Over the next four quarters expect some troubled times for anyone that sells TV advertising. So far cable and broadcasting channel owners, and this includes Viacom, NBC, Time Warner, Disney, Liberty Media and Fox, have only reported up quarters. By this time next year some of them will be reporting down quarters, due to the slowing of US advertising markets.
News this week that cable’s Upfront negotiation is finally over, with perhaps a 5% rise according to the Cabletelevision Advertising Bureau, means that advertising as a whole has opened up something of a black hole.
Both the Broadcast Networks Upfront and reported syndication revenues have fallen badly, almost for the first time in the history of US television, and certainly for the first time due to the fact that viewers are leaving TV in droves.
In the past a slide in broadcast networks, or a low rise, usually meant that more advertising was drifting to cable. But with only a 5% rise to just over $6 billion in the cable upfront, this is the smallest rise in years, and it means that broadcast isn’t losing out to cable, broadcast revenues are disappearing to other media such as the internet.
The fact that the cable ‘Upfront’ took months to negotiate, instead of days or a few weeks, suggests that advertising buyers were being cautious and were happy to enter longer term negotiations. In the past these negotiations have been more or less over by the end of 4 or 5 days, with hot cable channels that are showing programming that is considered a hot property, virtually panicking advertisers and their advisors into believing they must act swiftly or miss out completely on major advertising deals.
Cable attracted just $300 million more than last year’s $6 billion, with prices up 3% and a little more inventory on offer.
The Upfront is a beauty contest of viewing figures for the new season’s shows when advertisers commit spending alongside both broadcast and separately on cable delivered content.
The content and advertising industries are making comments in their trade press that they ‘hope’ this is just a one year phenomena, when secretly many of them know that the writing is on the wall for the boring old broadcast content delivery model. With every DVR or DVD recorder that is sold, or with every new cable VoD customer or IPTV sign up by the telcos, less advertising will be watched on all forms of broadcast TV, and by this time next year, the situation is likely to be considerably worse, and for those ad reliant operators there will be corporate write downs, missed advertising sales targets and expensive forays into new business models, before this can be put behind them.
And as the squeeze gets put on to cable and broadcast networks, they will buy in less expensive content to fill out their channels and close their less appealing channels. That will result in content owners shifting emphasis to direct content delivery, with internet delivered content models and DVD business being driven up, and TV specials de-emphasized. That in turn adds to the spiral and will drive viewers away from advertising driven TV even faster.
For the next 12 months it is only the effects of these upfronts that the channel owners will feel, along with the sale of any discretionary inventory held back. These figures will be flat or down slightly, and in spring next year there will lots of eyes, from investors to advertising execs to content owners, fixed on the outcome of the next upfront.
The smart businesses, like News Corp and AOL, are already responding and trying to drive new ad revenues onto internet properties.