Various reports this week confirmed what Faultline wrote last week, that the various P2P systems are in retreat and disarray following the legal decisions of the US Supreme Court and the follow up last week from the Recoding Industry Association of America.
After the June court win, and with ‘right on its side’ the RIAA has the weight of legal argument to stop any P2P that is designed to encourage the swapping of copyrighted files. The Supreme Court effectively clarified how it would treat any case referred to it by a lower court, saying that it thought that merely having lots of illegal traffic effectively constituted encouragement to break the law, and so is illegal.
One report this week from Reuters points out that WinMX had gone offline and eDonkey has closed its New York office.
Last week the RIAA said that it sent seven letters to various of the popular P2P networks, but declined to name them. Guesses suggested they might include BearShare, LimeWire, WinMX and eDonkey.
Grokster is believed to be in advanced discussion with the RIAA over clearing its name and starting life as a legitimate service, and will now fall into the waiting arms of Mashboxx which will acquire the business as part of its own legal file-sharing service. Mashboxx and rival iMesh, both want to become the legal havens for ex-P2P filesharers and have made overtures to most of the other P2P companies.
Both iMesh and Mashboxx will use technology that scans downloaded files and compares them with copyrighted files provided by record companies.
We said last week that our guess is that some P2P companies will go legit and others will move offshore and try to carry on. But it would be relatively simple to block them from US viewing once they are deemed illegal, and then take the fight to Europe and the rest of the world to finally close them down. The advertisers that keep all of these services in play are mostly in the US, so that should kill off most of the rest.
On the subject of Bit-Torrent which people keep reminding us is a piece of software, not a company, this is already easy to stop since it has to direct requests to BitTorrent superhubs, which are other sites and these can be cut off or closed by legal action and it has already been the subject of dawn raids all over the world to close such sites. It is unlikely that on their own that this will be able to maintain illegal sharing.
It turns out anyway that BitTorrent may yet become a company anyway, with the software authors taking funding under the BitTorrent name from Doll Capital management to the tune of $8.75 million and offering a business model of either free content carrying advertising or paid content. So it seems that even BitTorrent, whose authors have always maintained that they were never intentionally supporting piracy, is running for the hills. The new company will be run by Ex Yahoo man Ashwin Navin and BitTorrent author Bram Cohen and it is likely that Cohen will be under pressure to adjust BitTorrent to work less well on illegal downloading, and is apparently talking to each of the superhubs about going straight and charging for copyrighted works.
One other thought is that it is possible that a technology war will ensue, with a new range of P2P systems coming out that are untraceable. But then, just how will youngsters find out about them? And almost nothing is untraceable on the internet.