The first thought that comes across in the eBay purchase of Skype is that they paid rather a lot of money for the business, but when you are worth $52 billion, and have $2.7 billion in the bank and are cash generative, it’s easy to be cavalier with your money.
That’s a pretty huge valuation for eBay given that it has just $4 billion in revenues, which funnily enough is what eBay will pay for Skype all told if the company meets all of its performance options, with $2.6 billion of that up front in cash and shares.
But the key to whether or not this deal is likely to be a success for eBay is whether or not founders Niklaus Zennstr’m and Janus Friis stay with the business, as the statement says they will.
Supposedly Zennstr’m and Friis will remain in their current positions and Zennstr’m will report to eBay CEO Whitman and join eBay’s senior executive team. But the world is littered with ex-CEOs that become disenchanted after a merger and who slide away 90 days later.
Luxembourg-based Skype has created something of a monster effect in the short time it has been in existence and over 50 million people use the software regularly and more than 157 million have downloaded it.
It is easy to see the principle behind the merger, with eBay adding an instant messenger for each auction client so that more complex data can be swapped between buyer and seller, and this taking eBay into more complex forms of online transactions.
At the same time it is a pretty simple way to open up another 50 million PayPal accounts (PayPal is owned by eBay), by giving each of the Skype accounts a PayPal wallet it could make payment for Skype services a lot easier.
But some questions remain over just how the technology will be integrated. Skype sits on the Joltid P2P network, with an additional distributed database. To some extent it just lives on PCs all over the internet, but on no servers. The eBay system is a service based system and it’s fairly easy for them to talk to each other, but perhaps not quite so easy to rebuild eBay with the Skype tools if that’s what’s required.
Another thorny technical issue is that the rest of the VoIP world relies on the Session Initiation Protocol, which Zennstr’m roundly criticizes. As other portals attempt to hijack the free VoIP space such as Google, MSN, AOL and Yahoo, they are all likely to use SIP. The Skype technology may find it has to accommodate these services, even if it does not have to copy them, and that’s a technical challenge.
Certainly the timing of the deal is right for eBay. It would soon get so that Skype had to go public in order to exit as its value was rising so rapidly. Skype did $7 million in revenues in 2004, and was on track for $60 million this year. And projecting over $200 million in 2006.
Effectively Skype is being valued at the same multiple as eBAY, 13 times revenues, not today’s revenues, but those in just over a year’s time.
But Skype has been adding features like there is no tomorrow. It already had voicemail, instant messaging, calling out to the PSTN, call forwarding and conference calling and is set to add Skype video, avatars, and customized toolbars for Outlook and Internet Explorer.
We are drawn to the comments made in a US court this week about Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer, throwing chairs at a departing employee and screaming that he is going to ‘kill Google.’
Perhaps investors should not only question the leadership capability and stability of a man that throws chairs across a room, but also question Ballmer’s fitness for purpose to identify Microsoft’s competition. Google may be stealing Microsoft’s employees, but Skype, and now eBay, may be stealing its thunder in the marketplace and Ballmer clearly has been blinded to this fact until now. Perhaps it’s time for Bill Gates to ask him to stand down.
Back at the eBay transaction, the market has yet to make up its mind about the eBay deal, with shares dropping from $40.5 before the deal was announced to $38.25 in the days after it, which means it has been discounted in the last 5 days by around $3 billion, about what the deal is costing up front. Instinct suggests that investors are split on the outcome. And, as we said above, we are clear that it depends on the contribution that is yet to come from Zennstr’m and Friis.