Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 September 2005

Microsoft buys Teleo to bring MSN Messenger to the VoIP wars

Which has been downloaded more times, MSN Messenger or Skype? That’s the first question we thought of when we heard that Microsoft had acquired Voice over IP software firm, Teleo.

The answer by the way, if you believe what they both say, is that MSN Messenger wins by some 13 million copies, but by the time you read this, Skype’s 157 million downloads may have jumped once more. Effectively it is neck and neck.

The truth is that Skype is not only accelerating its usage more and more each day, but with it announcing that there are over 400 new applications available for it from this week, it is already way ahead in the development of a true platform for voice over the internet.

That’s not to say that Microsoft can’t catch up, but because it plans to tie its initial service to MSN Messenger, and with so many of its MSN Messenger clients buried inside enterprises, and its initial VoIP service targeted at consumers, there’s a very simple question that stands out. If Microsoft begins its VoIP services around Messenger, surely it is targeting people that already have a means of communication that they are happy with.

You might assume that the technically savvy users of MSN Messenger may well already use Skype, but if that was the case then they’d be using the IM that’s built into Skype, so it seems unlikely.

Either way, it is now just a matter of time before everyone that uses a PC and a broadband line regularly, downloads a piece of software that allows virtually free telephony over that broadband line using some version of VoIP.

It is already possible for Skype to talk to the regular PSTN phone world and that will be a target both for Microsoft and for other newcomers like Google. Microsoft may be able to enforce a download of its VoIP client, as a part of another piece of Microsoft software and provide it free within future copies of its operating system, but this time this won’t necessarily give it the edge. And if it does, that’s just another anti-trust issue it will be storing up for itself.

Allocating a genuine phone number in each of the countries where this service will operate (globally) so that PSTN callers can call the Microsoft VoIP phone numbers, will be another problem for Microsoft to overcome, but overcome it, it will.

What is very tricky technically for Microsoft is that it has to either choose to build its service on Peer to Peer technology, or it has to incur far greater costs than companies like Skype.

Also a company like Skype may be happy with a few $100 million in revenues, whereas Microsoft could not remain focused for a business that was so small.

Both Google and MSN have various servers that they have to maintain already and loading these up with Softswitch duties may not appear too heavy an additional workload, but the SuperNode architecture of Skype spreads even its directory around the internet and that is something of a neat trick and will take some copying.

Microsoft has been buddying up to virtually all incumbent telcos for one service or another during the past few years, whether or not this is over teleconferencing services, using Netmeeting, or in offering broadband with email fixed to Outlook or supplying them with IPTV. Some telcos even use Microsoft’s Connected services Framework software for their own service provisioning, or at least are starting to think about it and are signing up for trials.

But psychologically, offering VoIP undermines those same telcos that are involved in a war against erosion of their voice revenues. They would have to think twice about supporting any software that accelerates that undermining process.

That is, unless Microsoft partners with those same telcos and pushes its product as a way of ‘eating their own children,’ as it is known in the trade, and offering their own VoIP before anyone else does. So it might even partner with Telcos in a perverse form of co-opetition.

The words of Skype founder Niklaus Zennstrom echo around us from our first interview with him ‘one day all telephone services will be like this’
It look like he is going to be right.

Teleo is a private US based firm and we don’t know just how much Microsoft paid for the company, so in a way we don’t know just how important Microsoft feels this play is.

Microsoft already uses VoIP technology in some of its enterprise products, but Teleo’s technology offers things like click-to-call where a phone number found on the internet can be simply dialed, and it can use click to call on the contact list in Outlook as well, a feature that Google with its Gmail touted as a significant time saver for clients, when it launched its service two weeks ago.

Microsoft insists ‘We’re not going to be a telephone company,’ well that’s obvious, there’s not a good enough margin in it, but it says it will offer ‘some form of VoIP enhancements’ to MSN Messenger by the end of this year.

Here’s a simple question that will define the struggle ahead? Will Microsoft VoIP clients talk to other VoIP clients. And the equally obvious answer is ‘No,’ at least certainly not to Skype. Anyway it’s not Microsoft’s way to welcome a free for all, because then it can’t land a monopoly. Instead it will look to create genuine technical advantages for its service and then bundle it.

Theoretically SIP standard clients should talk to each other, though Skype does not use SIP (Session Initiation Protocol) and also there is the small matter of where do you look up directories for other SIP services. Microsoft may continue use SIP to say that it is a standards based system, but it will be true to its nature and if it doesn’t let messenger clients interoperate with other IM’s, then why let phone clients do so.

Of course there’s nothing to stop someone emulating a PSTN gateway on the internet and then re-routing the voice back into VoIP and delivering to Skype or Vonage or anyone. But what’s in it for them and how will customers look numbers up? If someone can come up with a reason to do this, it will take the edge of Microsoft’s usual walled garden approach.