Time Warner this week agreed to pay out $2.4 billion to settle its major outstanding class action shareholder law suit from the AOL takeover, and also said it would set aside $5 billion of its $7.5 billion in cash to buy back shares. But some shareholders don’t think that’s enough.
It now finds itself beset by a group of shareholders, led by billionaire financial Carl Icahn, that wants it to make assets sales and pay out more like $20 billion in stock buy backs.
Time Warner continues to be the largest content company in the US by both revenues and market value, at around $87 billion, but it is only valued at twice revenues, the aggregate value of the entire Fifty Faultline stocks that we keep track of. Other content leaders such as Viacom and Liberty enjoy valuations of 2.4 and 3.2 times revenues, while Pixar has the ludicrously high revenue multiple of 19.
Icahn will details his plans this week in the wake of a lack luster quarter by Time Warner where overall revenues were down fractionally and net losses incurred due to the $3 billion provision for all costs associated with the class action. Without this provision operating income would have been virtually identical to this time last year at $1.8 billion.
Icahn has been reported in US newspapers as owning less than 1% of Time Warner, but works with hedge funds to raise his impact level so that he is speaking for over 5% of the company. He has a reputation for getting companies the size of Time Warner to listen to him and is expected to recommend that the company expand its stock buyback plan to $20 billion, paid for by selling off Time Warner Cable and other assets.
Time Warner said it generated $2 billion in cashflow throughout the first half of the year, and most of its segments were up or flat except for Film entertainment, a full $450 million lower than last year with half the operating income, much of it due to being compared with the highest yielding year for its Lord of the Rings trilogy, and a year when it also released Matrix Revolutions and the Last Samurai.
AOL was also slightly down, and has already completely changed its future revenue strategy to be more dependent on advertising rather than subscriptions. This is already showing in its figures with revenues down $80 million to $2.1 billion, showing a 45% increase to $99 million in advertising revenues, more than offset by a 9% decrease of $168 million in subscription revenues for the quarter.
AOL now has 20.8 million US members, down 917,000 from the prior quarter and 2.6 million from the year-ago quarter and is suffering similar declines in other territories.