The Faultline Fifty (see separate spreadsheet) has fallen 1.45% since we last produced the table two weeks back. In the same time the Nasdaq composite index is off 2.35%.
A combination of soaring oil prices plus fears over a new US Hurricane called Rita, due at the weekend, which may cause problems for Texas refineries, has made investors jumpy.
During this time there has been a run on the cable and satellite operators, down 3.89% in the past two weeks, and this has been a constant slide for this sector with the exception of XM Satellite Radio, which is gaining ground on its arch-rival Sirius, which has always been valued ahead of it.
The two segments which are noticeably up, rather than down, are telecom equipment suppliers and consumer electronics. Both handset makers Motorola and Nokia have made announcements of recent significant deals and Alcatel has also risen more than $1 billion in value. Alcatel is still only valued at just over 1 times its revenue and is still at odds with the over-optimistic valuations of Lucent and Nortel which gain from being US companies which are closer to 1.5 times revenues, despite constrained growth.
In the CE sector only Sony rose, almost certainly a reaction to the fact that the New CEO will announce a restructuring plan tomorrow and he is likely to reach for long awaited job cuts of around 15,000 more staff (Sony has lost 20,000 in the last two years) and the elimination of some weaker product lines and the introduction of more US originated managers in senior positions. Sony also launched some rather stunning flat LCD TVs this week (see separate story).
Elsewhere Telco and Technology stocks were in line with the market while the chips and content stocks held their form better than Nasdaq generally.
In the space of two weeks Blockbuster’s valuation fell underneath Netflix’s valuation based on bullish statements from Netflix management and a warning from Blockbuster that it would not declare a dividend because it has spent aggressively on marketing of late and now needs to focus on profitability.
Blockbuster is working hard to transform itself and was dropped by Viacom purely because it was in what is seen as a dead end business, retail DVD rental. Since it went independent it has sacrificed its very unpopular ‘late fees’ with a new ‘no late fees’ program, introduced its ‘Movie Pass’ system and added an online DVD rental option directly in line with Netflix, and has captured something like 1 million new accounts. Both Netflix and Blockbuster are both working on online delivery of films, which could be launched as early as this year, and Blockbuster is working on in-store DVD burning.
But the bare numbers (in attached spreadsheet) speak for themselves, all of which are caused by lost late fees and increased costs and has put Blockbuster in a position where it has shrinking revenues and is making losses, whereas NetFlix continues to grow revenues at around 28% even though it is still a tenth of the size of Blockbuster. Blockbuster has about $1 billion of debt and only around $145 million in the bank, but that should be plenty as it has huge property assets in its stores and both companies are cash generative. One response to the weak performance was to add about $3 a head to Blockbuster’s online DVD monthly subscription back to $17.99, after it had perhaps been too aggressive in undercutting Netflix at $14.99 a month.
Although revenues decreased for Blockbuster, this really reflects the falling revenues of its US stores. Its online service is growing leaps and bounds, other revenues are falling and late fees have disappeared.
By contrast during the last quarter Netflix acquired 707,000 subscribers, taking it to over 3 million and at an analyst day last week Netflix said that it would hit 5 million subscribers during 2006 and would produce a net income for the next year of around $50 million. For the next two quarters it expects anything up to $14 million in net income.
It is likely that Blockbuster is being wildly under valued here, and that much of this drop in value to 14% of its annual revenue, is emotionally based on the lack of a dividend. Certain investors only ever invest in companies that offer dividends and it is likely that if Blockbuster delivers on one quarter then this valuation will likely slide back up, but perhaps not to the two times revenues that Netflix enjoys.