Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 August 2005

DVD wars: Merger talks off, HD DVD delayed, studios dither

In a busy week for the DVD wars, any final hope that there would be a single High Definition DVD standard evaporated, and rumors emerged that HD DVD, the standard pushed by Toshiba and NEC, may be late.

The week kicked off with Toshiba President Atsutoshi Nishida telling Reuters that talks between Sony and his company were off. They had been announced as all over once before, but Toshiba was said to have kept them alive, talking at the engineering level and pointing to some future potential merging based on technical issues. Now even that remote possibility is dead.

Blu-ray immediately hit back saying that it was still hopeful that talks might resume, but it clearly had its tongue in its cheek. Blu-ray was denounced as wanting too much ground in the talks, effectively insisting on its basic laser and disk design and only wanting to discuss minor software concessions with NEC.

The Blu-ray Disc Association clearly has the upper hand now, and if, as is widely expected, HD DVD is delayed, its support may run for the hills. Certainly the studios that have come out in favor of it, Warner Brothers, Paramount, and Universal, will be under enormous financial pressure to switch if they have no HD disks to offer while their competitors Sony, MGM, Disney, 20th Century Fox and Lion’s Gate steal a march in the early market for high definition content. They are now thought to be scaling back their planned commitment of HD DVD production.

Although the high definition early adopters are not expected to be a huge amount of these company’s revenues, they risk their opponents tying up all the manufacturing capacity in the next disk format before they get into the market.

Blu-ray players have been in the market for some time, but these are high prices products, without the benefit of economies of scale, priced above $2,000 and with only home made content to play. Volume players will rapidly go to the price of the top end DVD players, but are expected to start shipping at something just under $1,000.

Given that the Sony PS3 has promised to ship with a Blu-ray drive and that it will not ship until after March 2006, that’s probably when the market for Blu-ray will open up. Prior estimates had it as neck and neck with HD DVD, with delivery at the end of this year, but the goal posts seem to have moved substantially.

It is likely that some players will hit the market with dual mode devices, able to read both sets of disks, but there are likely to be more expensive than single mode devices. However as it Blu-ray is winning the war its members are less likely to do this, so count out Sony, Philips, Samsung and Panasonic for dual mode devices, at least until HD DVD begins to ship in volume. In the meantime if Toshiba hedges its bets by offering both formats on a player, then it will almost be an admission that it has lost the third global DVD war.

However either side could be able to catch up ground, as the HD market will be constrained by purchases of HDTVs, meaning that the great bulk of content will continue to ship in traditional DVD for at least a few years, possibly as many as five.