Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 August 2005

Nokia and Motorola now account for over half of all handsets

The Faultline Fifty fell around 1% in value to around $1.98 trillion, as the Nasdaq fell less sharply at 0.4% for the week.

The worst segment were the Telcos, where Vodafone pushed the average down with a drop of almost $6 billion, a fall of some 3.4% of its value.

The Content sector was also off $5 billion on the week, with continued weakness at Disney (off 1.4%) and Time Warner (off 3%).

The technology segment actually moved up purely on $3 billion of improvement at Microsoft.

This week we have decided to focus on the fortunes of the two leading cellular handset manufacturers and look at their recent figures in a little more detail.

This is because Nokia and Motorola have carved out an extra 5% of the handset market between them this quarter compared to the second quarter of 2004.

That’s according to figures published in their quarterly accounts, and based on total global quarterly shipment estimates from Nokia.

The outcome has been a gradual but sustained rise in Motorola’s share price, but a partial collapse in Nokia’s, due to the Nokia mix of phones leading to smaller margins, primarily due to its dominance of low priced, third world markets.

Just where this leaves other handset makers is difficult to say until they all report, but the chances are that the strong are getting stronger and the not so strong are getting weaker and must seek to consolidate, despite a market that expects to be up once again this year by something like 18% by units.

It helps us understand why companies like Siemens have been so keen to offload their handset divisions, and soon as the market for handsets contracts or stabilizes it points to further consolidation.

The financial markets are right to drive up Motorola shares ahead of Nokia’s because it is a more remarkable achievement, and represents a unit shipment growth of over 40%, and must be down to the combined influence of the company’s new leadership (Ed Zander) and the massive popularity of the Razr phone look and feel. However Nokia’s shipment numbers grew 39%, which even for a market leader is a huge step up in a market that grew a phenomenal 24%.

Both companies reported a few weeks back in the second half of July and we took only a brief look at the Motorola numbers in our August 2nd issue. Faultline has elected to change the way it reports on the Faultline Fifty, focusing on a different detailed drill down into one or other set of figures each week, rather than reporting them all ‘en masse.’

Financially speaking the handset side of Motorola grew some 24% in revenues, to $4.9 billion versus $4 billion this time last year.

The company found that it as not as a result of a huge push for 3G phones, but is mostly in GSM handsets. In other worlds Motorola sold on style, rather than new technology.

Sales were up in North America, Latin America, Europe and the Middle East, Africa and South Asia, but declined slightly in North Asia. Effectively Nokia did better in China, and India, Motorola did better elsewhere in the Far East, and that’s confirmed by Nokia’s figures.

But Motorola’s average selling price still declined 12% compared to the second quarter of 2004 and by approximately 5% sequentially from the first quarter of 2005. The decrease, as always in average selling price, was driven primarily by shipping more, less expensive phones.

Nokia’s average selling prices in the second quarter declined by just 3% when compared with last year to $128.5, and was also down 5% sequentially from the immediate past quarter. One way of reading this is that before Ed Zander came to Motorola, the company was charging too much for its phones, and hence it was losing market share. Now it’s prices are falling in line with the industry and things are better.

But one problem persists for Motorola, and that is that Nokia has a stranglehold on what it calls Smartphones.

In smartphones, Nokia reckons the total industry volume reached about 12 million units for the second quarter 2005, which still makes it one of the fastest growing segments of the handset business, up more than 300% over the 3.5 million units it says shipped this time last year. But Nokia has cornered this part of the market shipping 6.7 million units, compared with 2.1 million units in the second quarter 2004, a market share of 55%.

Okay, that’s a fall from a 60% market share, to a 55% market share, but with companies like Sony-Ericsson, focusing almost entirely on the smartphone market, that’s a pretty hefty slice, and it will eventually grow to a size where it begins driving up average selling prices for all of Nokia phones, and so will the fact that Nokia also grew its share of the 3G phone market. The question is where will Motorola find the same kind of price hike.

The likely answer could easily be the iTunes phone that Motorola is producing with Apple, but until that sees the light of day (see separate item) and a major operator takes it, which may be as soon as next week, it has to be discounted.

An operating income at Motorola of $982 million and a net income of $933 million meant that Motorola as a whole was operating on a 10.6% net margin, up from a loss last time. At Nokia virtually exactly the same margin last year (10.7%) has fallen to a margin of 9.9%. Much of this was achieved by Motorola achieving that magic combination of decreasing costs while increasing sales, with costs of selling, general and administrative, for instance, dropping 6%, as sales have gone through the roof.

The set top division of Motorola benefited from an upsurge in capex in the cable industry, and it also has lucrative contracts in IPTV or Telco TV, to come, later this year. The cable industry has been on a spending spree replacing low end set tops with Digital Video Recorder class devices and the result was a 35% increase to $718 million in the quarter, making it a $3 billion business in its own right.

Other parts of Motorola were not so bullish, with Government and Enterprise Mobility and Networks up only slightly. In total the company generated $1.5 billion of net cash gains, to take the cash in the bank to $7.5 billion.

Motorola is already well set up for next quarter, given that the Sprint Nexel deal will go through and Motorola will end up with 69.3 million shares of Sprint Nextel stock and $46.3 million in cash, in exchange for its 54.7 million shares of Nextel. As a result it will recognize an after-tax gain of approximately $780 million in the third quarter of 2005.

At Nokia some 34 new mobile devices were launched in the quarter across different price points. It did $5.9 billion in handsets compared to $5.0 billion this time last year.

We have already talked about recovery of Nokia’s Networks division in the past, and it remains in profit and grew at around 6% to $1.98 billion for the quarter, but it is the multimedia division of Nokia that must be taken seriously at present, already its third biggest business and likely to overtake Networks in the next quarter or so.

Currently it is up 89% to $1.68 billion on the quarter, with sales mostly in Europe and the Middle East and Asia-Pacific and China. This segment includes its new Internet tablet and its ‘Maemo’ development platform, smartphones sold for entertainment, and of course N-Gage. Nokia said its 6680 was the number one revenue generator in Multimedia for the quarter.