Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 October 2005

Congress group pick up Broadcast Flag to run with

A number of US Congress members are beginning a movement to bring back the US Broadcast Flag. This was a system of notifying DVD recorder or VHS recorder equipment of the owners rules regarding making copies of a particular piece of broadcast TV content. The equipment vendor would then program his equipment to observe those rules.

The Broadcast Flag was mandated by the FCC so that it would become illegal to sell TV equipment without software the recognized the flag, but this ruling was struck down by the US Court of Appeals in May this year, saying the FCC did not have the right to impose a new law.

There is an argument that says that if content owners choose to include the Flag, then it might qualify as a form of content protection and equipment suppliers may be obliged under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act to support it. They may also choose to support it voluntarily, but no statements from any suppliers have been made since the May ruling, when many of them were happy their obligation had disappeared.

Now the Congress members are trying to bring it back by passing a new federal law to insist on the Broadcast Flag. Congress does have the power to create new laws, whereas the FCC doesn’t.

A letter from the Congressional group has gone to Fred Upton, chairman of the House of Representatives panel on Internet and commerce, to get the ball rolling.

The Motion Picture Association of America has been lobbying Congress to reinstate the scheme and this looks like the lobbying had paid off.