Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 October 2005

TiVo’s NDS Nemesis approaches, as EchoStar court case opens

TiVo is a clever company, we don’t doubt it, but there are dark days ahead for sure. Investors are a fairly simple bunch. Will TiVo’s quarterly revenue disappear when DirecTV begins shipping its own DVR, or will it just lose growth percentage points? And what will that do to its share price. If revenues do tail off it’s going to be tough for TiVo to survive past February.

We will find out soon enough, but the answer is fairly obvious. The NDS designed DVRs do not carry any contingent liability with them when they ship. Customers get charged $5.99 a month for the TiVo service and TiVo gets a small portion of that around $1.13, and customers will be charged the same amount for the new service, but TiVo gets none of that.

The first thing that is going to happen is that TiVo is going to stop getting 60% plus of its new customers. The second thing is that DirecTV is going to conduct a huge advertising campaign (spending $30 million) to get people either to take out their new DVR or to switch from TiVo (so that DirecTV costs go down). Currently TiVo has 2.3 million DirecTV customers, so that’s $2.6 million a month that is under threat. That revenue cannot disappear overnight, because these clients are on annual contracts, but as they come up for renewal, they could erode.

Given that TiVo is currently spending money like water in order to drive up its subscriptions, this could leave TiVo with an awful 4th quarter, unprofitable and virtually out of money.

There are two ways that investors can respond. They can let the price go into freefall, or hold it and wait for the result of the TiVo versus Echostar patent trial, which has just come to court this week.

Of course the trial is likely to be over before TiVo ever reports any quarter which has lower DirecTV revenue in, so effectively the trial decides the future of the company. Of course appeals can drag on for years.

The TiVo patents are what’s at risk here. EchoStar bought Eldon a UK set top and DVR design house before the turn of the century, and has engineered all of its set tops, including DVRs, in-house. That team and the rest of its engineers have been saying that what TiVo does is ‘just common sense,’ and did not deserve to get patented.

Given the history of US patent law, with companies like Acacia drawing down licenses for claiming it invented streaming, and the Freeney patent for downloading, holding on to suspect patents, the TiVo patents are likely to stick.

The patents are largely TiVo’s original ‘Trickplay’ patent that enables DVRs to pause live TV as well as rewind, fast-forward, play, play faster, play slower and the Goldwasser patent which covers simultaneous recording and playback of video material. Others include the ‘TimeWarp’ patent for synchronizing of the various multimedia streams.

There may be some prior art out there, but TiVo has patent applications for things like ‘smart’ recording techniques, that learn what customers want to record, and they will almost certainly stand the test.

So how much might that be worth if TiVo wins it? Given that its technology licenses have never been worth more than $20 million a time, then even with damages tripled this could be set as low as $60 million. On the other hand, EchoStar has perhaps made billions out of having this technology, so that could play a factor if TiVo won.

The best outcome for TiVO would be if EchoStar had to take a permanent license to TiVo but ended up, offering to replace DirecTV as the main customer for TiVo and drive up sales. If the case is looking like it is heading for a pro-TiVo result, that could be a distinct possibility for some rapid, behind the doors negotiations.

The other upside for TiVo is that if EchoStar has to pay a patent license, then so do all the other companies who currently use or supply equipment that is not licensed. The reason that EchoStar got sued first is because it moved first and TiVo could begin calling on everyone’s door if it won the case, including its old partner DirecTV, asking for a license for the new NDS designed equipment.

Of course, EchoStar would appeal the decision, and delay the inevitable, and that could potentially force TiVo into the hands of a friendly suitor for a takeover, perhaps one of its overseas equipment licensees. We once suggested Apple should do this, and said it was only for the intellectual property, and we still think that makes a good fit. Add Apple design know how to the TiVo patents and it could be supremely compelling.