Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 August 2005

Faultline Fifty focus on DirecTV and EchoStar

This week we have slightly changed our Faultline Fifty format so that it is more analytical and less data intensive. The spreadsheet still covers the market capitalization of each of the fifty representative companies as well as extended recent financials for one or two that we pick out each week because they are interesting or relevant (see attached spreadsheet).

Still above $2 trillion in value the Faultline Fifty lost just $6.5 billion, some 0.33%, in a week when the Nasdaq Composite fell 0.9%.

The CE sector rose, and this time not just on currency shifts, but genuine sentiment, with Sony making nearly $2 billion of recovery, but Matsushita, clearly taking a lead in investors eyes and continuing its pursuit of a $40 billion valuation.

Telcos are also up, mostly on Vodafone shifting up almost $5 billion in value, with a little more continuing movement from France Telecom, which has been consistently moving upwards the past few weeks.

The most down sector is Content, off over 2% in a week that saw Vivendi, Disney, Viacom and Time Warner all battered possible on the slow ‘Upfront’ (see separate article).

This week we want to take a closer look at the US satellite TV providers who announced results in the last two weeks.

Both EchoStar’s Dish Network and DirecTV numbers show them growing healthily. Each remarkably added precisely 225,000 net new subscribers, both threw off substantial amounts of cash, both were profitable, and both are showing a huge 1.69% monthly churn.

Dish ended the quarter to June 30 on 11.455 million subscribers and DirecTV on 14.7 million, but it is the churn figure that tells a tale. Faultline suggested a few weeks back that a triple play for these companies, offering voice and high speed internet over perhaps a parallel network, could be justified in terms of savings from churn.

The total churn for Dish customers amounted to 574,000 customers and for DirecTV it amounted to 759,000 customers, so they each replaced these and added a further 225,00 customers. These are the customers that either do not renew, move home, cancel or cannot pay their dues. It is pretty well agreed that churn among a triple play is far lower because a home cannot be without its phone, internet access and its TV for any length of time, and there is a greater fear of upset in changing all three at once. If these two companies could save even half of that churn, then instead of replacing 20% of their customers every year, they would have to replace just 10%. That’s a saving of some 666,500 customers each year, 287,000 for Dish and 379,500 for DirecTV.

Now if you just naively multiply that by each company’s subscriber acquisition costs (SAC), it should give you the amount they would save, which would be $245 million a quarter for DirecTV and $191 million for Dish. Actually those SAC costs include the cost of the network aggregated across the entire customer base, so real savings would be better if we took off those costs. This brings it to around $432 per subscriber for Dish and although no equivalent figure is published for DirecTV, we estimate it to be around the same, so a total potential saving of around $288 million of savings between them each quarter, around $500 million for each company, each year. It makes it almost a certainty that both companies will invest heavily in triple play strategies around the same time that the telcos begin selling TV services in the US.

But despite all of these costs, both companies make money, DirecTV almost for the first time. The transformation during the past 30 months at DirecTV is testament to the single-minded ability and genius of Rupert Murdoch, and he and his team have done miracles with what everyone else saw as a moribund asset.

DirecTV made a net income on the quarter of $162 million, up from a loss last time of $13 million, while throwing off cash of $330 million in the quarter.

Dish made a huge net income of $856 million, up from $85 million this time last year, but this was affected by a huge tax reversal and an insurance payout on a failed satellite, and without those it would have been $129 million. The company threw off cash of $230 million over the first half of the year, so roughly half of that for a quarter.

The pace of growth of both companies is slowing. It is costing more to acquire new customers and keep existing customers each year, and churn seems to be both companies’ single most worrying issue, especially at DirecTV where it is rising.

DirecTV acquired 409,000 net new subscribers during the same period last year compared to the 225,000 it acquired this year. It says this is down to higher involuntary churn from subscribers with lower credit scores, due in part to the significant increase in gross subscriber additions over the past several quarters, and a more competitive marketplace.

The average revenue per subscriber at EchoStar’s Dish is $57.74 and at DirecTV $66.91. This means that currently it takes 11 months for Dish to recapture the entire subscriber acquisition cost out of subscription revenues and takes DirecTV 9.7 months to get their SAC costs back.