same as cable modem internet access, and apply lighter rules to it. Effectively the provision of internet lines are an information service not a telecommunications service, whoever supplies them.
The decision heavily favors large US incumbent telcos which no longer have to offer either wholesale or unbundled DSL connections to third party companies, a benefit that cable operators have had in the US for some considerable time.
The order, which will come into force in one year, gives the appearance of creating a level playing field between the two large power blocs in residential communication, the big incumbent telcos, usually referred to as the Regional Bell Operating Companies (RBOCs) consisting primarily of Verizon, Bellsouth and SBC Communications, and the large US cable TV operators.
The FCC fancies that with new technologies on the horizon, including satellite, broadband wireless, broadband over power lines and eventually broadband cellular, it thinks that it has neatly managed to sidestep the issue of supporting monopolies and at the same time creating ample competition for domestic broadband supply. However we believe the FCC makes the mistake of creating competing technologies rather than competitors within a single technology. The unbundling legislation in much of Europe and the Far East is perhaps borne of a different conundrum. There, cable operators do not create a strong second string for broadband as they do in the US.
And, as we said, earlier this order is only giving the appearance of creating a level playing field anyway. The FCC offered assurances that it will create future orders based on the following four principles.
(1) consumers are entitled to access Internet content of their choice,
(2) consumers are entitled to run applications and services of their choice,
(3) consumers are entitled to connect their choice of devices to the internet,
(4) consumers are entitled to competition among internet providers
But it’s pretty tricky to decide to take your IPTV from someone other than your wireline supplier or your cable supplier. It is only the cable owner that can facilitate the end to end Quality of Service that is required for streaming TV.
The build out of backhaul, of QoS, the use of MPLS routing to speed video delivery and the creation of routed DSLAMs in a network is entirely the province of the incumbent telco and by allowing what the FCC calls ‘market pricing,’ wire owners will never offer to CLECs the basic connectivity, plus all the QoS requirements for TV signals to reach the home over IP in real time. That will be reserved for their own triple play services.
Despite the FCC’s position on an open internet policy, any CLEC (competitive local exchange carrier) would have to virtually build its own access network, and still, if it used any of the telco wiring at all, it could be priced out of the market for triple play services.
It is only on pure ‘best effort’ internet access that the FCC is promoting competition, not real time services that run over it, and more competition will have to come from broadband wireless or a hybrid between that and satellite, before there are three competitors for triple play in each home in the US.
Voice can be carried reasonably reliably over best effort internet (not at carrier grade), and video file download-to-own or rent, can also be delivered that way, but any other service that requires real time guarantees will remain the province of the RBOCs and Cable operators.
So is this legal framework likely to be embraced overseas? Outside the US, there is a slower rate of growth in alternative services such as broadband wireless, and also in the developmental level of Cable operators. The legislative requirement in Europe for instance is to unbundled the last mile, because there is currently only ONE option for wire into most homes in Europe, at best two, so it is unlikely that any country other than Canada and Latin America would go the same route legally.
In the US, the FCC says that in most states there are two high speed internet offerings and three or even four in others. But this currently relies on existing CLECs and ISPs, which received investment at a time when it appeared clear that the FCC would support unbundling and protect wholesale pricing. That investment environment is long since over and it is likely that as RBOCs re-negotiate contracts with their clients, the margin will be slowly squeezed out of them. Certainly growth will.
The FCC says that it will now also seek comment on a consumer protection framework legislation for anyone providing internet service infrastructure, and Commissioner Michael Copps, previously a critic of this type of strategy, put it best when he said ‘I am especially pleased at my colleagues’ adoption of this Statement of Policy on Internet openness. This is something I have been advocating for nearly two years. We need a watchful eye to ensure that network providers do not become Internet gatekeepers, with the ability to dictate who can use the Internet and for what purpose.
‘Consumers do not want to be told that they cannot use their DSL line for VoIP, for streaming video, to access a particular news website, or to play on a particular company’s game machine.’
But in reality that’s exactly what this order is likely to lead to. The US has already had one case where Vonage (VoIP) traffic was blocked, and although a court found this to be unacceptable, it is unlikely that every service provider that uses IP will be able to amass evidence when its particular service runs unacceptably slow in some locations.
The main declared strategy of most telecommunications service providers who own wires, is to act entirely as an Internet Gatekeeper. How else have they managed to build up substantial portals in their own right?
Another requirement that has been dropped in parallel with all of this, are those for Computer Inquiry. These rules prevented telcos with substantial market power from entering the business of enhanced services. The argument for this is that this rule was invented to stop monopolistic telcos acting as gatekeepers to services into the home, and holding the service operators to ransom.
Now on the one hand this removal is required if any of the RBOCs want to offer IPTV, as this constitutes providing services in their own right, but at the same time we have to ask if this means that all telcos, by weight of their broadband customer power, growing every year, will enter the portal and search engine business. Will they go out and buy up ISPs? to collect more customers? Can they not buy up TV service and music and other content offerings and offering them a dedicated route to market?
The cable operators have become content owners and minor advertising carriers, so is this the future for telcos. We are always assured that this can’t happen because of the clash of cultures between content and telcos. But if you cast your mind back just a year, you will recall that Comcast found itself bidding for Disney.
Are we going to see the same type of bidding in a year or two, perhaps now from Verizon or SBC, chasing content owners the size of Disney in transactions that create unlikely pairings that between them will exercise even more control of this gateway into the home.
Faultline has often pointed out that a telco offering a TV service leads to a disjoint in pricing. The service it is carrying out is the reliable carriage of digital bits. But because they are video bits carrying popular content and because they can create one of the only viable routes to market for residential customers, they will be able to charge their full worth for carrying out their primary service, bit carriage, and additional charges for marketing content services to those customers.
The pricing issue is much the same as Mobile telephony. There customers pay a premium for a phone call made on the road versus one made from their desk, sometimes in the order of three to four times the value of the fixed line call.
Once content goes to a mobile phone, because of the walled garden nature of most mobile operators, those operators also expect to charge three or four times the price for that content as well as charge for its carriage.
That disjoint in price is caused by controlling the route to market, and it always leads to monopoly power and high customer charges, so we think the FCC is going to have to be on its toes if it genuinely believes in its internet statement of policy.
Much of the rhetoric for pushing this order though the FCC was down to issues about providing homeland security, universal internet service, disabilities access, and Internet discrimination protection, so it seems unsurprising that on the same day the FCC also passed another ruling which will mean that VoIP carriers will need to facilitate police wiretaps on VoIP within 18 months.