Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 September 2005

Sony restructuring sounds good, but investors snub renewed forecast

The anticipated restructuring duly arrived at Sony, with cuts of 10,000 jobs, charges increased by over $450 million and a radical plan to salvage something from its electronics group.

Like CEO’s before him Howard Stringer promised profit in the relatively near term, saying that the company’s operating margin would be 5% by the end of 2007 which ends in March 2008, two and a half year’s time, by which time costs will have lowered by 200 billion yen ($1.8 billion) a year.

Previous CEO Noboyuki Idei, had promised a margin of 10% by the end of 2007, and in a Faultline’s research paper last year we said that the best he could hope to achieve was around 6.5% and that’s if everything went his way.

Sony will also review its holdings in real estate and stock holdings and some 120 billion ($1 billion) of these assets will be liquidated in disposals by the end of fiscal year 2007.

Two of the new big cost factors for Stringer is writing off many of the assets of the cathode ray tube TV division and cutting headcount, much of this in Japan, where it is expensive. Some 40% of all job cuts will come from Japan. These new costs will hits its end of year figures said Stringer and he released new downward projections for the year that is halfway through, with revenue the same at $64.5 billion, a projected operating profit of $267 million turning into a $178 million loss for the year.

But it’s was the words rather than the numbers that carried the most interesting details of the three Sony announcements made this week.

Gone are the separate fiefdoms of the Electronics Group, and if you want to get anything done in Sony Electronics, it must now go through a centralized teams run by Group CEO Ryoji Chubachi. He will be supported by teams that operate across the product ranges rather than down them, with merged and re-organized R&D and more emphasis on software, especially in areas such as Digital Rights Management, middleware and codecs. It turns out that work on many pieces of Sony software is duplicated in each of its silos and rarely works with software from other departments. Stringer is determined that this becomes a thing of the past and will open up software centers in China and the US to combat this.

Within Electronics, resources will be focused on High Definition TV and DVD, digital imaging and portable audio products. Key semiconductors that have the power to differentiate Sony’s products will come to the fore, but we have heard this before. Under Idei, Sony already had plans to slash the number of separate parts from 840,000 down to 100,000. This was to be completed by March 2006 taking its suppliers down from 4,700 to 1,000. The idea was more economies of scale in the order process and better quality assurance.

Sony had said it wanted to go even further than this, and have just 20,000 parts designated as Sony-approved and standardized throughout the company, so it looks like this grand plan of Idei has been continued by Stringer. The idea was always a good one, but it will be execution that will make it a success, which is Stringer’s strong suit.

One of the changes at Electronics includes the creation of a new division to promote the development of Cell processor-related technology, which will report directly to Stringer. The Cell will not only be the basis of the Playstation 3, out next spring, but also will find homes in HDTVs and other home networking products.

Out also goes the famous ‘network companies,’ the silos that Idei tried to limit in individual power and force into co-operation, but which essentially refused to co-operate and cost him his job. Sony last year began a Sony One campaign, suggesting that Sony is now a single entity. Under Stringer that catchphrase is now supposed to come true, instead of being mere lipservice. Instead there will be Business Groups for each product type.

Sony will throw out 15 business categories by either downsizing, or through alliances or disposals, which will see Sony cut its number of device models by 20%. This in turn will mean that the number of manufacturing sites can go down, with 11 of them to be closed or sold , but this will still leave Sony with 54 separate plants, which may remain too many.

The ailing TV business came in for special criticism and is to be brought into line by rationalizing manufacturing sites and sourcing more components in-house. This will include a shift to making its own LCD panels and stop relying entirely on its Samsung joint venture, something that Sony executives casually addressed last week. TV will be profitable by the second half of fiscal year 2006, which is one year from now.

Stringer made a good deal about using High Definition products as a major profit pillar. That’s got to come true, but as prices crash around Sony’s ears in large screen flat TVs, it’s going to be tough to make happen and the only way is by making more of the components, with the key part being the LCD panels or new screen technology such as OLEDs.

Stringer says that one key to this will be to develop the Sony 4K cinema projector down to consumer level. Naturally, Blu-ray disk will play a huge part here, showing that Sony cannot afford to lose out to the HD DVD rival consortium for high definition DVD.

Stringer said, ‘We will focus engineering resources on semiconductors and key component devices essential to adding value to products. Key areas in semiconductors will be games and imaging. In the key component device area, we will develop innovative technologies for system LSIs and next-generation displays, as well as Blu-ray disc-related devices.’

This idea of developing what he refers to as LSI (Large Scale Integration) as opposed to VLSI (V for Very) seems to suggest that Sony is going to put simple consumer systems onto a single chip.

He mentioned them in a range of home electronics products built around high definition, and that sounds like he means the Cell chip.

But he also talks about a system LSI for cellular phones, something that Sony has not touched until now. The better integrated chips are for mobile phones, the less power they use and the smaller footprint they take up inside the precious real estate inside a phone, making room or things like hard disk drives.

Lots of people focus on what is wrong at Sony, but it must be remembered that a lot more than just platform games are right at Sony. Its imaging products which drive digital still and video cameras are world leading in both technology and volumes and Stringer says there’s more to come here in CCD and CMOS image sensors.

He also pointed to a future display technology that Sony was marrying itself to, which is self-luminous flat panel Organic Light Emitting Diode (OLED) displays and Sony will establish a Display Device Development Group that directly reports to the Electronics CEO to accelerate development.

OLED came originally out of Kodak about 25 years ago but has been really tricky to bring to a bulk manufacturing process. Like the SED technology that Canon and Toshiba are just about to bring to market, which is expected to revolutionize flat TV screens, this is another flat version of the Cathode Ray Tube which effectively creates thousands of tiny CRTs behind a glass, coated with an emissive layer. A charge is applied to the back of the screen and generates light. This class of technologies have the clarity of CRT, but are usually under an inch thick and can be made far wider than CRTs.

In Sony’s mind this technology was on the blocks to arrive in 2007/2008 timeframe, but it looks like Stringer is accelerating its arrival. So far Sony was been loathe to even talk about it publicly.

The gaming group mustn’t slip on its delivery of PlayStation 3 and Stringer promised, just as Faultline has been saying, that there is a lot more to come from the PSP. The PSP is a device that anyone else would have had to sell for about $800, but Sony gets it out for $240 including extras. It has the power to be the next mobile platform and it is ever gets a phone, even a wi-fi only phone (which is just a software upgrade as far as we can see) it will become seriously dangerous in the market and is a natural outlet for the vast video library of Sony Pictures plus MGM in its new and very successful UMD format.

Many of the PSP qualities are also promised in Sony Ericsson phones, encouraged by the recent unexpectedly good performance of the Walkman Phone.

And Stringer has put off the IPO of the financial group which includes Sony Life, Sony Assurance, and Sony Bank until fiscal year 2007 or beyond, scotching all rumors that is was about to be sold off.

Sony kicked off all of this on the day that it released a new forecast for the year (see diagram below) and the markets immediately yawned and dropped the Sony share price. If any US company had promised aggressive fixes run by a man of Stringer’s past record, the share price would have jumped, but with much of the Sony stock held in a highly skeptical and critical Japan, Sony immediately dropped a couple of dollars near to the low that it has occupied until recent PSP success.