Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 August 2005

Blu-ray adopts three layers of DVD protection

This week the Blu-ray Disc Association publicly adopted what it described as three parallel content protection technologies for its next generation DVD disks and players.

It says it will use AACS, BD+, a Blu-ray-specific enhancement for content protection renewability, and ROM Mark, to guard against mass production piracy.

The first is called the Advanced Access Content System which comes from an organization that was set up last July by IBM, Intel, Microsoft, Panasonic, Sony, Toshiba, Disney and Warner Brothers. It published its specification in April this year.

Given that the organization was set up specifically to replace the simply and easily duped CSS (Content Scrambling System) that protected content on first generation DVDs, and that members included both Sony, driving the Blu-ray technology effort and Toshiba, driving the alternative HD-DVD standard, then it always seemed likely that both flavors of High Definition DVDs would use AACS.

There has been no change at the AACS web site since the project was launched over a year ago, and so there are no convenient explanations of how the system works. It is supposed to allow content to be copied onto local players in much the same way as Microsoft’s DRM system or Macrovision’s CDS DVD protection system, which allow copies of content to be copied once, but in an encrypted form and with a new decryption key for each device it is copied onto.

The digital copies themselves cannot be copied, and by adding what limited analog copy protection there is available (mostly all patented by Macrovision) that more or less is meant to sow up the copy protection.

It is thought that each of the disk camps will also have to have a way of binding the content to the key that is used to decrypt it, so that if that content appears on the internet, the key of the player can be identified. That key can then be revoked and subsequently released DVDs will not play on that player.

However film studios have been very clear about just what they want in the forthcoming definition DVD system and it has to have the ability for the security logic to be renewed as well as having this forensic marking to help track pirates.

The HD DVD definition coming out of the DVD Forum is expected to use AACS, plus Cryptographic Research’s Self Protecting Digital Content system for this renewable element (which is it currently trialing).

With this, each media disk carries encrypted content and its own decoding software. This software runs in a simple security interpreter embedded in each player and run in a sandboxed virtual machine. If a player’s security has been broken, this can be renewed either over the internet or by subsequent pieces of content issued later.

In May Cryptography Research succeeded in convincing Sigma Designs one of the leaders in digital media processing chips for DVD players, to support its approach to renewability on its SMP8630 series of chips which are aimed at both the HD DVD and Blu-ray Disk players.

The BD+ renewability system that Blu-Ray has endorsed would seem to be a version of this same or similar technology and the Rom Mark is simply the Blu-ray version of the forensic binding of the analog output to the cryptographic keys.

HD-DVD forum has yet to make any statements of its own about its content protection system, but if there are going to be players that can read both formats (and we believe these are planned) then it is likely that the protection on the HD-DVD systems will be virtually the same, apart from marketing names for the systems and key issuing processes to manufacturers.