Earlier in September we wrote that new support for HomePlug from Sony, Intel, Cisco and Motorola was enhancing HomePlug’s chances of becoming a standard in the home, but after talking to Spanish chipmaker DS2 this week we’re not so sure.
DS2 has now shipped 100,000 chips offering Powerline Communications, and claims that it can deliver 200 Mbps, which Homeplug is still only talking about right now, and says it already transports multiple video streams around a home.
Early experiences with HomePlug equipment were found not to be able to sustain a permanent data link, were prone to interference from motors used in the home and still continue to interfere with Ham radio.
And while Homeplug is trying to address all that the Universal Powerline Association (UPA) has begun to spread word about its alternative approach to the technology. Members of UPA include Ambient in the US, Ascom, Corinex Communications, DS2, Itochu, Ilevo, Sumitomo and Toyo Network Systems.
UPA adapters contain notch filters to reduce the interference with ham radio broadcast frequencies, support user-configurable QoS (quality of service) and offer TripleDES encryption so that neighbors can’t listen in on communications.
Actual UPA technology is being driven primarily by just one chip maker, DS2 so we asked it this week what’s different about its approach to Power Line Communications.
Lance Watson, a spokesman for DS2 told us, ‘We use OFDM and HomePlug uses Ethernet. The underlying issue with IEEE 802.3 is that it uses CDMA/CD (carrier sense multiple access with collision detection), and that means it’s fine for sending one TV signal around the house, but when you want to get two signals sending simultaneously you get collisions.’
When a CSMA/CD carrier gets a collision both sources wait a random period of time and then both try to send again.
‘What happens is that you keep getting repeated collisions and on the TV that means lost packets and increased packet sizes, and the whole thing slows down until you have pixellation on your TV, every 30 seconds or so.’
‘At least one of our clients, Telefonica, tried this technology and threw it out and took UPA instead.
‘The other thing wrong with Homeplug is that it is still an 85 Mbps carrier. It is going to 200 Mbps and that may allow it to carry two TV channels simultaneously, but it still needs to go to chip design, sampling and testing, and with the best will in the world, there will be no 200 Mbps Homeplug silicon before third quarter 2006. And by that time we’ll have our second generation silicon out.
‘But our technology isn’t just a home network solution. We can be used for last mile access and for moving data around a home. Telefonica is using our chips to deliver a 3 Mbps broadband service to homes in the South of Spain.
A Metropolitan Area Network is established by linking either the medium voltage segment (11 kilovolts) of a City Grid or the low voltage segment (230 to 110 volts), to a backhaul source, using either fiber or wireless fiber.
If it’s the medium voltage segment, the signal then hops across to the low voltage segment with more DS2 repeaters and then is delivered right out of the plug into homes. ‘There are anywhere between 50 and 350 homes on a single low voltage segment, so these can all share 200 Mbps. In the US, where power tends to be carried on overhead cables (in Europe they are mostly in the ground) and where they have very spread out rural locations, there can be as few as 15 homes on a low voltage segment,’ said Watson. ‘Think of it as being analogous to WiMAX,’ said Watson.
The way the technology works is that hundreds of OFDM (orthogonal frequency division multiplexing) carriers are set up between 2 MHz and 34 MHz on a power line, each delivering part of the data. This makes it easy to allocate some of the carriers to one function and some to another, making QoS simpler to put in place.
In may Opera (Open PLC European Research Alliance) an EC funded body, published the baseline technology choice for its forthcoming Power line standard and it was based on this same OFDM technique, backed by 35 companies and universities in Europe.
The UPA has opened discussions the HomePlug Alliance, and OPERA, and consumer electronics manufacturers including the CE Power line Communication Alliance (CEPCA).
The technology is not only used in DS2’s native Spain, but so far has found favor in Endesa in Brazil, Schneider Electric in Switzerland and is on trial at Con Edison in the US.
Equipment makers that use the DS2 chips include Ambient, Ascom and Mitsubishi.
Now the UPA and the more powerful HomePlug Power line Alliance, will fight it out in the IEEE P1901 standards committee that was convened this Summer to decide on an IEEE last mile power standard which is not expected for over a year.